Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Wood Smoke Safety

Posts

Wood Smoke Safety

#1

Lee Gordon

Wood Smoke Safety

Lee Gordon

I recently completed a project using maple, walnut and jatoba that left me with a good sized pile of jointer/planer shavings.

I have a stove-top smoker that I occasionally use to smoke some shrimp and I know the maple is safe to use as a smoking wood, but what about the walnut or jatoba? Are there any health/safety issues using either of those woods?

Re: Wood Smoke Safety

#2

Ellis Walentine

I wouldn't use them

Ellis Walentine

Hi Lee,

I think the question you need to ask is what is the smoke flavor you want to impart to your meals? I've tried a lot of woods and I've narrowed it down to one wood that I prefer for flavor, and that is apple. Cherry imparts a very sweet, fruity flavor that is too intense for me. Hickory and mesquite impart a more acrid flavor that complements red meats like beef and venison, but they're a little too rough for fish, poultry and pork.

To your question, I personally don't care for walnut smoke at all, and I've never tried jatoba but I suspect it might be tasty. I've not heard of safety or health problems with either, but I don't have any evidence to support that.

Ellis

Re: Wood Smoke Safety

#3

Re: Wood Smoke Safety

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I doubt there would be any "safety" issues, but I agree with Ellis. You might end up with a very bitter tasting shrimp. I often use Cherry scraps from the shop and tree trimmings from my Apple and Cherry trees. I am pretty lax about trimming them so when I need some for the smoker I just clip a couple small branches - saves soaking in water. I have kept dry cherry shop cut off scrap soaking in a bucket for several weeks with a brick on top. Just pull out and use as needed. I have also used Hickory and oak scraps, they are a little stronger /bitter flavor.

Re: Wood Smoke Safety

#4

Re: Wood Smoke Safety

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

l have what might be a lifetime supply of walnut and I love the way it smells in the fireplae but I'm not fond of what it does to meat. lately Ive been partial to using olive wood to flavor meat with. it's hearty enough for beef but won't over power poultry. For something really special try olive wood with lamb. About the only think I don't use olive with is fish, but that is because I prefer fish over a charcoal grill with out any wood chips.

Robin

Re: Wood Smoke Safety

#5

JL

Re: Wood Smoke Safety

JL

The juglone and similar compounds in walnut impart a more bitter taste in my opinion - or it could be the tannins. I would avoid walnut.

I would probably avoid jatoba as its oil would probably not be that tasty.

Different people have different tastes. Not everyone enjoys the same cuisines. So give whatever woods you want to try a taste test. It could be that a little hint of walnut or jatoba might add a little extra piquancy to whatever you are smoking. Ditto for other woods. I have a friend who goes through my wood scraps on a regular basis. He makes his own "custom" blends for his smoker.