Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

I actually invented/discovered something

Posts

I actually invented/discovered something

#1

I actually invented/discovered something

Joe Vultaggio

I'm cutting some blind dove tail joints and asked myself: how do I saw a square slot in the pins?

Answer: with that new(ish) power saw that cuts by vibrating. The one that house trimmers use to cut door jambs flush.

OMG and it works!!!

I first cut using a dove tail saw as usual, then used the power saw to finish cutting by following the saw lines.

I wish I could draw a picture to make it clearer.

I hope this helps to those who hand hut dovetails.

Joe

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#2

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

roger lance

Joe.....congratulations on finding a new method for making blind dovetails.....you should photograph the process and post your pictorial over on Hand Tool forum.....they'll love it over there !! :D

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#3

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

...on the Hand Toll forum...

But doesn't the power oscillating multi-tool saw break the hand tool rules? Note that I don't get over to the quiet side very often.

Henry

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#4

Wouldn't the results

Stuart Johnson

be similar to trying to hand feed raw meat to starving wolves?

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#5

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

" how do I saw a square slot in the pins? " I must be feeling dense this morning for I have no idea what this statement means relative to making a dovetail joint. I don't know of any "slot" involved in the joint.

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I think he's talking about the cross-grain cuts between the pins or tails that are normally done with a chisel. Seems like it might be possible but tricky with a small blade for an oscillating multi-tool.

Jason

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#7

Re: Wouldn't the results

roger lance

Well if the results were like that.....Joe will have made two discoveries !! :D

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#8

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

roger lance

Bill....I think Joe is talking about pins for half-blind dovetails where he has used a handsaw to make the first side cut of the pins to the lines and then is using an oscillating saw placed in this kerf to complete the cut where the hand saw can not reach.....maybe.

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#9

Joe, here is another power tool technique...

roger lance

for evacuating the majority of the waste when cutting pins for half blinds.....it starts with a little jig....


which is clamped to the side of the work.....


and a small power router is used with a small straight cutter.....


with these results......


but to finish, you return to traditional methods with chisels.....


combine the two methods for some fun and see if you like the results.

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#10

jig unnecessary with the optimum bit

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I do the same but just free hand the router cuts. With good light it is not at all difficult. Just use a 1/4" bit that won't be grabby and nibble away at it. With little practice one can rout almost up to the scribe line and with one chisel chop remove the rest.

The remains after routing are not at all difficult to remove. I stick the chisel in the saw kerf and pry off what will come off, then easily pare away the remainder using the saw kerf as the guide. I find this the easiest part of making this joint. Anyone that can split the scribe line will have no problem at this point.

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#11

To summarize.....

roger lance

you are saying that if you have a router bit that will not "grab" (I also use a 1/4" straight bit....it occasionally grabs), if you have some good lighting set up specially so you can bend over and look in the opening and watch the cutting clearly without shadows etc, and if you have great muscle control over the router which doesn't fail you....then the jig is unnecessary. I agree....the jig would then be unnecessary. However, the jig makes all of your requirements for free handing unnecessary.

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#12

Re: To summarize.....

Robert Fuller

Correct me if I am wrong here, but if I were going to use a router to cut dovetails, I would use a dovetail bit and cut on the end grain, using a few scraps of wood on either side to form a platform for the router.

And if I did not want to freehand this I could just use a dovetail jig.

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#13

Re: To summarize.....

roger lance

The use of a dovetail bit and/or dovetail jig will generally limit the size, shape, and placement of dovetails.....but you are certainly free to do that.....I have a PC Omnijig (older version) and use it for certain applications like making shop drawers in 1/2" bb ply (try that freehand !).....the idea behind this post was to show some agreement with the OP....Joe....that there are many, many ways of cutting dovetails and using power tools in some part of the process....here, I'm using a small router to evacuate waste on the pin board of half-blinds.....Joe found a way to use an oscillating saw on cutting pins as well....Bill and I are blended woodworkers who like to use hand tools and power tools together....but I like to use jigs and Bill not so much....it gives us something to argue about....there are many ways to do things, not just one way.

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#14

Re: To summarize.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I bought a router with LED lighting just for this occasion. Otherwise I used the spot light on my pole lamp to shine in there. The secret is to cut the waste out in arcs. Start on the far side of the waste and cut out an arc half or less than the bit diameter. Keep expanding this arc taking cuts less than the bit diameter until the bottom of the arc nearly touches the scribe line. Then continue to nibble away what is left. So long as the bit isn't buried in the wood the forces will push the bit away from the wood being cut. It takes little skill, certainly less than splitting a scribe line with the saw, to rout within a chisel shaving of the scribe line. For anyone that finds it tedious setting up a fence, and that would include me, try it free hand. Most will be successful.

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#15

Re: To summarize.....

TomD

The key not to get a grab is to go in a counter clockwise direction. That is a climb cut, and it repels itself, and does not grab. It isn't always counter clockwise, but knowing whether one is cutting or climb cutting is basic to any power tool operation. I did some of my earlier dovetails that way back in the 70s. The only jig I used was a board clamped across the front to add width to the end of the board. This board had a rebate on it to provide space to start the cut.

I have also used the trim saw tools. They have been around for decades, so I don't think there is anything new about it. I used it mostly for trimming, but on large pieces for plunges also. The card scraper trick is so efficient I can't see bothering on smaller work. That is the trick where one does the diagonal cut with the hand saw, then pounds a card into the corner. Taig Frid demoed that in books and videos.

FWW did an article last year on this movie star and his jig for flattening timber where a planer was too small. Classic Taig Frid trick, that TF had shown in FWW publications. I guess the new editors haven't been around much. Hard to come up with anything new.

Re: I actually invented/discovered something

#16

Re: Gen 3

TomD

We are actually in stage three of these trim saws. First were the folks who bought the actual saws for removing casts without cutting into skin, and used those for plunge cut joinery. Then Fein brought their too expensive for prime time version; And now we have all the off patent saws. Been around a while.