Let's say I have something like a foot long two by four and I want to cut an irregular curve more or less down the middle the long way in such a way that the two parts will mate up perfectly. The only way I know without endless effort to use a very fine blade in a scroll saw. ( Using one of those comb-like gadgets won't be accurate enough.) But I'm wondering about some kind of router set up -- sort of the way two router bit collars can be used for setting inlay. Any ideas?
I scribe stuff to walls and other immovable objects when needed, it can be a pain but usually worth the effort.
I also do a lot of routing with flush trim bits, both top and bottom bearing and a template or pattern. Usually there's at least a little head scratching or maybe a couple runs at making the jig, so for one off stuff I don't do this, just fit by trial and error.
I use a spindle sander. I cut to within 1/32" of the line and then sand to the line. the key is in acurate layout and a good scribe line with a knife. With a bit of practice and good technique a spindle sander can produce curves more acurately than a router.
You can do it with a router, template and collar setup. You can get a very precise fit.
I would rough bandsaw the shape first.
Make a template the the curve shape that you want.
you will then use a combination of router bits and different offset collars to put the cutting edge from on side to the other side of the cut line when running against the template.
I used to do a lot of template routing on various items.
These are business card or creditcard holders that i used to make.
The first is a simple curve, the second a more complex offset inlay
The biggest problem is the depth. I use what is mentioned above for 3/4" stock. I use an upcut spiral bit and my bushings to guide the cut. I make a template first of course. I have a longer bit but it tends to chatter when routing 1 1/2" stock. I guess it would work but I haven't tried it.
The quick and easy way, with one pattern bit, no meticulous detail sanding, no offset calculations, etc., etc.
1. If you don't already have the first part, bandsaw one to the desired profile. Smooth it to the line and remove the blade marks with a file or spindle sander.
2. Trace the profile of the first part onto the middle of a piece of MDF. Cut the MDF outside the lines so the MDF "template" is a tad smaller (1/16" - 1/8") than the first part. No need to be precise here.
3. Cover the edge of the first part with thin plastic wrap (Saran Wrap).
4. Mix up some Bondo, butter the edge of the MDF template, and mate the MDF to the first part. Apply enough Bondo so there are no gaps. Hold or clamp the first part and template together so you get some squeeze out.
5. After the Bondo has hardened, separate the two pieces. If needed knock off any squeeze-out or hit it with a file so both faces of the MDF template are flat. Ta Da! You have a template the will mate perfectly with the first part and can be used with a flush trim bit to make the mating part.
A few years ago I saw a cabinet with doors that had irregular lines that appeared to be string inlay running from top to bottom of each door. There were about five lines in each door relatively evenly spaced. I asked the maker and he said he used a band saw to cut the doors into strips and then sandwiched thin strips of holly between each piece of wood. I believe he said the door parts mated well enough after cutting that no addtional work was needed. The contrast between the dark door wood and the holly strips gave the cabinet a unique and attractive appearance. The cabinet was at the Clayton, MO art show.
Thanks for this reply; it's the closest to what I had in mind. Unfortunately, I can't quite follow what you wrote. It's your forth paragraph that seems garbled to me -- the one that starts with," Make your first pass ...". Would you be willing to rewrite some of it? I really can't follow it as it is.
Lets say you rough bandsaw two edges close to the finish shape and now want to trim them to fit with the router.
This is an example of how you might go about it.
This photo is from the end of the boards.
Example A: 1/2" router bit with a 3/4" template guide
Example B: 1/2" router bit with a 1 -3/4" template guide
Template on top, wood to be cut on the bottom.
Example A.
you are trimming the right had piece of wood.
Clamp the template and onto the left hand piece as in the example.
Position the right hand piece so the rough bandsawn edge wood should be moved into the path of the cutter, trimming a small amount (1/16') off.
you would be standing on the left of this page facing the right, pulling the router toward you and against the template.
If you start with the router at the right hand end of the boards and feed it along the length of your board to the left, you will be climb cutting, which will push your router against the template, if you feed the other direction you will be up cutting which will tend to pull away from the template and into your wood, experiment. on a scrap.
This example gives you a cut that is offset .625" or 5/8th from the template.
Example B;
You are trimming the left hand piece of wood using the same template.
You will be using the 1-3/4" template guide.
Clamp the template onto the wood to be trimmed, leaving approx 1/16th in the path of the cutter.
Clamp the template and board together.
You will be standing on the left of this picture, facing the right, pulling the router toward you.
Start the cut from your right hand end of the board and run the router to your left, you will be up-cutting this will keep the router pulled into the template guide.
This will give you a cut .625 or 5/8ths offset from the template and should match you first board.
If you decide to cut from the other direction you will be climb cutting and you will need to have good control of the router as it will want to run away and wont pull in tight to the template. you can do it, and it may give you a better surface, but you will need to practice on a scrap.
Things to remember, Bearings are more accurate ( concentric ) than template guides.
Template guides are rarely concentric to the bit, this can be used to your advantage as they are like a cam and you can vary the fit by using turning the router slightly.
This is just an example of how you might do it.
You can of course use a different combination of template guides and bit to achieve the same or different results.
For instance if you wanted to inlay a 1/8" strip of different wood.
There is no end to want you can do with jigs and template following setups.
Hope that is a little clearer, let me know if i have not explained it correcty or clearly or messed anything up.