Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Electrical problem revisited

Posts

Electrical problem revisited

#1

Electrical problem revisited

Dave in Bryn Mawr

Subject is table saw blowing fuses. To all of you who kindly responded to this last week. I have a link belt, so that's not it. It is a dedicated line. A cold motor could be it. Maybe I can warm it up with my heat gun (?). I'm waiting for tomorrow when the temp will 60. New info is that the motor is rated at 18 amps. All the hard wiring and extension cord are 12 gauge. I assume the short line out of the motor is too. So, now do we think a 20 amp delay fuse is OK?

Re: Electrical problem revisited

#2

Re: Electrical problem revisited

Bill Howatt

If you as stated in the previous thread were running with a 15A when it was warm the odds are the 20A will work but there is only one way to find out. However, even a 20A is low if you follow the biggest load on a circuit should be limited to 80% of the breaker capacity idea. However, most shop tools often run at less than their full-load rating and also start under virtually zero load.

Bill

Re: Electrical problem revisited

#3

Re: Electrical problem revisited

Barry Irby

Bill is right. My understanding is that the motor load should not be more than 80% of the rating for the Breaker. You should be OK but marginal with a 20 amp circuit. You can buy fuses or breakers that are made for starting motors. They have a slight time delay built into them that allow them to pass a large amount of current very briefly. Is this motor running on 120 volts or 240? If its on 240, that may reduce the Amps to half or 9 amps and then your wiring would be plenty large.

For the life of me I can''t think of the correct designation for the breakers, but they are called "hacker" breakers. Used in HVAC work regularly.

Re: Electrical problem revisited

#4

Re: Electrical problem revisited

John McGaw

The breakers are called 'hi-mag' in the trade, AFAIK. I was forced to install one in my shop on one circuit to allow the 2HP motor on my dust collector to work reliably. With a standard breaker it would pop maybe 1 time in 3 or 4 at startup. I could have rewired for 240V and halved the current but my remote control was already installed and that was meant for 120V only and I didn't want to fiddle any more than necessary.

Re: Electrical problem revisited

#5

Re: Electrical problem revisited

Larry in nw ohio

John That is how my DC remote is. As a matter of fact the remote is actually a 110 remote for a light switch. I ran 110 to the switch and them to a 30amp 240 relay with a 110 volt coil. It hasn`t skipped a beat in 8 years. Larry in NW Ohio

Re: Electrical problem revisited

#6

Re: Electrical problem revisited

John McGaw

Never underestimate my laziness... ;)

Re: Electrical problem revisited

#7

Re: Electrical problem revisited

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

What brand and model saw is involved with this problem?

I would recommend removing the link belt and spinning the motor by hand it should turn easily. If it does not, you could have a bad bearing or one that needs oil. Some older motors had oillite bearings that required periodic lubrication. Look on the end of the motor to see if there are either flip up oil caps or small plastic plugs that will pop out revealing a hole. If they exist, put in 3-6 drops of oil and wait a day or two and try starting the motor. Try starting the motor without the belt.

If the motor is fine check the arbor to see if it spins freely. You may have bad arbor bearings.

Lee

Re: Electrical problem revisited

#8

Re: Electrical problem revisited

Gary on Saltspring Is.

"So, now do we think a 20 amp delay fuse is OK?"

Dave, the answer to your question was made clear on your initial post. Please read all the answers again. If you are still uncertain as to why a 20 amp fuse may solve your problem .... Stop .... Hire an electrician and let him/her resolve this issue. When it comes to electrical matters a basic understanding is needed for d.i.y. and trying things out from advice on this board without a full grasp of what and why, could lead to serious harm. Sorry to be so blunt, but I'm worried about you getting in trouble. No offense is intended.

Re: Electrical problem revisited

#9

Re: Electrical problem revisited

Bill Howatt

Barry,

I think you are referring to HACR breakers which stand for Heating, Air Conditioning and Refrigeration. Essentially, they are for motor loads. I asked the Square-D people if all their QO breakers were HACR rated since I had seen some with the letters and somewithout. They said they were all HACR rated. Now this was Square-D and we were talking about their QO line.

Bill

Re: Electrical problem revisited

#10

Re: Electrical problem revisited

Jay Lombardo

20A breaker is marginal but OK for an 18A motor. If all wiring is rated for 20A, that is 12 gauge, you will be fine. It is still possible to pop the breaker if you somehow bog the motor down but if that happens it would probably be a good thing that it blew.

An electrician by trade but I don't play one on TV.

Jay

Re: Electrical problem revisited

#11

Re: Electrical problem revisited

Galen Vetterick

A 20 amp time delay fuse would be fine for your dedicated 12 gauge wiring to your saw. If the fuse was an Edison base then a type TL medium duty would be fine. If you have the rejection base fuse type S you cannot screw in a 20 amp fuse in place of the 15 without changing the insert to match the 20 amp threads. In that case you need a type SL fuse.

The extreme cold spell you had was enough to increase the starting amps to exceed your standard 15 amp fuse mainly due to stiffer bearing grease. Over time a motor subject to extreme temperature changes can also draw in moisture. Some in high humidity can actually build enough moisture to freeze the stator to the field. In water or waste plants many motors are equipted with auxilary heaters that are wired to keep the motor warm when not running and shut off when they do. It sounds like you do have a fairly long wiring run and the added length of an extension cord. This may add to dropped voltage and increased amp draw. Even though this was a dedicated circuit you also may have had some unbalance on that power leg during the cold to even more drop the voltage to that leg. If the motor has greasable bearing you can use a low temperature grease but most likely your bearings are sealed. The larger fuse and warmer weather will take care of your problem at least my guess.

Re: Electrical problem revisited

#12

Re: Electrical problem revisited

Dave in Bryn Mawr

After all your scholarly and detailed responses, the problem was solved with a 20 amp fuse. Haven't had a fire yet.

Dave