Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

World Series question

Posts

World Series question

#1

World Series question

Bill Tindall

Background: We have several regional minor league teams. I watch several games a year, live. I never watch a televised majors game except occasionally a World Series game. Well this year it has been part of a game. I can't stand it.

There are 12 players and coaches on the field playing a part in the game, plus umps and potential base runners. They are all doing stuff for each pitch, especially so the 3rd base coach and runners. I have never felt the need to bring a 50X spotting scope to a game to focus on the pitchers face before each pitch, or the pitching team's coach in the dougout, or some fan in left filed.

If there are base runners I focus my attention on them and the position of the fielders before and during each pitch. The ump is there to call balls and strikes so I have no need to train a spotting scope on the ball crossing the plate. I think others attending the game are similarly engaged.

Now the question: Why is it that TV coverage spends time in the following decreasing order of importance- pitchers full screen face, ball crossing plate, coach in doughout, fan in left filed? Anything of major interest that happens on the field is covered in instant reply, when there is time. Rarely seen are the runner and fielder positions before and during a pitch or signals from the 3 rd base coach. They put an icon in the corner of the screen to provide a clue that there is even anyone on base!

I don't get the disconnect in priority between the TV editor and a fan on site, nor why the fan at home tolerates the picture priority. I would rather watch the commercials than endless closeups of the pitcher's face or the catchers crotch.

Thankfully hockey moves to quick, well not this year, to provide the opportunity for a TV editor to spend the game focused on someone's head. As it is they don't pull back enough to see plays develop across the ice.

Re: World Series question

#2

Really a question about TV sports

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Bill: agreed - it is difficult to appreciate thee subtleties of pretty much any sport on TV, unless of course you are interested in how close a shave the 'actors' have. Since TV soccer (my sport of choice) often has a wide view, it is a little easier to see the "off ball" action (the subtleties you mention like player positioning).

I never quite was sure why I liked live baseball when TV baseball only keeps my interest for about 30 seconds. Even though my understanding of the game doesn't quite rise to yours, at least live you have the chance to view other aspects.

A similar though reverse order experience: When I had my first opportunity to attend a big time college football game, I honestly found my self missing all the replays and highlights of TV. Then I woke up and realized I was watching only the things the TV shows. Instead of relentlessly trying to follow the ball, I would focus on one player for several consecutive plays - I learned a lot more and enjoyed it more too. Fascinating to watch the battle at the line, or the position of the safeties...

Henry

Re: World Series question

#3

Re: World Series question

Dave's Not Here

The reality is that baseball is a game that's primary focus is between the pitcher and the batter. Without those two elements there would be nothing at all to watch thus the focus of attention is on them. Until the bat meets the ball or the pitcher fails to throw the ball across the plate four times the other players on the field have nothing to do. The fan in the outfield bleachers is shown so that the entire audience can hopefully watch him make an ass of himself.

Re: World Series question

#4

Re: World Series question

Stuart Johnson

Going down memory lane. Remember the excitement when the series was day games on the radio? Every bank, bar and most business with an inter-com would have the game on with people packed around listening.

The announcers could make you see and feel the game as well as hear it.

Re: World Series question

#5

Main World Series question in Michigan.....

roger lance

Will the Tigers show up ?? The subtleties of the game maybe more difficult to show than the emotion.

Re: World Series question

#6

closet woodworkers

Jerry Gibbs

Playing with their toys is all the fun.

