Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Countertop Choice

Posts

Countertop Choice

#1

Countertop Choice

John foster

Hi All, Just an opinion question here. We are putting in a new kitchen, and are going fairly high end woodlandhorizon.com cabinets, rachiele.com sink, thak.ca range hood. The one area causing us worry is the countertop material. Everyone says that in a premium kitchen we should have granite countertops , mostly because it is expected in a nice kitchen and not to have it would detract from the value of the house. We find granite cold to touch and noisy; and would rather go with a laminate top. How much of a design faux-pas is this? Has anyone ever regretted not going with granite? Would we suffer if we ever sold our home( no plans for this at present) ?

Thanks John

Re: Countertop Choice

#2

Ellis Walentine

Trade-off

Ellis Walentine

The way I sort out design questions like this is to ask "who is the customer?" In this case, it's you -- and you don't care for granite, for all the right reasons. I say, do what you like best and let the next owner replace your countertops with granite if they see fit. Unless your kitchen is really huge, the replacement cost will only be a few thousand dollars at most, which shouldn't be too big a concession to make on the sale price of your house.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Countertop Choice

#3

Re: Countertop Choice

Keith Newton

I agree with Ellis, but was wondering if you had looked at some of the other solid surface material. The plastic would not be as cold, nor quite as hard/ noisy. There are some nice options, and I don't think anyone would think the look cheap, because,,, it is not. The last time I checked, it was about the same price as stone.

Re: Countertop Choice

#4

Re: Countertop Choice

Bill Howatt

I admit when I go into a kitchen the granite counter-tops look very nice and "rich".

My wife wasn't that keen on them or Corian so spending the extra money seemed silly. We used laminate and had it edged with Corian and also about a 4" Corian backsplash. We are very happy with it and we also don't live in fear of an expensive surface getting marked up. Since the laminate is horizontal and the albeit smaller Corian surfaces are vertical I think the Corian is more prominent to the casual viewer.

One minor annoyance for me is that the installers made efficient use of the laminate sheet resulting in one seam. They did put it in the best place but I notice it. So you could spend a bit more and tell them no seams (if possible).

As far as resale value goes, people these days seem to change kitchens a lot more frequently than years ago. So by the time you want to sell your house the buyer may be ready to throw it all out anyway.

Ellis, has the right view, it is your kitchen, do what you want.

Bill

Re: Countertop Choice

#5

Go with what you like...

John in NM

When/if you sell, the trend may be different and your re-sale value oriented choice now may work against you then.

Personally, I would look at some of the other solid surface materials, as I don't find laminate to be a good value for the money. The one time we bought the granite, a custom laminate job was only slightly cheaper, and from a physical properties point of view, granite is the more durable material.

Last time we bought one of those epoxy/sand materials, and I like it too. I tend to like solid surface materials a lot, as you can tell :D

Re: Countertop Choice

#6

Rock rocks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Has anyone ever regretted not going with granite"....No, but I regret not installing it sooner. Don't know where you live but if you can find a distributor of rock and visit you may find a rock of your liking. The distributors in our area (travelrs Rest SC and Knoxviille TN) are happy to have customers tour the inventory, and if a selection is made deliver it to the fabricator.

I don't understand the "noisy" reservation. It is not a factor I can even imagine. As far as "cold" there are a vast array of rock types, and now days surface lusters, that can be bought in every imaginable color and texture. Very few are actually granite and the surface does not have to be shiny.

I too was opposed to rock until we visited a distributor (Travels Rest , SC) and saw colors and textures we liked. We went with an Indian Gneiss, formed when India crashed into Asia and smushed the rocks under the Himalayan mts.

I have made several tables from Travertine which has a soft luster.

Re: Countertop Choice

#7

Re: Countertop Choice

Christopher Fitch Memphis

We went with Quartz...and I couldn't be happier.

Since it's a man made product, it lacks some of the downsides of granite.

On the other hand, it lacks that natural randomness that granite has.

Re: Countertop Choice

#8

Re: Countertop Choice

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Here's a picture...


Re: Countertop Choice

#9

Re: Countertop Choice

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Another Pic:


Re: Countertop Choice

#10

my recent reno choices

GolfSteve in Calgary

I loved my old, brown, cut-up, 40 year old laminate counters. Thought it was the best stuff in the world, but the '70's brown was ugly as sin, and the brown tile backsplash was even worse.

I renovated and put "silver-pearl" granite counters in. I wouldn't go back to laminate. Maybe I have "soft" hands, but I don't notice that the counters are noisy, and I haven't chipped the granite or broken any glassware. (Friends warned me that granite counters have a learning curve where you needed to learn to set things down gently).

I don't find the counters cold - physically or visually. The gloss finish is a bit lifeless. You can get a "leather" finish ($$), but I didn't like the look of that, and I think the satin finish would show scratches.

I think colour choice is important - granite reportedly does stain and needs to be sealed annually. The "silver pearl" is about 40% black and 60% silver (magnetite). Pure black counters shows streaks too easily whereas the silver pearl is perfect for not showing streaks, but is also dark enough that if stains occur, they should not be too visible. If you go too light, then I think stains might show.

I went with a Blanco "silgranit" sink - ie. granite dust mixed with epoxy. While I like the sink, I think a high quality stainless sink would last longer. The silgranit is very quiet - no banging noise when washing the dishes, but the black sink is a bit hard to keep clean looking.

Re: Countertop Choice

#11

Not directly answering your question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

We put in one of the quartz composites, and like it. But it was costly.

