Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Hot water heater (OT)

Posts

Hot water heater (OT)

#1

Hot water heater  (OT)

Larry in nw ohio

Am in need of a hot water heater, either gas or electric is OK. What does the collective have to say about them. Larry

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#2

Re: Hot water heater  (OT)


Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#3

A lot depends on a lot....

Gary Smyth

if it were me and I had my druthers I would invest in a high efficiency gas tankless. This is not a do it yourself installation. There are codes to consider. That and the tank makes it expensive. Still, that is my first choice, and the only choice if I'm absent from the house like a cabin or second home that is not occupied all of the year. If you require a tank, I suggest a high efficiency 40 gallon tank. If you have a big family with high demand you can consider a larger tank, but why pay to heat water if you don't need it. My opinion.

i

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#4

Re: Hot water heater  (OT)

Jesse Cloud

I'm curious to see what comes of this thread, bet the responses will vary a lot.

The tankless are great, but I have some friends who caution against them if you have hard water - lots of small passages that scale up quickly...

I like gas, but our codes here are nuts, require separate venting for each gas appliance.

Looking forward to hearing from others, I'll probably be in your shoes before long.

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#5

Re: Hot water heater  (OT)

john Veerkamp

In most parts of the country, gas heaters cost less to operate. that said in various localities electric and gas providers offer incentives for hot water generation. Tankless as was stated are the most efficient, but you need to size your capacity by flow rate(x volume of water raised x degrees temp per minute.) Most homes don't have the gas or electric capacity to heat large volumes of water per minute. If you decide to go electric you can save quite a bit by installing an in line timer to turn the tank off when you go to bed, and then back on shortly before rising. Lots of information on the internet about various options.

Good luck. Water heaters take about 1/3 of the energy use in the average home.

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#6

Re: Hot water heater  (OT)

R Payne

We have a tankless and hard water. We installed one of those electric water conditioners and haven't have a problem with the hard water in either the tankless or the other water outlets, before we put that in we expected to change faucets every 5 or 6 years, it's been 7 years since we installed the conditioners.

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#7

Technically......

Pete in Holland, MI

.....you need a "cold water" heater.

Why would you want to heat hot water ?

Same English language abuse as:

* Unthaw some meat (says to freeze it)

* ATM Machine (Automatic Teller Machine Machine)

* PIN Number (Personal Identification Number Number)

You get the point....

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#8

Bob

Re: Hot water heater  (OT)

Bob

I would go on demand tank-less/whole house.

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#9

Re: Hot water heater  (OT)

Chuck Hans

Hooray for someone else that knows enough to not to have to heat hot water. Been a sore spot with me for many years but not many people know the difference it seems. It is indeed a "cold water heater"

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#10

Bob

Should be called a Hot water Holder.

Bob

When the time comes I will remove our electric stove and hot water tank replacing them with gas stove and 220VAC on demand hot water maker or gas if efficient enough.

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#11

Re: Hot water heater  (OT)

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

Larry, I can't offer an opinion as to which type of water heater to buy. But to some of the other posters, the water heating device could be called a water heater, a cold water heater, or a hot water heater. Isn't it sometimes heating water that's still hot but cooled down a few degrees after sitting in the tank a while?

In that case it sounds like a hot water heater. :)

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#12

Re: Hot water heater  (OT)

John in NM

I like electrics personally, but then they suit my area better than gas. When we lived in Tucson and had NG piping, that is what we used and it was great.

Somewhere I remember seeing a website that talked extensively about how to get the most life out of your metal tank water heater -- of course, now I can't find the site. It was stuff along the lines of adding another galvanic electrode, and using a curved inlet tube to keep sludge stirred up.... stuff like that.

I would also like to know why it is considered horribly rude of me to correct people's spelling and grammar on internet forums, yet guys jump all over "hot water heater" every time it comes up :D Give it a rest boys, its old, very old :D :D :D

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#13

JL

Re: Hot water heater  (OT)

JL

I just had a Whirlpool Energy Smart water heater installed from Lowes. So far so good. Has worked well.

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#14

Re: Hot water heater  (OT)

Barry Irby

As a Home Inspector I know a little something about this. I have also been interested in Energy Conservation for a long time. You have lots of variable to consider. How is your house heated now?. Do you have Natural Gas Available? Propane? Do you have a large enough service of electricity? Is your gas service large enough? (If you have it at all?) Where is your existing water heater located? Inside the heated space or in some unconditioned space? Can you use an existing flue (vent) or do you have to create one or move the heater to create one? What is the cost of the various fuels per Therm or other equivalent unit?

