Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

How much will gravity help this DC?

Posts

How much will gravity help this DC?

#1

How much will gravity help this DC?

Henry Higginbotham

A friend of mine (really, it's not me, though I sure wish it was) is nearing completion of an enviable detatched home shop: 28x40x10H, with a full basement with 8.7' clearance to the floor joists above. We planned to place the dust collector in the basement, generally centered with a bit of offset to the rear where most of the machinery will reside on the top floor.

The flooring upstairs is a low grade of red oak and the plan is to run the piping through the floor and to the collector. Gravity should help a good bit--there may be some horizontal runs upstairs, but no lifts. Max run might be 25 feet if all goes well. And just one machine at a time.

No dust collector has yet been acquired; he's looking for a good deal on a used unit. 1.5hp cyclones come up occasionally on Craigslist. With the help of gravity, would this be workable for that size floor above? Some of the more volume-needy machines might be located nearer the collector, but still . . . . Thoughts?

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

#2

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

Dick Coers

You really have to give us some details. What size thickness planer is the biggest question. A shaper? What size jointer? Those are the big guns. Gravity won't do squat to get the chips out of a machine, where the air flow is really critical.

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

#3

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

Henry Higginbotham

Planer probably 15". Jointer is 8". Probably no shaper.

My experience with jointers is that they need a lot of flow to get the fine dust, which seems to escape from about 853 places on my old Rockwell 8" when the DC isn't on.

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

#4

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

Brian from Monument

When i was setting up my shop, I contacted Oneida and sent them a drawing of my shop and how my ducting would be run. They made some real suggestions.

One of the most critical is that the static pressure drop is not too high at the machine.

This really IIRC is determined by the effective length of the duct run.

Each elbow weighs in as several feet of length.

The diameter of the elbow is also important.

Most important is the diameter of the ducts.

With 25 ft runs you may need a 3 hp and use something like if not greater than 6 inch ducts.

Remember that this is not like a bulit in vacumn system.

good luck and I hope your system really sucks (those wood chips).

(IIRC it is really more like blowing them through the ducts.)

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

#5

JL

Re: How much will gravity help this DC? *LINK*

JL

IMO - depending on the total length of piping - you would need at least a 2 hp cyclone - possibly a 3 hp cyclone.

Go for 6" mains, reducing at the end to 4" to go to the tools.

The guru is Bill Pentz. Go to his site. He's done all the work.


Bill Pentz

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

#6

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

Larry in nw ohio

Henry IMO for what it`s worth, I have a 24x24 shop in my basement and have an Oneida 3HP Industrial DC. What they mean by industrial, I have no idea, and I`m glad I didn`t go any smaller. It does a great job, even on the SCMS. So I would suggest nothing smaller than 3HP. I have a friend that has a 1 1/2HP Oneida and has a shop smaller than your friend, and is wishing he had a bigger unit. So I would give Oneida a call and see what they say. Good Luck to you and your friend. Larry In NW Ohio

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

#7

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Doubt gravity will have much effect at all. The biggest issue is getting the fine dust and shavings out of the air and machine into the piping. That takes air flow. I have a 3 hp Grizzly Cyclone (great machine) in my 30 X 30 shop. When running the 20" planer I need to shut off almost all the other gates to pick up the "fines". One thing not discussed is how he is going to handle the shavings when he empties the collector. I know I have to work to empty mine at ground level. The 55 gallon drum is a bear to handle alone and I can fill it more than once a day if I am planing a lot. I would certainly hate to have to move it "upstairs" to empty.

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

#8

I agree, contact Oneida

Merle

I am one of the very few people that bought a WoodSucker (Anybody remember them?). It is a 2 HP and wasn't really doing the job for me. I have the usual compliment of tools-TS, 8"jointer, 15" planer, drum sander, SCMS, BS, router table. I was looking at 2 of Oneida's units and couldn't decide which would be adequate for my needs. I sent a diagram of the shop & tools to Oneida and the support tech offered 4 suggestions to improve the performance of the existing WoodSucker even though I was ready to buy a new machine from them. I implemented the suggestions and didn't need to buy a new DC. If the WoodSucker ever dies, I will buy an Oneida.

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

#9

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

Jason Waters

I have a 1.5 HP Oneida. If I did it again, I would build a Bill Pentz design or buy one. 3hp or more. The 1.5 HP Oneida is barely adequate (maybe not even) for what I do. I have nothing exotic, 10" table saw, bandsaw, 12" planer, 6" jointer.

Ductwork is a huge issue. don't skimp and go too small. I originally did this and ended up redoing it and it helped a lot but now I wish I had bigger.

At the time, the Oneida was one of a few cyclone units available at the hobby level I'll say. And probably one of the better ones that was available (I say probably because I never saw too many of the competition in the flesh). I have no issues with the build quality, it just needs to be bigger. I don't think any 1.5 hp is enough.

Jason

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

#10

Re: I agree, contact Oneida

Larry in nw ohio

I agree. If I would need another DC, I would deffinetly go to Oneida. When I was looking, I called Oneida and asked them about piping and they wanted to sell me their steel pipe but I was fixed on the S&W pvc., they of course still tried to sell me the steel, I don`t blame them because that is their buisness. But I stuck with the PVC. But they still made plans for me. They are a good group over there. Larry

Re: How much will gravity help this DC?

#11

Thanks, all

Henry Higginbotham

We're digesting all the advice and information.