Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

12 inch SCMSIn

Posts

12 inch SCMSIn

#1

12 inch SCMSIn

Rocky rctools

In the market to buy a new saw as my 10 inch Makita has seen many hours and bumps...Very good deal on The 12 inch Milwakee with stand and radio for 699 Canadian at Home Depot...was gonna get a 12 inch Makita or a Dewalt but heard not great things about them...any advice would be appreciated...thx!!!

Re: 12 inch SCMSIn

#2

Ellis Walentine

Miter saws

Ellis Walentine

Disclaimer: I have not used the latest versions of any of those saws you mentioned. But, in my tool-testing days, I tested them all. We consistently rated the Makita saws ahead of the rest, and DeWalt was usually right up there in the ratings. Milwaukee and Bosch were the other major contenders.

I'd say that if value for your dollar is the main concern, and you can get a Milwaukee saw for an amount significantly less than a comparable Makita or DeWalt, it sounds like a deal. I just can't figure if you need or want the stand and radio, and if you don't, I'd be taking the hardest look at the Makita.

If performance is your main concern, you should consider several important factors: the detent system that locks the miter setting (It should be positive and allow for tiny adjustments.); the range of bevel angles (A saw that tilts both ways is superior to one that doesn't.); the fence and hold-down system (Are they high enough and easy to use/); and the rigidity and smoothness of the slide mechanism.

Ellis

Re: 12 inch SCMSIn

#3

Re: Miter saws

Rocky rctools

Thx Ellis for the reply...First off Im a finish guy that does lots of various jobs from tile to flooring...Money is of no concern relatively speaking...Was gonna go with the latest Dewalt but two I know have them and said they wouldnt buy another...When I go online trying to find tool reviews for these saws in the last year I cant relly find much. I have sen a couple of reviews on the Milwakee ranking it higher than the rest however I find it hard to believe when its cheaper...You are right on the radio but the stand is a must... At this time last year was thinking about the Bosch with the new arm gear but confused about the lot of them now...I know I like Makita but when played with one at the store the lock and adjust mechs. at the back are confusing....uggh

Re: 12 inch SCMSIn

#4

Bigger Ain't Always Better

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I've had an LS-1211 [12" Makita] for many years, but I cussed it for the first 2 or so as I was using it for furniture (cutting solid hardwoods) and it simply would not give me a satisfactory cut. I solved the issue when I changed out the stock 12" blade and put on a full-kerf blade. I discovered that most all of the 12" saws come with thin blades that will flex and wander a bit in long cuts.

12" may be nice for crown work, but for cross cutting of flat stock, a 10" may give you better results. Also, look at the Hitachi. Friend of my does trim and siding and his joins are hairline tight using an 8" blade.

Re: 12 inch SCMSIn

#5

Agree...

John in NM

I have one of those old, old Hitachis. I sure wish they still made them! I believe they make a newer version, maybe a 10" rather than 8", but it doesn't get the reviews the original got.

I prefer the smaller blade simply because it is cheaper to buy and re-sharpen, and 99% of the time I simply do not need a huge blade.

Re: 12 inch SCMSIn

#6

Re: Bigger Ain't Always Better

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My son gave me his Hitachi miter (not sliding, just miter, although it does tilt, so it can cut angles in both dimensions) when he moved up to a Bosch sliding saw. He's commented several times how bulky and heavy the Bosch is. I can pick the Hitachi up with one hand; I doubt I could do that with the Bosch.

On the other hand, I can't cut the nominal 10" wide siding on our house on the Hitachi, so butt joints in the siding require borrowing his saw, or carefully cutting by hand.

So I guess it depends a lot on whether you need the extra cutting width.

Re: 12 inch SCMSIn

#7

Re: Bigger Ain't Always Better

Rocky rctools

Thanks for all the imput...like I said I love my 10 inch sliding makita but I do alot of 4 inch baseboards and prefer to cut them vertical as opposed to flat...much better success on this cut in my oppinion. Plus I do alot of shelving with 12 inch stock that the 10 inch sliding doesnt do in one pass...This is why I prefer a 12 inch slider. Any comments on the Milwakee?

Re: 12 inch SCMSIn

#8

Clint Searl

Re: 12 inch SCMSIn

Clint Searl

I have the 10" Makita and the 12" Hitachi w/laser and micro adjustment. The Makita can't be beat for its size. The Hitachi, once the laser is set up, is very accurate, and can handle anything, and the micro adjust is a nice feature. Whereas the Makita is easily portable, I consider the Hitachi best set up as a stationary machine. It's a beast.

Re: 12 inch SCMSIn

#9

Re: Miter saws

Lee Brubaker

I have a like new Delta 10" miter saw on a folding stand that was a gift when I retired 16 yrs ago. It commenced spending its' life leaning against the shop wall outta the way when I discovered it was no more accurate than my 1958 AMF RAS saw & the latter does not have a universal motor screaming right up next to my head & hearing.

Lee