If NG is available in sufficient quantity and a flue is easy and you can locate the unit outside the conditioned space and you can protect it from freezing a tankless unit might be suitable. I am not as big a fan as many. In order to heat water fast enough they have HUGE burners. Something on the order of 175,000 BTUH. A tank heater has a burner of about 40,000 BTUH. This difference could require upgrading the entire gas system to your house. If any gas unit is located inside the conditioned space, it sucks air out of the space for combustion, consuming your heat and AC, replacing it with outdoor air. You will pay to recondition that air with whatever your HVAC is now. Tankless heaters don't suffer much in the way of standby or tank losses, but they lose a lot of heat up the chimney while they are heating. Its hard to jamb that much heat into the water as it flows through and some of it is lost.

Standard tank versions of electric heaters and the inline ones don't suck combustion air out of the house, so you don't pay to reheat lost air. You can add a lot of insulation to the tank and reduce the standby losses. They used to lose energy to convection in the pipes but all of them come with flow restricters in the connections now that pretty much stop that.

An alternative could be a Heat Pump water heater. (GE makes them) If the space you have is tall enough to accommodate a unit about two feet taller this might be an excellent alternative. Uses less than 600 watts for the Heat Pump unit And has the electric elements available for periods of high demand.

The On Demand units can be a bit tricky. You must have a large unit to accommodate peak demand, but some of them demand a fairly large flow in order to turn the burners or elements on. So they may not heat a trickle of water.

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#15

Re: Technically Bull crap -

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

The use of the English language is basically to convey information - I will bet you are the ONLY one on this (or any other site) that did not recognize that he meant a "Water Heater". I have a pretty good command of the English language and really, really hate it when people try to make themselves "superior" by correcting others - when the information they are conveying is perfectly clear.

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#16

Re: Hot water heater LONG (OT)

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I agree with Barry, I installed and serviced many water heaters as a part time contractor. An awful lot depends on your needs (family size) distance from "water heater to use sites. number of usage sites, and availability/cost of fuels The location and type of existing water heater, family size, etc. For instance the economy of operation is dependent on 1. fuel type available - In almost all areas of the US, if natural gas is available it is quite a bit cheaper than electricity. As has been stated Tank-less heaters have some advantages: steady amount of water heated - IE a proper sized unit will produce water for continuous showers. and the tank-less units don't have a lot of stored, heated water that does lose some heat. However, in most homes I have worked on the loss of btu's is far less on a standard water heater than is lost in the piping system. Cost of purchase and installation of the Tank-less units is much higher than conventional units. Logically I think the tank-less is a decent choice if one is placed at each point of use site - Bathroom's, Kitchen and Washer sites. Tank-less also are susceptible to "hard water" and will have short operating lives in that environment. The units are expensive and far more complicated than conventional gas or electric tanks so consideration should be given to maintenance costs over the life of the unit. I have installed some electric tank-less units and would not ever consider using them in a home environment.

Conventional Gas and Electric water heaters are fairly inexpensive, quite easy to install and pretty darn efficient. You will gain more efficiency by insulating your pipes and putting a Jacket on the heater than any other way. Normal Gas water heaters have quite a bit higher recovery rate than Electric units. Gas units do lose efficiency in hard water areas due to lime build-up on the areas where the tank transfers the heat to the water. Electric units do not as the Element is the only transfer point and the lime will crack and fall off the element when it expands when power is applied. (Tank still requires draining to remove the lime.)

The Heat pump unit is a very efficient unit, (in temperate climates - no heat pump is efficient (compared to other fuels) with temperatures below about 40F) has a very high initial cost and installation cost. I am not familiar enough with these units to guess about life or maintenance costs. Due to the secondary heating elements used at lower outside temperatures, does require fairly large electrical supply.

To sum it up IMHO.

IF you have natural gas available:

(1) If you have a conventional gas water heater with the chimney installed and natural gas available I would install a replacement - may look at one of the newer direct powered vent, high efficiency units.

(2) If you have an existing Electric water heater, I would look at installing a Natural gas direct vent water heater. I would make my decision dependent on the piping cost to deliver the NG to the unit and the installation costs and feasibility of installing the PVC venting system for intake and exhaust air .

(3) If you live in a Temperate climate area where temperatures are normally above the 40F mark I would look into the costs of a Heat pump unit. (and if you decide to do that I would add the cost of water conditioning).

IF you do not have NG available:

(1a) If you have an Electric unit installed - I would replace it - if the current one has provided enough hot water for your use - I would use the same size.

(2a) If you have a Propane unit and it has served you well, I would probably replace it with a Similar unit, but with a "high efficiency direct vented" unit.

