Complicated subject...
John in NM
A lot of times, safes from places like Walmart or Costco are little more than a placebo for the buyer. Once when I was shopping for a safe the store had a display they really enjoyed showing off - a cheap safe made of 20 gauge steel and fire-brick that had been opened with an ax 
From what I understand, the best fire rated safes use drywall - gypsum is a hydrous mineral, and the inside of a well sealed gypsum lined container will not exceed the boiling temp of water until all that bound water is cooked off (the gypsum is then a mineral called anhydrite).
Still and all, for theft prevention, good camoflage is likely more effective than a safe. Best of all would be to have a really cheap, easily defeated safe with some very common rifles in it, and the valuable collectables in a hidden spot elsewhere
I'll have to remember that one if I ever have anything really valuable.