Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

rosewood?

Posts

rosewood?

#1

rosewood?

John Garcia

Hi I'm wondering anyone can recognize this wood I believe it to be rosewood.I bought this house in the country and it came with the house,The house is over 100 years old and the woman I bought it from said it was here when she was a kid.

She now deceased from old age.


img

Re: rosewood?

#2

Re: rosewood?

John Garcia

Heres another shot where it shows the size of this thing.


img

Re: rosewood?

#3

Re: rosewood?

William Duffield

From here, it looks like southern yellow pine. The determination depends to a certain extent on what part of the world you are in, because, guessing from the quality of the cabinets, it was most probably a locally sourced wood. It might be white pine or SPF with lots of yellow varnish on it, or even Douglas fir, if you are on the left coast. It is definitely not a rosewood, or any other hardwood, for that matter.

Re: rosewood?

#4

Dale Lenz

Agree

Dale Lenz

Southern yellow pine or Doug fir. Looks like the cabinets in my mother's house, circa 1955 and her cabinet are DF.

Re: rosewood?

#5

Re: Agree

John Garcia

Ok thanks.The reason I thought it was rosewood was I had to trim a piece and it had perfume smell to it aas well as being very dense.

Also the wood has been here when the house was built in 1910 located in south east TX.

Re: rosewood?

#6

good old pine


Re: rosewood?

#7

Interesting construction

Yonak

It looks as though the panel may have been attached after the rails and stiles were put together because of the routing pattern. That would have been quite a large router bit.

Also, the wavy apron (curtain ?) above the windows is very interesting.

Re: rosewood?

#8

Re: Agree

William Duffield

That's the clue we needed. It's SYP. Doug Fir and White Pine have almost no odor, but SYP is full of resins and smells strongly of turpentine. Also, white pine and SPF (framing lumber) are much less dense than yellow pine.

Re: rosewood?

#9

Odor....

John in NM

Many old closets and cabinets have a perfumey smell due to long time use of air fresheners.

Rosewood smells more like incense than perfume to me, I never quite figured out why the smell would be connected with the name. Might even say that old saw I've read everywhere doesn't pass the smell test :D

I agree that it is probably yellow pine or maybe douglas fir. Panels look more like fir (rotary cut plywood) than the frames, they look a bit more like pine.

Re: rosewood?

#10

Dale Lenz

Age of cabinets

Dale Lenz

Just my best guess the cabinet are circa late 1940~1950. IIRC plywood was not readily available until after WWII. My mother's cabinet, house built 1955, had the same pulls back in the day, except they might of been bronze or brass plated.

Re: rosewood?

#11

Re: rosewood?

Terry Quiram

It is beyound a doubt Southern Yellow Pine.

Re: rosewood?

#12

Re: Age of cabinets

John Garcia

The woman I bought the house was in her 80s that was 10 years ago she told me that the cabnets were there when she was a kid, the house was built in 1910.

Also as far as the pattern that is cut it would seem a bit dificult to cut without it breaking the wood if it was pine or a soft wood.

Also I checked the bottom drawers and they are dovetailed.

Re: rosewood?

#13

Re: rosewood?

John Garcia

Thanks I have to agree with yellow pine thanks.

Re: rosewood?

#14

Ellis Walentine

I vote for yellow pine


Re: rosewood?

#15

Re: I vote for yellow pine

John Garcia

Heres a Ebay sell of rosewood and heres a closer look at mine.

http://i716.photobucket.com/albums/ww162/jag4575/possible-rosewood_zpsc9048d0d.jpg

http://i716.photobucket.com/albums/ww162/jag4575/rosewood-ebay_zps4e388aab.jpg

Either way Im not taking this foroum as the absolute difinitive answer.If it turns out its not rose wood I look at it on the bright side,I started out with nothing and I still have a little left over:)

Re: rosewood?

#16

JL

Re: rosewood?

JL

Reality check.

Even back then - rosewood was quite expensive in comparison. You might use rosewood as a wood in high end furniture - but not in cabinets.

Rosewood is also fairly hard. Southern yellow pine (or Douglas fir) would be typically used for houses and cabinets. Inexpensive, relatively easy to work with - unlike rosewood.

Re: rosewood?

#17

Ellis Walentine

Let us know how you make out

Ellis Walentine

John, I'm flattered that you came to WoodCentral for advice, but I'm not happy that you are so dismissive of the replies you've gotten. You're talking to hundreds of years of collected experience here. If you don't respect us, maybe you should try a couple empirical tests to satisfy yourself that your wood isn't rosewood.

For example, try pushing your fingernail into the lighter colored grain of your cabinet doors. See how easily you are able to put a dent into the wood. With rosewood, you wouldn't be able to even begin to dent it.

Another little test you might try is to take one of the doors off and carefully calculate the volume of wood there, then weigh it and calculate the density. You will find that the density of your cabinet wood is around 25-30 lb/ft3. Rosewood of any species will have a density in excess of 50 lb/ft3.

And, regarding the photobucket pix you showed us, note that your wood is yellowish in hue, while the rosewood is reddish/purplish. This isn't merely an irrelevant anomaly.

If you really want to invest more effort in this exercise, cut off a sliver of your wood and send it to the Forest Products Laboratory in Madison, Wisconsin. For a fee, they will identify it positively for you. Let us know what they have to say.

Cheers,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: rosewood?

#18

Re: Let us know how you make out

John Garcia

Ellis I had in the previous post agreed that this was probably yellow pine however Im not going take peoples advise as the gospel.

You people seem to have issues with this other person posting my dieing breath,The fact is if you read my previous posts I did not disrepected anyone.

Simply because your on this foroum does not make you an expert.This is my last post on this pos foroum.

Re: rosewood?

#19

Pay no mind to David....

John in NM

He enjoys being whimsical, and will often point those same barbs at himself :D Best response to David is a jest in reply, he enjoys those too.

One of those instances where the words and joke would be taken quite differently if said in person, preferably over drinks in a noisy bar :D

Re: rosewood?

#20

Re: rosewood?

Larry in nw ohio

John I would even bet that would be Pine, and probably Southern. I worked with pine for over 30 years, when I was doing that nasty thing. That has the all around look of it. But the way I think, if I think something is what I think it is, that is what it is untill someone proves me wrong without a doubt. Good Luck with your project. Larry in NW Ohio

Re: rosewood?

#21

Re: rosewood?

John Garcia

Here are my thoughts I live in a rural area the house I live in was built in 1910 I suspect that the lumber was used from the property.

Here are some pictures of what I beleive to be rosewood trees.

http://i716.photobucket.com/albums/ww162/jag4575/006_zpsb8349a4a.jpg

http://i716.photobucket.com/albums/ww162/jag4575/004_zpseb27ed4b.jpg


img

Re: rosewood?

#22

Re: rosewood?

John Garcia

I forgot to mention on the leaf pictures do a search for rosewood tree leafs.

Re: rosewood?

#23

Re: rosewood?

Keith Newton

John, I have been a professional furniture-maker / designer for 40 years, and worked all kinds of rosewood. It appears to me that your wood is Pine, and that is the only answer you will get from anyone with any knowledge of wood. I don't care what forum you choose to show it on.

Re: rosewood?

#24

100% rosewood

Mark Hennebury

Don't listen to this small minded bunch, they are just jealous.

Its beautiful rosewood, and fine cabinetwork.

By the way if you want any more rosewood, i can get you truckloads; its about twice the price of that yellow pine crap, but hey its rosewood.

Re: rosewood?

#25

Re: Agree

C. John Hebert

yep...old fir cabinets commonly used in that era