Re: World Series question

#7

Game is s l o w

Gary Smyth

Television directors actions reflect the poor attention span of the audience. Baseball is painfully slow for television – and also in person. For baseball purists that is a virtue, but for the majority of viewers, in real time it is like watching paint dry. Count the director’s cuts. (HURRY, there may be only one game remaining this year.) If the typical shot averages more than four seconds the director will be chastised for not running the show – which can be completely independent of the workings of the game. With nine or more cameras for the World Series plus the CG, slo-mo, pitch grid, corner game situation icon, and replay operator(s), directors run a routine for each pitch (so the TD and various operators are ready and don’t screw up) with cameras assigned only to their “sections” of the field so that a play is covered no matter what happens with the ball. With 50 to 1 optical zoom lenses and quality digital zoom available in the truck, if the operators are not otherwise engaged eating nachos there should never be a missed play. To waste more time between actual game happenings at least two other cameras are assigned specifically to look for people attending that game. So if you want to take away the shots of the face of the pitcher then speed up the game with three new rules. 1. No equipment other than a helmet and the bat for the batter (no gloves, shin guards, elbow pads). 2. Once in the batter’s box the batter cannot leave during that at bat except to fall down, replace a broken bat, or run to the base. 3. Put the pitcher on a twenty second clock . Do those things and TV baseball won’t show the pitcher’s mug so often because the game will move too quickly for that to occur. Never happen of course, because the network and advertisers will lose a minimum fifteen ads per game.

Re: World Series question

#8

Answer.....not yet.


Re: World Series question

#9

Re: Game is s l o w

Bill Howatt

Yes, the pace of the game requires filler.

I'm not a baseball nut or actually a sports nut of any kind but years ago when Toronto was in contention for and finally in the World Series I was watching some games. Later I had a chance to go to the Skydome in Toronto to see a game and I found I missed being able to see the ball curve, slide over the plate liike I could see on TV. I congratulate the cameramen for being able to track the balls after they are hit - most times I lost sight of the ball against the closed stadium roof.

Bill

Re: World Series question

#10

You Are So Right

Dave's Not Here

It isn't just baseball either. All sports from the college level on up are more about advertising revenue than the sporting event itself. If you want to watch how these games were meant to be played, go to a high school game. You'll really enjoy yourself!

Re: World Series question

#11

Alan Young

World Series? Was there a Series?-A Tiger fan :^(


Re: World Series question

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

No kidding.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

But, look on the bright side.

The Tigers were 7-6 in the postseason (0.538) and 88-74 in the regular season (0.543), so they played about the same, on average. They also spent much of the season below 0.500.

And sweeping the Yankees is a pretty good consolation prize. :D

Another Tigers fan wishing that had gone differently...

Jason

Re: World Series question

#13

There was a World Series?

Brian from Monument

Really? Was there a team from Cuba, Dominican Republic, Japan, Taiwan?

Maybe not such a world series.

Perhaps it should be called the USA series!

But do I care? Not really, I dont watch mlb.

When, I was a kid, I was a NYMets fan.

Pete Rose was the nemesis of the mets.

And used by mlb as an advertizing image. Charlie hustle.....

Now inspite of the fact that his records have been unbeaten, he has yet to be eligible to enter the hall of fame.

Re: World Series question

#14

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: There was a World Series?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Teams from other countries? No, but there are quite a few nations represented on most rosters.

Jason

Re: World Series question

#15

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

P.S.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I actually got to see Pete Rose play in about 1985. Dad always liked the Dodgers, so when we were living in Madison, IN--about an hour's drive from Cincinnati--he took us to Riverfront Stadium to see a Reds/Dodgers doubleheader. I think those are the only MLB games I've ever seen in person (I may have previously gone to a Brewers game with my uncle in Wisconsin, but the memory is fuzzy on that--could have been a minor league game that was played in Milwaukee County Stadium).

Players today could use a little more hustle. From what I saw in the playoffs, there would have been quite a few more close calls at first base--and perhaps a few more hits--if the players ran out their infield grounders.

Jason

Re: World Series question

#16

Re: World Series question

Mike Circ

Not specific to World Series. Here in the Chicago area, Cubs fans with certain cable TV providers can pick their way to enjoy the games. Uverse has a setup for all the Cubs home games where there are 8 or 10 channels each piped from a specific TV camera on the field. One watches the runner, one ground level behind third base, one from the outfield, etc.. They are probably used for production cutaways, TV replays and other uses. Really cool way to experience the game from home.

That being said.... I'm a Sox fan so I couldn't care less.

(Still a cool system)

Re: World Series question

#17

So, Being A White Sox Fan........

Dave's Not Here

Does that mean that you won't be dancing in the streets when the Cubs finally win the World Series in 2079? :D