Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

De-stressing Lumber

Posts

De-stressing Lumber

#1

Jim in Burlington Ont.

De-stressing Lumber

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I was reading the recent FWW and came across Steve Latta's article on making flat doors. I have long used quarter sawn wood when I can for door stiles and rails in my designs, but Steve mentions a process he uses before dimensioning his lumber, he drops it on a hard floor to de-stress the wood. This is a new idea for me, not sure my take on it but I can understand the stress release potential mechanically doing this, but not quite 100% on it. Do any of you out there also use this process?

Wondering how to evaluate this method vs others.... I usually see stress released in my work when I initially dimension wood or re-saw, I usually don't fully dimension my wood for this reason until I feel it's had time to find an equilibrium after some rough dimensioning.

Any Thoughts?

Take care,

Jim

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#2

Re: De-stressing Lumber

John Lucas

Jim I read that article and personally think that is BS. There are stresses in lumber due to the way it grows but I find it hard to believe dropping it on the floor would do anything other than dent the wood and/or maybe release some stress in the carpenter.

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#3

Re: De-stressing Lumber

Dave Bair

I also can't quite bring myself to believe the process de-stresses anything. And even if it did, why wouldn't a few blows with a rubber mallet work as well without the noise and possible contamination of dropping planks on the floor. It might be that the article is in the April issue.

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#4

JL

Re: De-stressing Lumber

JL

My initial thoughts when I read the article were that it was a bunch of hooie.

Then I thought about it. You probably put a lot of stress into wood when you rough it and kiln it. I don't know how many times I've seen wood curl in different directions after it has been sawed. Like you - I rough dimension my lumber and let it sit before final dimensioning.

How about a test? Cut a board in half. Treat half gently and cut and dimension it as quickly as possible. Use a dead blow hammer of a decent weight on the other half and give it a few solid whacks - say 5-10 along the board. Then cut and dimension it. You just have to make sure the lumber has some interesting grain patterns that mind lend themselves into going every which way.

When I split and rive lumber, I know that I'm giving it many a whack. Generally the spindles and legs I make from this lumber are straight and remain that way. But I usually choose reasonably straight grained material for splitting and riving - so I don't think that this is a fair test.

All I know is - I wouldn't drop lumber on the floor - too much of a chance of dinging it up. I would give it a few blows with a dead blow hammer - that would be somewhat gentler.

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#5

Re: De-stressing Lumber

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

I didn't read the article but from the brief description it ranks up there with the infamous board stretcher and left handed hammer (with the accompanying left handed nails). But if you insist on wanting de-stressed wood I suggest some crystals placed under your table saw, or for truly relaxed wood perhaps a prescription for some medical marijuana.

Robin

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#6

Hoo---ieee!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I tried them crystals, din't do a thang; what a rip-off.

But the Pyramid Tent, now that bad boy works ever time. Sharpens chisels and razors as well and keeps bread fresh for a month or more (if you get the right one a course) :D

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#7

Re: De-stressing Lumber

HC Sakman

Hi Jim,

"Hard floor" did not make any sense to me at all, sorry I didn't read the article. What's this about? Straitining the bowed board or....?

If so, I don't think anything works for deformed lumber other than milling and even then it may still not work. Appearantly, trees growing on slopes are the most difficult to tame, then again that is impossible to know ahead of time unless you know the tree before it is cut.

Chico

PS: For the same reason, large branches that lean in one direction is only good for firewood, not lumber no matter how big the diameter is.

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: De-stressing Lumber

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Not sure Chico,

I prefer jack pine, always buggy and crisp, no strain, LOL

Take care,

Jim

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#9

Someone is pulling your hockey stick.


Re: De-stressing Lumber

#10

Re: De-stressing Lumber

HC Sakman

He probably pissed of that good looking board is out of shape and he is getting his frustration out of it by throwing it on the floor... Good luck. This technique may de-stress the woodworker, but not the deformed lumber.

I think they are running out of article topics and trying to be creative.

Chico

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#11

JL

The board stretcher....

JL

one such example is in the Infancy Gospel of Thomas - "And Joseph did as the child said to him. And Jesus stood at the other end, and took hold of the shorter piece of wood, and stretched it, and made it equal to the other."

But as we have no chance of divine intervention in our shops - we have to measure several times before we cut - and make sure we have a long enough piece to begin with.

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#12

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: De-stressing Lumber

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Who Knows Chico... I've bit on a few things...but as I get more grey hair I wonder sometimes what to do if there's no "app" for that.. or so my child tells me "I'm weird"...LOL >> God Is Great, Beer Is Good and People are Crazy....

Take care,

Jim

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#13

Measure, Cut . . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey


Re: De-stressing Lumber

#14

Alan Young

I'd try Heavy Electricity   *LINK*


Heavy Electricity

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#15

Re: De-stressing Lumber

Michael Wilkins

I always destress my lumber after I make a mistake and cut a piece too short, put a mortise in the wrong place or some other dumb mistake. Then I take the board and slam it to the concrete, usually with a couple of words that I will not print here. Works every time.

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#16

Re: De-stressing Lumber

Thomas S Stockton

I usually just make sure it has a nice comfortable place to rest and give it a couple of beers or a medicinal margarita.

Tom

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#17

Cold Reason Wins Out

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I don't much care about the stress thing. I simply address the board, in a reasonable way of course, and give it a simple choice.

"Yo, youz can keep your damn stress to yourself, behave like a proper board, and be incorporated into this fine piece of furniture that will be cherished and cared for for generations, or you can get slammed on the floor, walked on until you've lost all identity, and then be fed to the termites. So, what's it gonna be, eh?

Noo, problem. Works every time.

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#18

FWW April Fool Issue?


Re: De-stressing Lumber

#19

Soak it in beer?

John in NM

That does de-stress me after all :D

Before I say anything too sarcastic, I'll just reflect that Jess probably has it right :D

Of course if you want to check the process, you can carefully gauge the straightness of boards before you drop them. If the action releases stress, the board probably will have moved - like it does when you cut such a board on the table saw.

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#20

I understand you can use the same seasoning,

Keith Newton

for Bologna to make Summer Sausage, but I prefer the SS. This seems like Bologna to me.

However, anytime that I'm making something which I want to depend on for strength, but the wood is suspect, I will give it a hard whack to see if it will break. I'd rather it break then, rather than later.

I used that trick this past week. I'm helping a cousin re-build a cabin next to ours down on the creek. Sent him to town for materials. One of the rafters he came back with, had big knots on both edges. I whacked it on the floor, and it broke, so rather than using it for a rafter, it will be cut into shorter lengths for blocking or other short parts.

I'm not sure if breaking a board is the same as relieving it of stress though, unless psychologically it wanted to be two, rather than one.

Re: De-stressing Lumber

#21

De-stressing or Distressing ???

Don Orr

I have not seen the article yet but from reading the above is he actually talking about relaxing the internal stresses in a board or putting in some dents and dings to make it look aged?

Hard to believe tension or compression of reaction wood would be eliminated by this method. Maybe he's just throwing it on the floor in frustration after it bound up on the table saw. :\