Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Pricing dilemma

Posts

Pricing dilemma

#1

JL

Pricing dilemma

JL

I made the pub chairs as a gift to a friend.

Frankly I was tired of seeing the cobbled together stools that he was using in his store. Those were built out of 2 x 4s, 3/4" plywood and screws - and they looked ugly. Anyway, Tommy and Gary have been very generous to the playhouse and have given us a deep discount on paint, hardware, tools and supplies. I also wanted to do some real woodworking other than set building.

So the chairs have been at the store for a couple of weeks. Evidently they've been shown - well they are quite visible behind the counter - and people have asked about them.

The pub chairs aren't difficult to build. I can knock several out in a week if I apply myself. However, they aren't inexpensive - maybe 12 board feet in the legs and stretchers and 10 board feet in the seat and back. The hardware, glue and finish costs are negligible - deck screws, Titebond and an oil/poly blend.

The cost with new lumber (as opposed to from my stash) - is $98 for ash and cherry, $111 for ash and walnut. I always figure on a 10-20% wastage. I don't really see how I can get the materials cost lower.

I am not going to give my labor away (except to the playhouse, but that's different). I was figuring on at least $200 for an ash and cherry pub chair and about $225-250 for ash and walnut. I don't want to ask for less. Should I ask for more?


Re: Pricing dilemma

#2

Re: Pricing dilemma

Nat Robison

To answer your question, I don't think your price is too low and could probably be higher.

My sister-in-law was considering having me build her a counter height kitchen table and I suggested she look into some unfinished bar stools (with backs) that she could purchase and could be stained to match the table. I was surprised to see how many sold for $200-$400 each unfinished. Maybe it was the number of spindles, I don't know but I don't think $200-$250 is too much for custom stools.

Re: Pricing dilemma

#3

Bob

Re: Pricing dilemma

Bob

I think your price is dead on however you should be able to do much better on your material cost.

Re: Pricing dilemma

#4

Re: Pricing dilemma

paul in AZ

Agree that the price is very reasonable if not too low. Depends on what you figure your hourly labor is worth.

A one-off project done gratis as appreciation or friendship is not like a retail production run, no matter how small.

I had something like this with beds. A neighbor in the mattress business saw my bed and sent several people over who thought they wanted custom made beds. Once they heard the cost of the lumber alone they lost interest. They wanted a custom bed in good hardwoods at Walmart prices.

You may find that interest fizzles out as soon as they hear that they can't get a chair for $99.

Re: Pricing dilemma

#5

Re: Pricing dilemma

roger lance

Ask for more.....at least $250 & $300.....1) you don't need the work.....you're at a stage of life where you can volunteer your time and service....2) people will pay that and more.....and who knows a customer might want a table to go with them or other work.....if you low ball now, they will expect you to be low then.....be sure to sign and date the underside of the bottoms....people like that and they'll know who to contact for more.

Re: Pricing dilemma

#6

Re: Pricing dilemma

Jesse Cloud

If you plan to sell them locally in retail, rather than in bulk to a store, here's an idea to add value easily... make them truly custom. Offer a "fitting" and customize the height of the seat from the ground and the height of the back from the seat to provide lumbar support where it is needed. Simply a matter of length of the legs and how far up you attach the seat. Add another $150 to the price for this. Short and tall folk especially will gladly pay the premium when they sit in a truly comfortable stool. And it makes the whole project more fun for you.

Re: Pricing dilemma

#7

material cost

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

These cuttings are all small. If you live where lumber is available these should be built from at best #1 common lumber at a substantial cost reduction. Buying in quantity from where a shop would be buying would reduce your material cost by half. Additional cost can be wrung out by using all ash or oak. Actually the style in all ash or all maple would look great (I am not a fan of mixed woods, but that is admittedly a personal deficiency).

I can't offer any useful advice on what to charge. Economic theory says that price is determined by the buyer, availability by the supplier. At first charge what you are willing to make them for. If there is demand raise the price.

Re: Pricing dilemma

#8

Double your price, at least!

Dick Coers

Had a plumber out to the house lately? They want $150 to pull in the driveway. Don't sell yourself short on these. Very nice work!

Re: Pricing dilemma

#9

A cat-astrophy in the making.

Brian from Monument

I think your cats like your chairs.

Perhaps they will buy them or demand they not leave.

Re: Pricing dilemma

#10

Re: Pricing dilemma

don stephan

Cherry should cost 6-7$ per bd ft 4/4, ash half that. I'd ask you make a good estimate of the time required and reasonable materials cost, and mark up your time using a reasonable part time hourly rate. If the people seeing your chairs are all Walmart shoppers it's likely they won't be willing to pay what the chair is worth. But selling for less cheapens skilled woodworking in the eyes of the general public, imho. Market the price (educate the public on the value of good working) rather than pricing to the market (pricing to match the price of disposable furniture). Just my two cents.

Re: Pricing dilemma

#11

Re:$1700

TomD

Is what Thos Moser asks for. He is not my idea of a rock star designer, but he has a solid long held rep, and the stool in question is nicer than yours. You could do something to make the back a little less boardy, though it does have a contrast in form, and stuff always looks so much richer in person. I am not questioning your judgement, just since you are going to market, maybe there are steps you might want to take, to make it even more broadly attractive. You sure beat the 2x4 stools, so now maybe you have something you may want to add to take it to the next level.

http://www.thosmoser.com/collection/edo/product/1315/edo_stool/

You may need to consider insurance, which could run 1K a year as long as the chairs are out there.

I don't make stools but I am surprised there is nearly 20 bft in lumber, that sounds like 80 pounds ish, my math must be off. Remember when you price wood you sell it at retail. You are buying at wholesale (either in reality or conceptually) and you mark that price up as you pass it on to your retail customer, you are also machining it, so you either charge for that, or rather than charging a hourly rate for your labour you charge a shop rate. 30 years ago that was 60 bucks. There are a lot of other costs that you need to mark up, like merchandising unless your pals at the store are marking it up.

Also, now that you are turning pro, who might do a better job of repping your work in the area. You need to chase down the maximum buck.

Re: Pricing dilemma

#12

Re: Pricing dilemma

Frank Orfanello

I'm sorry I'm so late in answering but I would not hesitate to ask $250-$300 each for these. They are beautiful and look sturdy. I have paid near $200 for chairs not nearly that nice.