Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

(OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

Posts

(OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

#1

Moses Yoder

(OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

Moses Yoder

We have a Meijer credit card and occasionally get a 20% off coupon, plus my wife works there and gets a 10% discount, so I could buy the latest I-Pad for about $372. I would add a keyboard which I think I would have to order at a cost of about $69. A laptop would cost me around $500 plus I would have to buy Microsoft Works at a little over a hundred dollars and would also buy a keyboard and wireless mouse. Mostly I want the ability to do some word processing but nothing too fancy, look at photographs (I read that I can take good pics and video with the I-Pad) and also browse my favorite internet forums. I would use WIFI at restaurants or the library or hotels and would not spend the money to subscribe to internet. Do you think the I-Pad is a reasonable option for this versus buying a low end laptop?

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

#2

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My wife owns an IPad, and has found that she could not get software called "Flash," which is needed for a lot of online videos and the like. So, for her, it's been an imperfect alternative to a laptop. That said, we found it quite helpful on vacation; I was even able to keep up with Wood Central.

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

#3

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

John McGaw (Bodger)

I think that your estimate for a laptop is rather excessive if you are a light user. I'd say $400 tops for an i3-class laptop with no need to add any hardware at all. It should still be far faster than an iPad at everything and with a 14" screen will be easier on the eyes. Software is another question but, if Works is essential, how much will it cost to add it to the iPad?

I was looking at the ads I got in my email overnight and see that the Acer Aspire AS4830T-6682 can be had for $400 with free shipping. It comes with some sort of introductory version of Office which, despite showing ads, might do whatever word processing you need until you decide whether you want Works or not. Me, I'd download OpenOffice for free and install that.

Just my $0.02 of course...

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

#4

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I have a Toshiba net book with MS office installed so I can do word processing and put together powerpoint presentations for school. In that use it has been exactly what I needed and at $300 its been a good value. The down side is that it has windows 7 starter edition and there ahave been a couple of times where that has been a problem.

I do most of my email and a fair bit of internet reading on my android smart phone. A year ago I ditched my old merchant services account and saved $20/month in service fees and switched over to square. The savings over a year have just about paid for the phone. I didn't think I would really get into the whole smart phone thing but I really like having it. and find yself using it more and more. I have problems with being able to see up close so I figured I would never want to watch a movie on my phone. I was wrong about that and I actually enjoy the ability to get net flix on my phone and supposedly hulu will be abailable soon on android.

For me the combination of a smart phone and a net book works well. If I didn't need to produce handouts and presentations for my class the smart phone alone might be enough.

Robin

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

#5

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

Jesse Cloud

Why would you need to buy microsoft works for the pc, but not the Ipad?

If all you need is simple word processing, there are several free word processors you can download.

My advice would be to try both the laptop and the iPad for browsing and word processing before buying.

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

#6

I like refurb laptops...

John in NM

You can get a nice Lenovo, maybe 3-5 years old, from Tiger or similar for $200-$300. For word processing, download openoffice or libreoffice - the open source bunch got mad at Oracle or whoever bought openoffice, so now they've spun off another, very similar clone. It all seems very similar in use to me, and they all have versions that will run on Windows.

The last computer I bought for my wife has Windows 7, and they seem to have finally accepted what has been obvious for 20 years -- people prefer free software and there are other products available aside from MS. So the new one came with a free limited version of MS Office, which actually recognizes the open source file formats.

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

#7

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

Mark

iPad for word processing even with keyboard is cumbersome. As for Internet browsing , downloading movies to watch when travelling, maps and gps , and all the many many apps you can get that are not really available with a laptop ....it's great

I use my iPad for writing this, and just about all Internet browsing but when I need to do any word processing it's back to the laptop or desktop.

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

#8

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

Bill Howatt

I don't have an iPad but bought a Blackberry Playbook only because it was cheap and I wanted to see what the tablet fuss was about. I have used if for email, web-browsing, reading Kindle books. If I am on a forum and want to enter a reply, I quickly throw it away and get a real computer (laptop or desktop) to do my touch-typing on.

We bought prior to the Playbook a W7 netbook for travel. Reason was it has a 93% full-size keyboard that closes up and offers automatic screen protection and I'd sooner deal with the Windows OS. So far the only good thing I've seen about the tablet format is that they are handier to pass around a table for people to look at pictures. However, I do see them as being handy for certain "work" applications such as inventory control and things you can do by selecting displayed options.

I was going to load Office Libre onto the netbook but it came with a free MS Office starter edition which is more than enough for our purposes. The big problem with some netbooks is the Intel Atom processor and related chipset is rather gutless.

