Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Problem for electranic guru`s

Posts

Problem for electranic guru`s

#1

Problem for electranic guru`s

Larry in nw ohio

My son has an electric 220V heater in his garage. He had trouble with it a couple weeks ago that it didn`t heat. He first thought it was the thermostat on the heater because some web site said that those type of heater had trouble with the thermostates. He took it apart and cleaned it and it worked for a while and then same thing. Well I went down to help, and the first thing I did was check the voltage coming in the heater. I had 110 volts on both lines, but when I tried to get 220 volts across both 110 I got nothing. So we went to the electrical panel and tried it there. Got 110 on both circuit breakers and nothing across both breakers. So we took them out and put new ones in, bingo for some reason that did it. They were new just maybe 11/2 years ago, why would the go bad in that time and what happened. I`ve had breakers for 30- 40 years in our house and never a bad one. Also why colud I get 110 on each breaker but not get 220? Larry in nw ohio

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#2

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Larry,

In my experience, provided the breaker was of the correct size and type for the job, defective electrical parts tend to fail early in their service life, so probably just a defective part. (Provided it was properly installed and of the correct rating for the task).

Why you read 110 from each leg of the breaker to gnd/neutral is that one side/leg of the breaker was closed, feeding 110 to the heater, the other breaker leg was open so you were reading the 110 from the first leg of the breaker fed back through the heater to the open leg of the breaker.

NOTE: I'm not an electrician. But have >35 years experience designing and troubleshooting electronics circuitry.

Bob in NJ

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#3

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

John McGaw

Measuring AC mains with a high-impedance meter can lead to very confusing results. What was it you were measuring with? I find it far more useful to test 'regular' AC problems with an old-school analog meter. Even a light bulb of the proper rating is more useful than a digital meter in these circumstances.

I'm curious about your reference to 'breakers'. Since this was a 240VAC circuit there should have been a single double-pole breaker. Having two separate breakers would be extremely dangerous.

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#4

Agree with John

Jay Lombardo

I agree with John, it sounds like you installed 2 single pole breakers to get your 220V circuit. This could create a dangerous situation. I would highly recommend replacing them with a 2 pole breaker. When you turn off any multi-phase circuit you Have to turn it off with a single switch, not 2 or 3 (in the case of 3 phase) individual switches. Someone could turn off 1 switch, think the device was dead because it was off but you still have live circuits there. Potentially very dangerous.

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#5

Re: Agree with John

Larry in nw ohio

Yes you guess correct. But with the way I have it, they can not turn off one without the other. I have a nail through the switch, so they both will go off. Are there any other reasons why I should not do it. I do want it safe for him. Thank You Larry

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#6

Re: Agree with John

Bill Howatt

Your nail may not be elegant but it does provide the "tie" that is necessary when using 2 single breakers for that purpose. It should not have excessive slack such that it is possible for one to trip without tripping the other.

They used to sell pins for that purpose at electrical supply stores but I don't know if they still do since molded double breakers with a single handle are common.

I disagree about the analog meter being better; it will not provide any better reading. Even a piece of junk analog meter with only a 1000 ohms/volt movement on a 250V range would have an impedance of 250K ohms. A good meter would at least 10X this. Compared to the 11 ohm impedance of a 5KW heater or the 55 ohm impedance of a 1KW heater it might as well be considered infinite too.

I do prefer an anlog meter for measuring resistance.

Bill

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#7

Re: Agree with John

John McGaw

The reason I advise against high-impedance meters of any sort when troubleshooting AC wiring is that capacitive coupling in house wiring can be so high that an open circuit will sometimes show appreciable voltage. I've never seen this happen with a cheap analog meter in the same circumstances. Alternatively, loading the circuit being measured will knock down the parasitic voltage and give a true measure of the voltage.

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#8

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

walta

How old and what brand panel is this?

Your symptom sounds like the bus bars in the panel is bad or the newer breakers don’t fit them correctly.

Some brands are fire traps and should be replaced on sight.

Walta

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#9

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

Larry in nw ohio

They are the cheaper Sq.D, I think they are made more for a house. They have the HOM on them. Thanks to all. Larry in NW Ohio

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#10

Larry, I'm working on an old cabin with the same

Keith Newton

I needed to hook up my welder down there, but couldn't get anything between hot leads, but 121 to neutral, or ground. Even checking the main lines in. It was somewhere up the line before the house.

The linemen came out, and somehow seemed to think it was a problem with the neutral, which gave me a headache trying to figure that one out.

I've bought a new meter box, weather head, and breaker panel, and they are going to bring new supply in from the transformer.

So, If you have not metered above the meter, that would be my suggestion, then you can leave the problem to the electric company to figure out, if it is out from there.

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#11

Re: Larry, I'm working on an old cabin with the sa

John McGaw

A 'real' 240VAC load doesn't even care about the neutral. It almost sounds as though the breakers involved are on the same phase, especially if you are able to feed a load from each of them separately. But whatever you do, be cautious; them ACs can sneak up and bite.

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#12

Re: Larry, I'm working on an old cabin with the sa

Larry in nw ohio

Keith Thanks for the suggestion, but I think we got it with the replacement of the two breakers. We checked everything else, and it seems to be OK. The heater is working. But still open to suggestions, always willing to learn something new. Larry in NWOhio

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#13

Re: Agree with John

Larry in nw ohio

I have the older filp open, flip closed Radio Shack anolog meter. I really like that one. I was really upset when they quite making them. I bought 4-5 of them when they were selling them out for less than half the cost. I gave my sons and SIL one and keeping the othercouple for myselp incase one quites on me. Larry

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#14

Suggestion

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hows about calling Venkman, Spengler & Stantz? :D

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#16

Thin Breakers?

Jason Waters

On the two breakers, were they "thin" breakers or "1/2" size?

If so, if you put two thin breakers side by side that are 110V breakers (not ganged) you might get 110V from each OFF the SAME leg, therefore no 220V. Unless you happen to put them in a location so they are off seperate legs (doesn't always mean same side of box).

That's why thinline breakers only work in the bottom of some breaker boxes, some thinline breakers for 220 only come in banks of 4 (I think the old Murray's were like this) to solve this issue (the wiring is rerouted internally). It varies from maker to maker. It can be maddening

I would never use two standard 110V breakers for a 220V circuit, thinline, standard or otherwise. It's not code and leads to problems like this. And is dangerous.

I also avoid thinline 220V breakers if possible (or thinlines at all if possible). But if you are out of room, buy a fullsize 220V, move it up in the box to replace a couple 110V fullsizes and use some thinline 110V breakers for those 110V fullsize breakers.

Because of all the variables mentioned and it's impossible to tell without actually seeing it, you should get a licensed electrician to look at it, it probably can be solved in short order if all the wires are there.

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#17

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

walta

Did you say the panel was new when the breakers were installed?

If you have a QO series panel I would only use QO breakers even if the label on the HOM line says it will work and I am not sure it does.

Walta

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#18

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

Larry in nw ohio

Yes the panel was new when the house was built,which was, I`m guessing here, about 10 years ago, and it is one of those prebuilt homes in a building somewhere and trucked to the location. The breakers are all the same type. Larry in NW Ohio

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#19

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

JoeW in Detroit

In your post you mention "circuit breakers". Are you using 2 single pole breakers instead of a double pole breaker? If you are using 2 single pole breakers are they stacked on top of one another. If they is a space between them or multiple spaces between them, you may be on the same phase on both leads.

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

#20

Re: Problem for electranic guru`s

Larry in nw ohio

They are stacked one on top of the other, and I`m getting 220 out of them. Thank You. Larry