Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

Posts

Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

#1

Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

Derek Arita

I recently purchased this DC based on research I'd done. All that research said that this DC produces 1600 CFM. I happened to be on the Laguna sight today and found that this DC is rated at 1450CFM. Being confused, I called Laguna and asked is it 1600 or 1450? The guy I spoke with at Laguna said, "I don't know." He said the manual for the DC says it's 1600, but the website says 1450. He said he would bring it up with someone.

Now I'm kinda bugged, since I did purchase this DC based on the 1600CFM rating. Had I know it was 1450CFM, if it is, I may not have chosen this DC. If it is 1600, I'm still kinda bugged, because Laguna doesn't even know what it's own DC is really rated at...not exactly a confidence builder.

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

#2

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

doug f, san clemente, ca

Derek - Laguna has never gotten gold stars for customer service, and this is another sad example.

About a year ago I was in the market for cross cut attachment for my Laguna TSS (12" sliding table saw.) I spent two days and a couple phone calls to find out if they had one in stock and how much it was. Never got a good answer, so I gave it up and designed by own sled. There's a quick $400 sale they missed because no one knew the inventory.

Sad, because they do have some remarkable tools.

Doug

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

#3

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

Barry Irby

I understand you are bugged and I get it.

OTOH, The difference may not be terribly significant. My understanding is the CFM through any of these machines is highly variable and depends on may factors, such as whether the filters are clean/right out of the box or if they are caked with dust as they will be soon after you start using it. Also the size and length of your ducting will dramatically affect it. Something as simple as whether the initial run is a long full sized piece of straight pipe or a fitting such as an elbow will affect it. The list goes on and on. Still not a good excuse for sloppy reporting on their part. I suspect the numbers are the best it will ever do, new, clean and with little or no pipe or hose attached and bear little relationship to the real world.

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

#4

Talk to Rick

McKay

I have had had really poor communication with some of the Laguna people and have found that the only person that you can talk to and get superior service is Rick Karrigan. There may be others, but ....

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

#5

Bob

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

Bob

The only number I ever saw that was true is a circular saw blade... but I never really measured on tooth to tooth so that may not be true as well.

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

#6

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

Derek Arita

I know there is an error somewhere, but I really don't know who's error it is and which number is right. I have a feeling that the manual is correct in 1600CFM/11" Static Pressure, but that means that Laguna's own website has it wrong.

At any rate, it's disheartening that those numbers really don't mean a lot. I don't understand why there's no standard that we manufacturers can go by. I guess if they did that, then they'd have to play on a level playing field and I don't think any of them want that.

Wonder if anyone out there has done some real world testing on the DCs and produced some real numbers. A while back, someone was doing that, but he and his cohorts got embroiled in some kind of weird situation and that only clouded the info. Too bad, cause the info was helpful while it lasted. I think it even resulted in a really efficient, home built, reasonably priced, kit cyclone.

Not all of us are equipped to interpolate all the numbers and come up with meaningful info.So how do we do it? How do we get manufacturers to Man Up and give numbers that we can compare, as Joe and Mary Beercan consumers?

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

#7

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

John McGaw (Bodger)

Does the tool do the job for which it was purchased? Would you be able to detect the difference which 150CFM might make in the performance? To me, these seem to be more important questions than a possible spec disagreement. After all, the most minute difference in duct smoothness or fitting geometry will affect performance as much or more.

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

#8

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

Derek Arita

You're right John. I know in the real world, I'll probably not notice the difference. However, as a consumer, I'd like to know that what I thought I was buying, was really what I was buying. Also, the knowledge that Laguna themselves, didn't know which rating was correct, is a bit concerning.

When I bought the Laguna, I was comparing it's 1600CFM to the JDS 1700CFM and throw in the Oneida, along with unit price, shipping, etc., because that's really all I had to go by. If, in fact, the Laguna is rated at 1450CFM, then that might have changed everything.

Not being an expert at DCs, I can only go by the numbers given, but it would be nice to know that the numbers given, are the correct numbers. After that, I know that real world suction will depend on all the different parameters of my setup.

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

#9

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

larry in nw ohio

Derek I wish you would have come here first, you would have been directed to the Bill Penz.com site. He has done a great deal of reserch on DC. I advise you to go there. Larry

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

#10

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

What about vacuum cleaners which are small DC. A true 1 HP motor pulls about 10 to 12 amps on 115 vac. So how can Sears, HDepot, Lowes, or Shopvac sell 7 HP vacuums for use on household outlets on 15/20 amp circuits? Most powertool manufacturers are LIERS. Get used to it. Same thing is true on air compressors. Truth in advertising should be on the menu for 2016.

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

#11

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

Derek Arita

Bill Penz! That's the guy! He's the guy I remember as the guru of DC. I should have looked him up before. Thanks for that.

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

#12

Re: Laguna 2HP DC...1600 or 1450 CFM?

John Lucas

Bill I've been doing research on Photo quality CFL bulbs. You talk about lying. They rate their 85watt bulb and say it is equivalent to 675 watts. Near as I can tell by placing the bare bulbs in a socket and standing 8 feet away in a dark room it measures about the same as an 85watt incandescent. That's a long way from 675 watts. It's also rated at 55K and I measured it closer to 65K.

I have another lamp that is 45watt. It says it is equal to 300 watts. I find it measures a hair over 45 watts with an incandescent bulb. It's Kelvin temperature is also much cooler than 55K. Don't remember what it was maybe 68K or so.