Different strokes for different folks though.

Bill

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

#9

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

NickinMass

I definitely come down in the laptop/netbook camp. I've spent very little time with the iPad, but the time that I did was irritating (lot of zooming in and out/scrolling to deal with websites and the virtual keyboard is incredibly inefficient/irritating). If I were in sales or doing something where I needed to show presentations/video/photos to one or two other people, I could see using a tablet, and maybe for blown-up versions of iPhone games, but that's about it.

I've seen people taking video with iPads at various events - it's an incredibly bad form factor for video, and I believe the only zoom is "digital zoom", which is just enlarges a portion of the shot. But if you don't have a good video camera or digital camera, it is certainly better than nothing.

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

#10

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

William Duffield

I have the new iPad.

If you want to use the iPad for navigation, be aware that the WiFi-only models do not have GPS capability. Apple doesn't tell you that. If you are using a cell phone as a WiFi hotspot for 3G access from the iPad, the cell phone will not send its GPS coordinates over the WiFi connection to the iPad, so there's no way the iPad can figure out where it is with any accuracy.

The keyboard I have, made by ZAGG and sold by Logitech, which fits the new iPad, but was designed for the iPad 2, works OK, but the iPad likes to fall out of it, and onto the floor, especially if you are typing on your knees. Also, the low battery light is never visible when you are using it, and it only has one delete key (delete back, but not delete forward). Perhaps the new keyboard, with security magnets. is better, but it is about $30 more. Of course, there are other recently developed keyboards out there.

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

#11

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

Ed in NY

Moses, I kind of see them as two different animals. While I don't have an iPad, I have an iPod touch and a Kindle Fire along with a Laptop. I find the Ipad/iPod Touch type of devises more as browsers or platforms to use apps, especially for hobbies like ours. Laptops are for more involved taskes like word processing, spreadsheets, video production, etc, where you have to buy and use programs. Now I know you can do all that on the iPad but it's just not the same. I actually find a lot of usess for both of them!

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

#12

Me too

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Bought the (refurbished) laptop I'm typing this on at an online boxing day sale last Christmas. $479 for a 17.3" quad-core laptop, with Blue-Ray reader, 8 GB RAM, etc. Of course I couldn't keep it stock, so I added a SSD in the second drive bay and installed Linux on it. Really flies.

However it's a sizeable chunk of hardware, not really convenient when commuting via public transit (I tried). Prior to that I had a netbook that I ended up handing down to my eldest son. That one was hot-rodded too (The AMD CPUs are much better than Intel's in that size format, and swapping the hard drive for an SSD really boosts speed, as does extra RAM). My main issues with the machine is the screen size (eyesight is not getting any better), and the keyboard was a bit cramped. Otherwise this thing is a champ.

When the iPad came out I looked at it and found it interesting (all my sisters own one), but I am allergic to Apple, its business model and its philosophy. So I waited until Android became mature enough and bought a LG Optimus Pad (it sold under a different name in the US). I have the 3G model as my main use for the pad is commuting and there's no consistent wifi coverage in my commute. I find it pretty good for content consumption, but it pretty much sucks when it comes to write on the thing. Bluetooth keyboard really helps, but in my case I have the extra issue of French accents, which don't work (or at least I haven't found a way) on the BT keyboard.

I also have a smartphone (Samsung Galaxy Nexus), and even with its comparatively large screen, it is painful to use as a "tablet". Can't even see which bird is to be launched in Angry Birds Space :D

I should add that I haven't bought any software for all these machines, there is plenty of applications available for free out there. In particular, LibreOffice will nicely replace MS Office for all but the most complex documents.

My advice is worth the price you pay for it I guess, but I would recommend getting a refurbished laptop (I bought a nice 15" model recently for a friend, $300), and an Android tablet that you should be able to find for $200 or so (mine is an 8.9" model, I wouldn't go any smaller). Just make sure it runs Android 4.0 or higher.

HTH, DC

Re: (OT) Laptop versus I-Pad

#13

Laptop with Openoffice

Jason Waters

An ipad is no substitute for a laptop.

You may want to consider a notebook. If you can handle the smaller keyboard and screen, it would give you better portability.

As to Microsoft office, if it's just for you skip it I say, and download the free OpenOffice Suite which I did for my mom, dad, and my wife's computer. It does just about anything you need to at home, and the files are mostly compatible with office.

And I would look in the $350-400 range. try to get more memory like 4 gb or more, and get HDMI out so you can hook to an HDMI TV if you want.