Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Most "valuable" wood?

Posts

Most "valuable" wood?

#1

Most "valuable" wood?

AZ in Colorado Springs

I don't recall seeing this discussed previously.

A friend has some property in the southern US (I don't know where precisely). He'd like to plant some hardwood species that could be harvested by his descendants in the future, maybe 100 years from now.

Any recommendations on what would be a good hardwood crop to sow now? Any guesses on what varieties of hardwood will be valuable a century from now?

I realize that there are many unknowns in such a vebture, like which bug may migrate to this continent and eat the whole d@#* forest.

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

Jesper, Denmark

The most resistant type of forest is a mixed hardwood - not monoculture.

If you look at various forests after major weather disasters, you will see that softwoods and monocultures suffered the most, but a "natural" mixed hardwood showed a remarkable resistance.

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#3

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

"southern US" is a pretty broad range of growing zones. Some species won't grow in all those zones. for instance one of the most valuabe trees that could be grown in the "southern US" would be cuban mahogany, but that is only an option if your friend lives in southern Florida. How about a little less vague of a location.

Robin

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#4

JL

Re: Most "valuable" wood? *LINK*

JL

What Jesper said - mixed hardwoods.

However you've got a big problem - forecasting future trends in furniture/woodworking - which is not feasible.

How about going to the local lumber dealers and seeing which woods are higher priced? Generally these are woods such as black walnut, cherry, white oak, hickory and a few others. Red oak, poplar and ash are generally less expensive in this area.

I typically buy from the North GA center of Hardwood Web. As they are in the southern US - I'd give them a call to check on lumber prices - and they may give your friend some ideas.


Hardwoodweb

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#5

site specific

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Every state will have a forestry department. This person should contact the local forester and get advice. In both VA and TN the forester will develop a management plan for a nominal charge.

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#6

pine, densely planted

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Given the fact that companies that make their earnings from growing trees in the south plant tree farms of southern yellow pine to be harvested for pulp and/or timber, it would appear that the answer to this question is not so straightforward. Clearly the best economic return in some cases is to lease to a lumber or paper company as a tree farm.

In some cases one can get a 30 year timber harvest from yellow poplar. Here in TN 50 years is the typical harvesting cycle is 50 years.

.

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#7

Kinda like the FAA accident investigator

DizD

who was asked "Whats the safest seat on a plane?" The reply was "Tell me what kind of crash you are going to be in and I'll tell you where the safest seat is." The Forest Products Lab is working on commercialization of wood derived cellulosic nanomaterials - maybe that will be the wood product of the future.

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#8

royal paulownia?

Dick Coers

No personal experience with the tree, and have never seen one. Sure gets a lot of hype on the internet though. Might be worth looking into.

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#9

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Tough question. American Elm was a great tree...until the 1950's (now making small come back) Ash....then the borers. So, long term, it's a dice roll.

If you are thinking about "most valuable" then I'm not sure. But if your southern friend lives in the eastern south then American Holly might be an interesting tree to consider.

T.

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#10

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

One of the most valuable in this area is Black walnut. Purdue University has a strain I believe can be purchased. This does take some labor as the value of the trees is in Veneer wood. The trees are planted fairly closely together, grass must be mowed every year, after a period of years the plantings are thinned. some pruning may be required. After 30 to 50 years each tree (if properly tended) is worth several thousand dollars. Kind of a legacy planting as if your middle aged - your children will reap the rewards!

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#11

Re: royal paulownia?

John McGaw

Well, it is a nasty invasive weed but that does mean that it is easy to grow if that is any consolation. Grown in a cool climate, preferably in the mountains, where it grows slowly it produces wood that is favored for some purposes in Asia but what grows in the southern US is of such low quality, low density, and wide growth rings that they won't touch it. What I've seen online about it is generally someone trying to sell seeds/starts which will surely make you rich. Well, will make them rich anyway.

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#12

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

Robert

To answer the question of the most valuable wood that will grow in the "southern states" environment requires a lot of research. You need to factor in historical trends in wood pricing, as well as how long it will take to develope a mature tree of each species.

