Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Accura band saw guide opinions

Posts

Accura band saw guide opinions

#1

Accura band saw guide opinions

Eric in Los Gatos

Good day all you band saw gurus,

I have a Jet 14 in band saw that I am considering upgrading to ball bearing guides. I've had Cool Blocks but can't get them to stay adjusted.

I've done some research and there seem to be three choices: Carter, Iturra Designs and Accura. The Carter stuff seems too pricey for me but I can be persuaded. The Iturra Designs look good and have a good reputation. The Accura (found on Amazon.com) seems is more of an unknown. They are priced about the same as the Iturra Designs but are more like a less expensive equivalent to the Carter guides. I'm left wondering if you get what you pay for. Amazon had only two reviews but they were pretty good.

Any thoughts, advice, opinions, advice or recommendations would be appreciated.

Thanks,

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

#2

Bob

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

Bob

I have a 16" Laguna that came with bearings and I changed out to ceramic guides, it took some getting use to but after playing with it I would not go back.

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

#3

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

Barry Irby

I have a love/hate relationship with my Delta 14" saw with a riser block. I tried Cool Blocks, Iturra's band rollers, and Carter ball bearing guides. The Carter guides are on the saw now because I am too lazy to change to something else. I don't like any of them. The band rollers clogged up with saw dust. The Carter ball bearings press sawdust onto the blade. Especially the ones below the table. I have dust collection on the saw but it lacks the force it would take to suck the sawdust away before it gets pressed onto the blade.

I might try a ceramic thrust bearing and cool blocks or ceramic guides.

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

#4

Picture looks similar to Carters...

John in NM

Which came stock on my saw.... Adjust really easy.

I don't really care for them much. They work fine, until the bearings get clogged up with sawdust, which happens maybe twice a year under light use. Heavy use I'd probably be changing them once a month. I bought a bunch of spares from VXB for maybe $1.50 each, so I can't really complain - but it still offends my sensibilities :D Its the thrust bearings that gets clogged, the others don't seem to.

I've been itching to try a ceramic thrust bearing, maybe then I'd be happy as a clam.

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

#5

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

Philip Duffy

I upgraded to Carters and have regretted it ever since. They might be fine for some saws but on my Jet they are no better than the blocks. I have done everything to make them work but the re-saw angle is still a big PITA. Philip

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

#6

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

Barry Irby

I have already replied, but I want to agree with Phillip. I spent about $150 on the Carter guides and it is the worst money I ever spent, at least on the bandsaw. In addition to pressing the sawdust firmly onto the blade, by their nature the rollers MUST guide the blade from half their diameter above the wood. So, they are further from the surface than guide blocks. The other thing I hate about them is the method of adjusting them. I assumed you would have a screw to tune them in and out and a set screw to lock them. Nope. You awkwardly loosen a set screw on a sloppily fitted shaft, fidget them into position and then tighten the set screw. All the while ruining the setting by turning the Allen wrench. A stunningly poor design.

The problem is I need two bandsaws. One for resawing and one for everything else. It can take half an hour to install the resaw blade and tune the saw and then another 20 minutes to put the bowl blank/utility blade back on it. Wish I had the room and money for another saw.

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

#7

band saw guide opinions

del schisler

i have the cool block for yrs now all i do is take them out and use the grinder wheel to flatin the end's and put them back in, I belive if the beiring's are moved out to far wouldn't thet take the set out of the teeth or am i thinking wrong?? i look at the video and it looks like it would if you weren't looking at what you were doing? i will stick to my old cool block's which if you want you can move them out and let the teeth cut a teeth grove and that wouldnt hurt nothing, you can also make some out of 1/2 white oak and that would work also or any good hard wood for free? my 2 cents

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

#8

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I think the best blade guides on a band saw are plain old steel blocks. Some of the guys over on owwm.com used a laser temperature gauge to evaluate the various types of guides and while I don't remember the numbers there was very little difference between ball bearings, cool blocks, and plain old steel. In light of that I would go with what will perform the best for the longest amount of time before needing adjustment and for me that is plain old steel.

Robin

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

#9

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

del schisler

woundn't the set in the teeth be runed if some how the blade got behind the frount of the guides ?? sometimes things just happen

Re: Accura band saw guide opinions

#10

Re:  band saw guide opinions

Kurt

I have a saw that came with typical Asian band saw roller bearing guides. I made my own blocks out of maple that I submerged in mineral oil and microwaved for about 30 seconds. I kept the thrust bearing, just replaced the OEM shielded bearing with a sealed bearing. The problem I see with either bearings or steel guides is with blades 1/4 or narrower" . There isn't much flat metal on a band between the bottom of the gullet and the back of the blade on narrow blades. That's where the steel or bearing guides must run. I have heard of people replacing steel guides with brass. Brass would be softer and maybe wouldn't be as likely to damage blade teeth and cause drift problems due to damaged teeth. Hard wood soaked in oil seems easier and cheaper. If the wood's blade contact surface gets chewed up, remove and sand it flat or replace and carry on.