We are going to be moving to town from our farm and I'm going to need a new shop. Am trying to decide whether to go the basement route, or add on to a garage, if feasible. I,m just in the planning/dreaming stage right now, not even putting the farm on the market til spring. What would you do in the basement to get it ready for a shop/ Am wondering...stud walls? Just thinking about running the wiring. Anyhow, any and all ideas welcomed. I'm really spoiled after having a two car garage shop with a nice woodstove and everything very handy.
I've got a basement shop. I started with an unfinished basement and went from there. I've got cinder block walls on the perimeter and a stud wall separating the shop part from the office/den part. I also enclosed the utilities (hot water heater and furnace).
The wiring was easy as I was able to run Romex in the floor joists to the stud walls and the perimeter walls. As I had cinder block - I had to run conduit.
Pros on my basement shop:
Conditioned space - heat or AC.
Less expense - walls were there - so I had to just install a ceiling and a fourth wall to separate.
Cons:
I've a daylight basement - but I still have to get lumber, tools, etc. around the house and in the basement door. Which means down a slope... Finished work has to get out of the basement - which is a standard door.
Noise from the DC system to the rest of the house.
I have only had basements shops essentially identical to JL, one with daylight basement(best) and one without.
Pros: It is handy. One can work 15 min sessions in the shop because it stays warm/cool and ready to go. After living with a basement shop I would find working in an unattached building inconvenient.
Cons: Lack of natural lighting and being able to look outdoors to see what is about. It has been a challenge to get sufficient light, but it can be done.
Neutral: I don't find the logistics of getting stuff in and out an issue at all, and I have to navigate stairs. However, I have stair access from garage with 36" door as well as living area stairs.
When we made a bedroom in out basement, I put in a Bilco door rather than an access window. The door make access easier for everything. No more winding stairs. Jerry
I have a basement shop and I agree with everything JL and Bill said. I have a wide outside stairway entry to my basememnt shop with double doors. Except for the stairs, it pretty much resolves the access issue. I just moved a 600 lb jointer/planer into my shop. It went down the stairs fairly easily (a block and tackle is your friend). I'll let someone else worry about getting it out.
The one thing I really dislike about my shop is the concrete floor. I may eventually put in a wood floor, but that would be SO MUCH easier if you do it from the start, before you get a lot of heavy machinery and benches in place.
I have a cyclone in my shop and the noise is not particlarly annoying. I put it in a sound insulated closet that keeps the noise at an acceptable level. If you're building from scratch, I recommend soundproofing an area for your DC. I also recommend planning an enclosed area that vents to the outside for finishing. That would help keep solvent odors out of the living quarters.
Plan lots of lighting. I love shops with lots of natural light and a view; but, unless you have a unique basement, those things are pretty much unavailable. Lots of good light makes the place cheerful and a pleasant place to work.
Finally, put in lots of electrical outlets. Unless you have a layout that you're happy with, I recommend that you not tie yourself to one layout from the git-go by selective placement of outlets. I've been in my basment shop 25 years and I've added new equipment and rearranged it a half dozen times. It's nice to not have to worry about whether the electrical outlets will work with a different configuration.
I have had both kinds of shops - detached (garage) and basement. I think I prefer my basement shop because of the conveninece Bill talked about. It's nice to be able to walk downstairs for a few minutes work without having to go outside, especially in the winter or the middle of the night.
Our club it looking for a new shop as well. I am doing the research for it and although a number of things we are looking at will not apply for you I did find a very good possibility for one scenario that would work well. First let me say I would not do a basement work shop unless all other options were unreachable. I found that for $25 to $35 a square foot finished you can have a dream shop 40' X 60' which would come out to about $60K. That would be a building with heat, A/C, elect. fully insulated windows doors and ready to go. I found these guys to be very good in all aspects of the project
just another thing to think about. Basement shops can flood. It could be from a hurricane or major watermain break in the house. Flooding is much less a danger if your shop is at grade or slightly above. Just my two cents worth. Andy
40'x60' That sounds like heaven. Built my dream shop six years ago 26'x32'. In floor heat (wonderful) . Keep the shop at 55 degrees .
One of many innovations was to place three separate 220v circuits in the floor before the concrete was poured. Made powering the big machines convenient.
Wall outlets every 4'. Lots of 8' two tube lights.
