Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Dust Masks

Posts

Dust Masks

#1

Dust Masks

Chuck Jurvelin

I know this subject has been brought up a number of times on Wood Central and I have read the old

messages. Does anyone have a recommendation on the best dust mask that actually filters the dust properly, fits comfortably, and doesn't fog your glasses? I sometimes wear a mask for long periods of time in the shop and find most of the masks I've used to be uncomfortable and fog my glasses.

Thank you for your input.

Re: Dust Masks

#2

Re: Dust Masks

GolfSteve in Calgary

If you don't want fogging of your glasses then you need a mask that fits well around the nose and cheeks to prevent leakage. I find an exhalation valve is essential. The fit will be different for every person.

This is my current preference for around the shop: http://www.leevalley.com/us/wood/page.aspx?p=62081&cat=1,42207

At work, where the dust concentrations are much higher, I use a silicone half-mask respirator with dust pre-filters and organic vapour cartridges. Works very well, but is bulky.

Re: Dust Masks

#3

Concur on the exhalation valve

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That's been what made the most difference for me; the valve encourages the air to flow out far from my glasses, instead of around the edges of the mask.

You can get N95 disposables at the big boxy stores. If you're getting a better mask, with replaceable filters, consider going to a safety supply store and getting it fitted.

And, of course, if you have a beard, you'll probably need a positive pressure system with a face shield and air being pumped into it through a filter.

Re: Dust Masks

#4

alternative

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

My frugalness is legendary. However, after decades of woodworking I bought an Oneida dust collection cyclone for the shop. I wish I had been less frugal and bought it years earlier. It solves the dust problem. Haven't used a dust mask since and I don't miss them.

I sand and route out doors on horses when weather permits.

Re: Dust Masks

#5

Fogging of the glasses fogging is a sign ...

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

My opinion....

Fogging of the glasses fogging is a sign ... that air moves around the mask. If it moves that way on the exhale, it is likely to be able to do on the inhale half of the cycle too. Now I understand that on the inhale cycle the mask will be pulled against your face, but I think the point remains. If air leaks around the mask, doesn't that defeat the whole purpose?

I suspect that these mask certainly provide some level of filtering, and the certainly are better than nothing, but if you are going to bother putting on a dust mask, why not go to a real solution? The half mask respirators are not cheap, but they are also not very expensive. in the long term they are WAY more effective (although I have no 'proof" of that), and in hobbiest use they will last for years.

I couldn't ever recommend a solution like a disposable mask for in shop use - most of us are in this hobby for the long term and a half-mask respirator is definitely a worthwhile investment (< $50??).

Henry

Re: Dust Masks

#6

Testing fit

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Every time I put on my half-mask respirator, I cover the exhalation valve and inhale sharply. If the mask collapses against my face, I've got a seal. Takes ten seconds, reassures me.

Re: Dust Masks

#7

Re: alternative

Larry in nw ohio

Bill I`m courious as to what kind of DC setup you have, do you have any pics? Sorry to be so nosey, but I`m always courious as to other types of setups other people have? While I`m at it, I would really like seeing anyone else that would like to post. Larry

Re: Dust Masks

#8

Re: Dust Masks *LINK*

Dave Bair

The "Resp-O-Rator" works with glasses and beards but does require a mouthpiece and a nose plug.


Resp-O-Rator

Re: Dust Masks

#9

Same here

John in NM

Its that little valve that makes a big difference. I get the disposable 3M ones with the valve from Home Depot and they work fine for several uses before tossing them out.

I started using those on GolfSteve's recommendation incidentally :D

Re: Dust Masks

#10

DC design

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Oneida designed it and that is the route I would suggest anyone take unless they are an expert in fluid mechanics. It has a blower and cyclone and final filter. Suction pipe startes out 7" and necks down as it goes ending in 5" gated flexible drops to machines.

Re: Dust Masks

#11

JL

Re: Dust Masks

JL

First line of defense - cyclone or shop vacuum

Like Bill, I have an Oneida Cyclone - I use it most of the time. In the instances when I'm not using the cyclone (typically when I'm using the router or my ROS) - I'm using my shop vacuum.

Next line of defense - air cleaner

Helps to trap all the rest.

Final line of defense - N95 dust mask - with or without valves. I usually buy the ones w/o valves. I do have a half face and a full face respirator that I use for when I'm spraying nasty chemicals or using bad solvents. I also use it when I'm working with somewhat nasty woods like cocobolo.

Re: Dust Masks

#12

If I recall correctly...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...someone tested that design and found it marginal.

Re: Dust Masks

#13

Re: Dust Masks

Chuck Jurvelin

Thank you for all the info. I have been woodworking for fifty-plus years and have probably inhaled way more pollutants than anyone should, but I am

always looking for a more effective solution. I have a complete dust collection

system including dust collection to my sanders, etc. I still believe in wearing a mask when creating fine particles. I am going to take Steve's advice and try the mask from Lee Valley. I have been using the 3M N95 masks for years, but do not think they are that effective. Again, Thank You !

Re: Dust Masks

#14

Re: Dust Masks

Jesse Cloud

Just FYI, here's the meaning of the NIOSH filtering standards:

N=not mist resistant, R=mist resistant, P=mist proof. 95=95% efficient, 100=HEPA filter or 99.97% effective. All percentages are rated to 0.3 microns.

So N95 means no filtering for vapors and filters 95 per cent of particles 3 microns and larger.

Best thing to do is to catch the dust before it gets in the air. I sand with a sander designed for dust collection (not a clumsy accessory) attached to a vac with a HEPA filter.

Re: Dust Masks

#15

Re: Dust Masks

Lars Parrington

i think you meant to say 95% of particles 0.3 microns and larger. an N95 mask should capture 100% of particles 1 micron and larger.