(3a) I would look at Barry's suggestion per (3) above.

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#18

Re: Hot water heater  (OT)

Mark Nowicki

My choice is electric, cheap to buy and install. We have a household of 6 adults and 60 Imp Gal capacity is sufficient for our needs. I recently installed one and I expect it to last about 10 to 12 years.

On -demand or heat-pump models are complicated and expensive to buy and maintain.

Mark

P.S. To avoid the language police I omitted "hot", "water" or "heater".

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#19

Technically I agree

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

But I remember the first time the water heater thing came up here and I was amused and enlightened by it. I made the correction in my own lexicon and moved on. It usually doesn't bother me when it reappears.

The PIN and ATM (and VIN) things are annoyances to me, however, and while I don't generally post about it, I have discussed it in person with abusers. It's not wholly about effective communication. It's also about sloppy language. Use it right or lose it might be one way to put it.

What I find interesting in the language abuse extant is how much of it has cropped up since the advent of the internet. For example, did you ever see anyone use "lead" as the past tense of "lead" (instead of "led") before the internet? It's so rampant, we've almost lost control of it. It's invisible (that is, impossible to witness) in the spoken word, but so many more people are writing in public now, those kinds of things show up a lot.

Rod

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#20

Re: Hot water heater  (OT)

R Payne

I have to disagree about gas water heaters using interior air for combustion, when we look at them a few years ago every one we looked at pull combustion air for outside (sometimes the same source as the vent sometimes two holes needed).

When we went tankless our propane use dropped by about 1/3, that included the propane furnace as well as the propane water heater.

ron

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#21

Yep

Henry Higginbotham

What's so difficult about learning something and moving on?

I'm from Alabama. I grew up in the '60s and '70s (not the 60's and 70's, by the way), and there wasn't a lot of outside influence compared to today. Over the years, I've been corrected numerous times on matters of grammar, diction, pronunciation, etc. by people who actually knew more than I did (imagine that!).

Each correction stung a bit, embarrassed me a little, but I usually remembered and got it right the next time. I learned something. If I suspected the "correction" was wrong, I checked it out. But I didn't try to defend my ignorance by calling the other person an elitist snob.

So be offended if you must, but learn something. You never know when it might be useful.

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#22

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I agree.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I grew up in the mitten state, but was fortunate to have done some world travel as a younker, hopefully balancing out the years I spent in small-town Southern Indiana (you could live in the small towns for 30 years and still be an "outsider").

Anyway, as a self-educated, well-read, machinist, redneck friend of mine put it, "The more I am corrected, the more correct I will be." It's amazing how tightly some people hold on to their ignorance. The more flexible the meanings of language in communication, the more difficult and problematic communication becomes. If you don't believe me, just travel the country and order a "Coke".

Jason

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#23

Marathon *LINK*

Craig Daymon

They're electric.

Highly efficient and well insulated. LIFETIME warranty. No anodes to corrode. Body is reinforced fiberglass of some sort.

Marathon is owned by Rheem.

Here's a link to the Fine Homebuilding's announcement of the Marathon water heater from 2008.

http://www.finehomebuilding.com/departments/fixtures-and-materials/plastic-water-heater-with-lifetime-warranty-by-water-heater-innovations-inc.aspx

-Craig


Marathon Water Heaters

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#24

Re: Hot water heater LONG (OT)

Barry Irby

Larry, You raise some interesting points.

Clearly the pipe losses would be a significant factor. This would be important on a new house or where it would be practical to insulate the pipes later. Another factor would be the frequency of use. If you only run the water occasionally, pipe insulation might not make much difference. The water would cool down after some time anyway. If you run the water frequently it seems to me the pipe insulation would make a larger difference. Also, if you run hot water in winter, the heat that escapes would be inside the house and help offset heating bills. In summer it would increase the AC bills. I also know one person who advocates insulating the Cold water pipes because according to his calculations they sap more heat out of the house in winter than than the hot water takes for the AC in summer. Wonder what the savings would be if we designed a house with the shortest possible pipe runs and insulated all of them?

Consumer Reports ran tests on Tank-less heaters and concluded it would take something like 22 years for them to payoff. I doubt they will last 22 years.

Re: Hot water heater (OT)

#25

Re: Hot water heater  (OT)

Barry Irby

I can not recall seeing a tank type water heater with a combustion air inlet. I will look into it.

There are issues. If the combustion air is extremely cold it reduces the combustion efficiency.

If the furnace or water heater is located in a damp crawl space, it is beneficial to the crawl space but detrimental to the unit.