I didn't have the option for a basement shop (1880's home on crawl space). But I don't think I would have used it anyway. I built my shop so the entrance door is about 6' from the back door of my house. When I built the 30 X 30 shop, I used 2X6 walls on 16" center, Truss roof with a 10' wide X 30' room upstairs (drop ladder). I installed an insulated 9' X 8' garage door and all thermo-pane windows and entrance door. I also set 3 blocks high on the foundation so my ceiling height is 10' (hard to do in most basements). I installed my high efficiency NG furnace upstairs with central air. I wrapped the outside of the shop with house wrap and the inside walls and ceiling with heavy plastic prior to installing the drywall. I wired the shop with 120V 20 amp outlets a little over 4' high on every other stud. Then added extra outlets where ever I thought I might need one - installed several 240V 30 amp outlets (think it is 9) & one 60 amp for welder, with a 100 amp entrance fed underground from my 200A house entrance. By super insulating the shop it probably costs an average of less than $50 a month to heat in the coldest months of the winter and less than $40 to cool in the worst of the summer (around $500 / year in all utilities added). I keep the shop around 70 ~ 75 year around (warmer in the winter). The biggest advantages of the separate shop are the 10' ceilings, all noise and dust isolated from the home, very easy to unload heavy equipment and supplies & move out finished products. No moisture issues - great daylight lighting, and I can leave it in a complete mess with no hassle from SWMBO (course no woodworker does that right?). Although I don't work on my vehicle any longer, my woodworking equipment is almost all mobile and my sons and grandsons do occasionally use the shop to work on theirs.
I think that the first thing would be to identify what type and size of work you plan on doing and what type and size of equipment you plan on having.
Lunchbox planer or monster 24" cast iron antique.
Lugging stuff up and down stairs will be a constant as will noise, vibration, dust and fumes. ( fumes go through the whole house)
I like cranking the music up while i work, I have to have the music loud to get over the din from the phase converter, compressor and machinery.
I have had basement shops: once rented a shop that had no windows in, it was like a prison, you had no idea of what kind of a day it was outside. In the winter it was dark when i went to work in the morning and dark when i went home at night. Not my idea of spending a pleasant time.
I also had a shop that got flooded; again not pleasant to find everything under two or three feet of water.
For my money you cant beat an above ground shop, bright and sunny with lots of windows and doors. Best would be to have a great view outside your window; that is a nice way to work.
Also if you have a dog, its nice to not have it locked in a noisy shop: with an above ground shop they can hang around outside and you can still be company for each other.
I often work with the doors open and get to enjoy beautiful sunny days and warm breeze.
My shop these days is just a three bay garage, with only one window at the moment, I hope to put in a few more windows in the new year.
Hank and anyone else interested in flooring, I also have a basement, had it all my woodworking career. I don`t think I`d do it any other way. The big thing is if I would build an outside shop, around here the taxes would be prohibited. But about the floor what I did for a chusion was to go to carpet stores or take our old carpet when we redid it, was to take it up carefully and put it down in the shop. I also put the pad down with it. It`s surprizing how well it works and it was free. Larry
I just or I should say I am in the process of finishing my shop. I have 10 dedicated 220VAC ckts and 18 110VAC I put only one in the ceiling for my TS because the floor was there I don't know that I would do any in the floor but that's just because of the way I have the lay out arranged
I just got my A/C and heat in. (1.5 TON window unit) All that's left is the ceiling and cabinets then paint the floor.
My concrete floored shop has a 3'x5' anti-fatigue rubber mat at each work station. ( purchased from a restaurant supply company)-----> makes a big difference.
James - I've been following this thread with great interest because I finished my garage/shop about 2 years ago. When we added a new room to the house, we expanded the three car garage so that I've got room for two cars AND an 18 x 22 shop.
Insulated roll-up doors and two nice big windows and this is my ideal shop. In the winter I close the doors and crank on the radiant heater; nice and toasty. Of course this is Southern California where 60 degrees is considered cold. In the summer, the doors come open and the breeze comes in with tons of natural light.
When I was planning the shop I used a bunch of miniature Jet tools that I got as a Christmas present and moved them around a paper floor plan until I had a workable layout. Then I put in all the electrical outlets I thought I'd need, then doubled it. So far, it's paid off; I can't believe how many tools I have with tails.
I would advise against a basement shop primarily because of the access and light questions, but, then, I had room for the attached shop which made the decision easy.
Good luck with your project and keep asking questions. My guess is that in this vast array of knowledge and experience known as Wood Central, someone has been there before and is willing to share their pros and cons.
Depends on how many hours a week you will be working in the shop. I love the basement idea since it takes almost no extra energy to air condition or heat. I work at a full time day job, and would hate to be keeping a separate shop at temp. year round. My garage is a mess in the spring as the concrete warms up and everything wants to rust. I have a walk out basement, which is the best situation. I've brought in some really heavy cast iron, with no trouble at all. The furnace doesn't seem to mind the dust too much. It is a partially closed utility room, so sees a little dust, but not direct exposure.