In my area (Pennsylvania) black walnut is one of the most valuable. I have started my own small forest by planting 7 trees on my property. But the intention here is not so much economics but rather to have a supply of lumber for myself in the future! Unfortunately, black walnut has a medium growth rate, so it will take many years for it to reach maturity, whereas a sugar maple tree grows almost like a weed, and could yield a large amount of lumber in as little as 20 years.

Another factor that could produce more income in an otherwise average tree is introducing an injury to the tree purposely so as to form a burl that can be harvested later. Burlwood prices are very high, regardless of the species.

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#13

In fact there isn't a lot of choice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Many of the responses presume that about any tree can be grown about anywhere. I recently had a forest management plan completed for 78 acres. This measly 78 acres was divided into 4 different zones dependent on soil and moisture found there. Each zone has a limited mix of tree species ideally suited for the conditions. Plant a "valuable" species like walnut or cherry where it won't grow and it will be a worthless exercise. Cherry will not grow at all on this plot. Walnut will grow in one zone only. White oak is better suited for another and red oak in a third zone. It may be that your friend's land is best suited for yellow pine, or peanuts, or nothing of any economic value. You won't know until a knowledgeable local forester studies the site.

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#14

Dale Lenz

Spot on!

Dale Lenz

I've read about 1/3 of the post above and Bill's advise is the best I've heard so far, I'm a forester that does exactly what you are asking. As Bill suggested get a local forester to write you a forest managment plan with your friends objective in mind. A site visit for me tell me a lot, what's growing there now and how are they doing. Once went to a landowner's property and he wanted to grow pecan. Pecan are the most picky of any tree that grows around here. Seen elm growing that was under 10' and was probably 20 years old and looked terrible, suggested pecan may not be the right species to try. He told me he was going to plant pecan and call me back, that's been over 20 years ago, have not heard from him.

Black cherry and black walnut would be a great species to have, but those species will never make anything worth having on a rock-pile. Holly is a Very valuable tree, but they start out in the shade of other trees, planting holly in full sun, would likely fail.

Good luck

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#15

Unless thousand cankers get it.

Dick Coers

Some predict the demise of walnut very soon.

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#16

Bob

Re: Most "valuable" wood? *LINK*

Bob

Check this out I would say this 44,000 sq. feet is worth big bucks


http://youtu.be/pzNKEO8rqJk

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#17

Thanks everyone for the great advice

AZ in Colorado Springs

I knew that the answer would have a lot to do with the specific site, but didn't know where to send my buddy for assistance. And, I knew that by asking a broadly worded question, I'd get a lot of good advice from the wise and experienced folk who hang out at Woodcentral.

Thanks for the information and thanks to Ellis for making this forum available.

Andy

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#18

Masur Birch - Figure NOT caused by bugs

Craig Daymon

I don't know if it is right for the area, but Masur Birch is very valuable and has great figure. It is not a specific kind of birch, but the figure appears most often (taking from the Wood Database description) in Downy or Silver Birch.

It is a genetic defect that causes bark inclusions, generating wonderful figure that is highly valued as veneer and by turners.

Might take some research to get seed from the appropriate trees and possibly even identify the defect so it can be reliably and repeatedly grown, but it would be a worthwhile attempt.

Other than that, I would consider Lyptus. Probably have to work through Weyhauser as I think they own the rights, but it is fast growing and strong with great color. A Eucalyptus hibrid.

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#19

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

John Lucas

My friend did exactly that. Planted Walnut mostly and Cherry. He would drive up and check on it once or twice a year since he didn't live too far away. He went there one weekend and it all been cut down. Of course none of the locals knew anything about it. His investment was gone. Filing a police report did nothing of course. I don't know if you can insure that sort of thing.

Re: Most "valuable" wood?

#20

Ellis Walentine

Y'r mst wlcm

Ellis Walentine

Like you, I'm usually pleasantly amazed at the breadth and depth of understanding here.

Ellis