If you're going to do laminate, you might think about either edging it with wood or using the color-core stuff that's the same color all the way through, to avoid that dark line at the edge (unless you're using the preformed countertops).

Also: you don't have to use the same countertop everywhere. We flanked the stove with wooden countertops from our local home center (I added a wood backsplash), and it was a great decision: built in cutting boards. I will eventually have to scrape them, when the marks from knives get bad enough; but this is much less of an issue than I thought it might be.

Re: Countertop Choice

#12

Re: Countertop Choice

Mark

Recently finished a kitchen Reno , wanted it bad,, saved for several years.

We significantly improved the function which was the real issue , but to be honest we wanted a makeover fit for an HGTV special...got close I think.

We spent neither the least nor the most we could have, but we wanted to ensure we did not spend all this money on new cabinets and layout , electrical and plumbing refit, new fixtures, new appliances, new lighting,etc etc ....and then put Building centre off the rack laminate counter tops on top of it.

As has been said, get what you like, you are the only ones who have to live with it , but there are many other choices besides Granite.

IMHO though whenever you see a top end Kitchen reno...its always granite or a quality stone or man made, it's never laminate.

Re: Countertop Choice

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: What's wrong with wood?????

Jesper, Denmark

I remodelled my kitchen a couple of years ago. Actually had a supply of elm boards intended for the counter top. After sanding off the old wood tops, they looked so good that the elm is still in the attic, drying further.

The old wood counter tops are comercial 5/5 tops, made from glued staves, and finished with a solvent base semi-gloss varnish, intended for high traffic wood floors. The cook-top is lowered a bit to make it easier to stir in the pots and the area around the cooktop is one piece of 1" slate, so you can set hot pans on it without any damage.

Re: Countertop Choice

#14

Wastefull Humans !

Pete in Holland, MI

We take stone products that took thousands of years to grow, cut them into counter tops, and, I do agree, they look cool.

10 years from now, that color will be SO old fashioned, and we'll throw it out to put something else in its place.

Such a waste of natural resources.

Formica brands have some really nice looking patterns anymore, and, if in 10 years, you want to change it, there isn't much cost, and it won't take 1000 years to replace the ingredients.

My rant.......

Pete

Re: Countertop Choice

#15

Seriously?

John in NM

Rock is one thing we're not short of on this planet :D

Re: Countertop Choice

#16

Re: Countertop Choice

Dave on the Mount

We replaced our formica countertops with granite several years ago and despite the stated pitfalls we like it. However there is one thing that I would do differently. We chose a chamfered/ beveled front edge treatment and in hindsight I would have/ should have gone for a bullnose. Those extra squared/ pointed edges seem to attract knicks and small chips, particularly around the dishwasher where pots and pans are coming and going. The rounded treatment in all likelyhood would have resisted the impact a little better. Just food for thought.

Regards,

Dave in Canada

Re: Countertop Choice

#17

no shortage of wood either

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The Forester here tells me that the growth rate in our area exceeds harvest by 3X. Furthermore, counter tops assembled from strips of wood will be cut from #2 Common lumber. There is never a shortage of this grade. Typically its sales price doesn't equal its manufacturing cost, the difference being made up from sales of the higher grades. Trees yielding mostly 2 common won't even be harvested so they are left to crowd out new growth of more valuable trees. The forest, loggers and everyone else down the food chain would benefit from more 2 common lumber usage.

Re: Countertop Choice

#18

Re: Seriously?

Mark

When we throw out the Formica either for loss of looks , or because it wears out faster then stone how long does it linger in the landfill before it decomposes, if it decomposes?

I can't see the glue or formica top being of any positive benefit to the environment.

Stone I would guess is neutral at best or can be recycled as an aggregate.

Re: Countertop Choice

#19

Re: Countertop Choice

Mark

Same for us Dave , but I think some granites have to be treated with a chamfer versus bull nose or ogee detail. They told us the one we choose after many hours searching was a bit " sugary" and trying to round it over would not work as the grinding would chip it out too much.

When I heard that I was up for looking for another piece of stone as I wanted ogee..SWMBO put a stop to that.

Re: Countertop Choice

#20

Interesting...

paul in AZ

My kitchen has a granite countertop with a chamfer of close to 3.8" that was put in by the previous owner. The rim of the undermount sink has only a slight roundover. Probably 25 years old. No signs of edge nicking anywhere.

If your top is nicking it seems more likely to be a function of the softness of the stone itself and not the chamfer. I suppose someone could be pounding on the stone with pots but that seems unlikely to me.

I recently did two bathrooms with a similar chamfer and used the remainder of a complete slab for a hallway cabinet top.

Re: Countertop Choice

#21

Bart Goldberg

Re: Seriously?

Bart Goldberg

Do I suspect that your predisposed to Stone? (as in Mark Stone?)

Re: Countertop Choice

#22

"Granite" is the salesman's term...

John in NM

And like all the fretting about sealing and hot pans, the salesman is usually very short on accurate information.

Most of the fancy granites you see are actually metamorphic rocks of some type, and some will be prone to chipping. It all depends on the minerals involved and any later alteration of the rock by either ground water or hot fluid from another source.

The typical true granite is usually quite boring (unless you're a geologist), but not prone to chipping at all. A fine grained one will also make a great counter top because it is not visually "busy" - more like a sandstone.

Re: Countertop Choice

#23

Re: Seriously?

Larry in nw ohio

For sure, there are plenty of rockheads in Washington. Larry