Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Extractives Interest

Posts

Extractives Interest

#1

Extractives Interest

don stephan

Bruce Hoadley's great book Understanding Wood is a good introduction to extractives, but I'd like to learn more. As I understand, as the diameter of a tree gets larger not all of the cross section is needed to transport water and such between the roots and leaves, so the longitudinal cells die from the center out. As these cells die the tree deposits extractives, and the cells become heartwood.

My increased curiosity was stimulated in large part by the swirling color in the heartwood of some ash killed here in Cincinnati by the ash borer. The swirling color is almost like what one sees when cream is poured into black coffee lightly stirred. In black walnut the transition is very sharp and the heartwood is a much more uniform different color than the sapwood.

And if I remember correctly, the number of annual rings of sapwood is fairly constant within a particular species, but can vary dramatically between species?

Curious in Cincinnati.

Re: Extractives Interest

#2

Re: Extractives Interest

Dick Coers

Not any insight, but just some comments. I've seen dramatic changes in the figure, and/or color of trees under stress. I've cut maple that had heartwood that is like hundreds of others, but the outside 4-6" has fantastic figure. Blisters, bark inclusions like masur birch, etc...It's like a switch was thrown, and it starting making all new figure and cell growth. I've seen lightning strike trees that show figure change, trees with bacterial infections that are extra heavy and stink, and lots of variables. Maybe someday, with some research, we will understand these changes or genetic changes.

Re: Extractives Interest

#3

Re: Extractives Interest

Jim Pugh

You might want to look into something called "olive Ash". Ash is a member of the Olive family and occasionally a tree will exhibit the color of olive wood.

Re: Extractives Interest

#4

Re: Extractives Interest

Keith Newton

Don, I too have been interested in this subject for quite a while, and have not been able to find the information that I wished for. However, having been working with wood for around 40 years now, harvesting my own wood for much of it, I have made some interesting insights into this subject that I could share. But first let me say, that I hold no degrees from any institutions of higher learning to back up my observations. If you find a good source of information on this, I sure with you would share it with me.

Otherwise, If you or anyone else, for that mater, know someone wishing to do some study / thesis, I would love to have a hand in guiding, or suggesting some experiments.

First, I have noticed that number of rings between bark is NOT really all that constant. My observations, is that it has a lot to do with thickness of bark, and it's possible association with the air outside. I have on many occasions seen trees where the heartwood transition will jump several years along one side of a tree. For example, I got a tree from the National Cemetery here in LR, which dated back to its inception after the Civil War, which was hit with an extreme lightning bolt in the year 1954. It should have killed the tree, but being a Post Oak, which are one of the best in this area of surviving under extreme conditions ,or should I say locations. One of the flashes, was so powerful, that it blew out about aprox 4" x 4" up one side. There were 12 other scars around the outside from the flickers of that same bolt.

But almost 50 years later when I got the tree, that scar was about 8" inside the tree, with bark about half the thickness of the rest, and a corresponding jump in the sap to heartwood transition.

I also happened to have found the oldest Cedar in AR about 25 years ago. It is interesting to note, that in Cedar / Juniperus Virginiana, when a Yellow-bellied Woodpecker pecks it, that forever after, beneath where its beak penetrated the cambium layer, there will always be a little streak of sapwood which never makes the transition into heartwood. I think this is due to the sap condenses into a thick varnish beneath the bark, which blocks the oxygen needed to fulfill that transition.

Besides the woodpeckers, about 10 years ago, Hendrix college commissioned me to carve a mace for their high ceremonies. For some reason, they saved a Cedar branch from in front of one of the old building to use. I was only able to use it for carving a flame to top the rest, which I used Rosewood for. But for a number of years, I left a piece of that wood out in sight, because I felt there was some other reason that it had found it's way to my shop. Then one night, I noticed that something. Most of the outside was dead, with only a strip growing on one side. Along the edge where the bark ended, and air could come around the bark, and up through the bare wood, exposing the sapwood to air, there was no sapwood line. The annual rings became sapwood the same year they formed. While the sapwood got thicker further away from the edge.

One question that I have, is whether the sapwood to heartwood transition happen gradually throughout the year, or perhaps at the end of Winter, or early Spring. I got, and turned a Mulberry once, which seemed to have a faint ring on the outside of the heart, that became fully dark by the time I finished the turning. But I'm sure trees in the tropics growing all year long wouldn't rely on this.

This is all I have time for now, and sorry I don't have any pics, most were taken during film days, and my filing system consist of piles of slides in cardboard boxes before going digital. Then, after my computer crash last year, my images didn't make it over with my assigned file names, so strolling through 10.000 images for anything is,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, well.

You must have experienced something to compel you to ask this question. I'd like to hear any observations that you have made.

Re: Extractives Interest

#5

ash

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

At least in E. TN ash does not have a predictable transition from heart to sap. I have seen the heartwood on the end of an ash log resemble an amoeba in shape. When sawed these logs yield an irregular heat to sap pattern.