Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

Posts

Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#1

Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

It's a dog eat dog world out there. It's tough enough to make a buck in the furniture biz in these parts. So the last thing I needed was more competition. Maybe I'll need a gimmick to compete...free coasters?


The Competition

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#2

"We have . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

. . . the furniture items that will make your trailer the envy of the entire park."

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#3

It could be worse

Henry Higginbotham

Remember when nearly all of this sort of stuff was painted "country blue"? You'd never sell anything again.


Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#4

Now yer in truble....

John in NM

Time to start painting saws? Or maybe that is passe....

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#5

bet you would be surprised at their P&L

Dick Coers

I'm thinking that in Central IL, they are doing quite well. Bang it out, and make the cash quickly. Not at all interesting for me, but they may have found the niche to make money, bottom line.

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#6

Re: bet you would be surprised at their P&L

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Probably true. They probably pay for a vacation home in Key West with just the sales of that stuff.

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#7

Maybe i could interest them in a Supersurfacer


Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#8

Re: Looks Like I have competition

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Maybe you should think about using some of that nice milk paint veneer instead of that crappy cherry stuff you like so much. Gotta keep up with the Clampetts.

Robin

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#9

Re: Looks Like I have competition

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Robin,

Thanks for the inspiration. I've got some old latex house paint. Now I finally know what to do with it! There is a house getting built down the street. I wonder if they would trade their cutoffs for some of my curly cherry? Fingers crossed.

T.

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#10

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Probably not.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

It would go against the builders' Man Laws to use a fruity wood. You're probably better off just turning that curly cherry into stir sticks for that latex paint. The curl of the cherry will help mix the paint.

Jason

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#11

Re: Probably not.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Come to think of it, most wood would be better painted. So many colors.

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#12

YIKES !


Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#13

I'm your competition

Clementine

I wondered where it went. It was stolen out of my shed the night before I was going to put casters and a chicken decal on it.

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#14

Re: Looks Like I have competition

Jay St. Peter

My wife shopped the competition. There's a place nearby that is only open one or two Saturdays a month. So she tells me she's going with her friends who all rave about the place and go every month. She tells me they sell "antique style" stuff and it's cheap. She comes home with a step stool ($20) and some "hooks" to hang on the wall near the door for the kids backpacks ($5 each).

So, I take the "hooks", which are basically pegs attached to a piece of 3" x 4"ish (none were the same) 1-by pine (their only material I think) with a hole in it. You're supposed to hang it with a nail through the hole, then hang things on it. But, nothing was centered so they hung askew and fell apart when something heavier than a feather was hung on it. I of course grumbled about them as I was hanging them.

So, she says that the step stool is much better. It was, but that's not saying much. It was again 1-by pine, but at least cut straight and consistent. I couldn't tell the joinery, but did see there were some finish nails shot into the top. It was painted black and didn't look too bad. A couple weeks later, I found out the "joinery" was the finish nails. Looked to be exactly 2 18-gauge finish nails shot into each piece that intersected another. No glue or other mechanical fasteners. I pulled it apart and reassembled with pocket holes where I could and black drywall screws where they had to show. Still using it, but she hasn't been back to "the competition". Don't think she wants to hear what I think of their stuff again.

Even with the poor quality, I don't see how it is profitable to sell the foot stool for $20. There is still materials plus cutting, routing, nailing and painting in it. Not a bad price for a pre-finished foot stool kit. Even the "hooks" for $5 don't seem like they could be very profitable. Each random sized part was cut, routed, and painted.

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#15

Re: Looks Like I have competition

Barry Irby

There was a guy at the last "Craft" show (a very loose term) I attended. He made little heart shaped tables out of pine shelving boards. The top was about the largest heart you could get out of a 1 x 12, there were three sort of serpentine legs and a lower smaller heart about 6" across that served as a stretcher. Fairly nicely sanded and left raw. Rounded over edges every where. $7 Then there was the painted version. White with a ivy vine running down two legs and across the top. $14. He told me he had somebody paint them for him. I still can't figure out how he made any money, even if he got the wood for free. I decided I would rather be the guy painting them.

My MIL bought a step stool from a similar place. Just one step about 7" high. Nearly killed her. The "legs" were set too far back and when she stepped too near the end, it shot out from under her. I built her a much safer one.

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#16

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Batch production

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...would be the only way to make any sort of profit on these kinds of things at those prices.

Sure, if you consider all the head-scratching, set-up time, tool change-over, part-making, assembly, finishing and clean up time to make ONE of these items, you'd probably lose money at $200 per. But, if you leave your shop set up to only crank out those items, and make hundreds of parts at one time, handling each part for only a few seconds for any given step of the process, you do have a shot at making money selling small stools and such for $10-20 each.

But, I'll agree, that the cost of materials would have to be pretty cheap, and you'd have to have hobby tools that you've already paid for. It also wouldn't hurt if you already had residual income, no mortgage, no other debt, etc. It's probably just a way for these guys to earn a little bit while keeping themselves out of more expensive trouble (like other, more expensive hobbies).

Jason

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#17

Re: Batch production

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"It's probably just a way for these guys to earn a little bit while keeping themselves out of more expensive trouble (like other, more expensive hobbies)."

And perhaps out from under their wives' feet, thus leading to marital harmony.

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#18

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Batch production

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I wasn't going to go there, as I couldn't reach the shovel I had already decided to toss out of the hole this morning. :D

Jason

Re: Looks Like I have competition *LINK*

#19

Re: Batch production

Gabe Doyle

Back in the 80's, when this stuff was more in fashion, my grandfather owned a small factory that turned out this type of furniture by the truckload. It was all knotty pine - butt joints, biscuits, and finish nails - slapped together quickly and sold unfinished to be distressed, painted, and re-distressed later.

Funny enough, one small chest of drawers from that place ended up in my mom's garage, and I confiscated it when my wife and I bought our first house almost 15 years ago. I stripped the paint and put a couple coats of poly on it. Somehow the thing managed to survive various moves and is currently in my four-year-old's room (having already been through two older kids). The drawers fit horribly and jam every time they're opened, but somehow those glued and nailed drawers are still solid as the day they were made. Every time I see a dovetailed drawer mounted on low-friction ball bearing drawer slides, I think about that old junky, slapped together, solid little chest of drawers. I think it's going to take a sledge hammer to break it up for kindling if we're ever through with it.