Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

Posts

LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

#1

LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

Derek Arita

When I purchased my Laguna 2hp DC from Rockler, their tech info said that the machine was rated at 1600cfm. Compared with the JDS at 1700cfm, there was little difference. At a lower cost and added features, I went with the Laguna. After the DC was assembled and tested, I took a look at the machine on the Laguna site and found that they had it listed at 1450cfm. I then checked the manual and it said the machine was rated at 1600cfm. I called Laguna to informed them of the discrepancy and find out which was correct. They said they'd call me back after investigating the issue...they never did call back. I called again, got the same answer, but no call back.

If, in fact, the Laguna is rated at 1450cfm and had I know that from the start, I might have gone with the JDS unit, even at the higher cost. If you're trying to make the same decision that I was faced with, beware that the 1600cfm rating on the Rockler site and in the manual, may not be correct. By the way, Woodcraft has it rated at 1450cfm. Sure wish i knew the correct number...just for info sake. If I posted this here before, please accept my apology.

Re: LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

Jesper, Denmark

The cfm number by itself is totally meaningless. It is often quoted with NOTHING attached to the fan. The data you really need is SFFM at the standard temperature of 70°F at a specified pressure drop in inches water gauge at that temperature. Then you can compare the numbers.

Re: LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

#3

Re: LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

Larry in nw ohio

Derek This is after the fact, but you should have goen to Bill Pentz`s site. He has the best site on the net about DC. Even now you should go there, anyone can learn a lot about DC. Larry

Re: LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

#4

Re: LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

Derek Arita

I have been to Bill's site many times in the past. I kinda got caught up in all the hoopla. My main concern right now is the best DC I can get, in the smallest package, with a lot of consideration on $. The Laguna and JDS were fairly close.

Re: LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

#5

Re: LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

Mark

I would be more concerned about the lack of Laguna's interest in resolving your question and not clarifying and properly representing their product . Maybe they need to be informed about Wood Central and the less then positive review their customer service is receiving and will receive... i wouldn't let them off the hook so easily....escalate to the next level till you find someone at Laguna who actually does what they say they are going to do ...as in call you back with the answer. Truth in advertising or product claims is a pretty basic requirement.

Re: LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

#6

Re: LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

Derek Arita

Jesper,

Who would have this information on this machine? Would they have comparable info on the JDS 2HP machine? That's the problem...how do you compare? The only thing we have to go by is the info provided, unless there's someone out there who is testing all or most of the machines for comparisons.

Re: LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re: LAGUNA 2HP DC CFM DISCREPANCY...

Jesper, Denmark

I do not know of any competent comparison test. There might be some in the articles either WC or the old Badger Pond,