Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

OT Car battery's

Posts

Re: OT Car battery's

#26

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Not quite.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

On cars, I would agree with you that the larger wheels are a fashion statement. But there's more to it than that for trucks. People are buying bigger, more capable trucks and SUVs--vehicles that can haul ever larger loads (while the vehicles themselves weigh much, much more over older models) and have stronger engines that can pull much heavier trailers and loads. Why does this necessitate larger wheels? To fit larger and larger disc brakes and calipers for increased stopping power.

Jason

Re: OT Car battery's

#27

Not buying it...

John in NM

Mostly because I don't believe that state highway laws have suddenly increased GTWR standards for non commercial trucks that manufacturers have had to increase the braking capacity of said vehicles. You can pull the same load with a modern truck as with the 1978 F150 I used to drive.

Also because increased braking capacity is the goal, there are other methods of achieving it - higher hydraulic pressure, more pad area, dual calipers. Improved braking compared to say the 1970's has everything to do with the switch to disc brakes from drum, not wheel size.

Without actual engineering data for those idiotic 17" rims, I'm sticking with the "looks cool, sells more trucks" explanation. Same reason they sell every chromed plastic gee-gaw you can imagine to strap on a truck - the junk makes a profit.

Re: OT Car battery's

#28

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Not buying it...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Those things you mentioned for increased braking capacity only get you so far. You still have to deal with heat dissipation to prevent brake fade, and increasing the diameter of the disc is still the cheapest and easiest way to do that.

What I laid out was also not just about capability, but the weight of the vehicles themselves--my '90 F150 weighed about 4300 lbs empty. A similar F150 from just a couple years ago comes in closer to 6000. Add in that many SUVs are based on trucks (and their bodies are much heavier than an open bed), driven by people who don't realize they're trucks, and you see a need for better brakes through bigger wheels. Sure, 16", 17", 20" and larger were first brought about by customizers, but the automakers sure didn't take long to latch on to them for other reasons--trucks being mostly advertised on their hauling/pulling capabilities, much less so on their bling factor.

Jason

Re: OT Car battery's

#29

You made my point for me...

John in NM

People were putting big tires on their trucks aftermarket, so manufacturers started making them standard in an attempt to gain market share. Guys like big tuff looking tires (I do too), and that sells more trucks.

You can pull the same 10,000 pound trailer with a 1970's 3/4 ton truck as you can pull with a modern one. Modern trucks simply tend to do so with a little more acceleration and speed, which might not even be a good thing.

17" wheels are simply not necessary for non-commercial vehicles.... but they do make for a much more expensive tire bill.

Re: OT Car battery's

#30

Re: Not buying it...

John McGaw (Bodger)

Wheel diameters vary for a number of reasons, some technical and some esthetic. Early Model T Fords had 30" diameter wheels and clincher tiers. When balloon tires were offered the wheels were downsized to 21". Seeing huge mis-sized wheels with the wrong offsets mounted with knobby tires on a 4WD truck that has to be modified so that they can stick out 8" from the fenders is just laughably wrong, especially since the most rugged 'off-road' use most of them will ever see is the mall parking lot. On the whole, my biggest complaint is that super-tall wheels mounted with super-low-profile tires results in a harsh ride that even the best suspension cannot mask; and face it, most of the time these vehicles aren't being called on to handle or brake like sports cars and that is where that combination really shines. Ferraris come with 19" and 20" wheels for a real reason.