Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Router collet questions

Posts

Router collet questions

#1

Router collet questions

Jerrid Edgington

I'm looking at getting a plunge router to start doing some small woodworking projects and I'm new at this. I've been reading that you can get either 1/4 or 1/2 inch collets. I've noticed people are saying you should go with a 1/2 inch collet. Being new at this why is that and should I get a 1/2 inch vs a 1/4 inch collet ? Thank you for your help all.

Jerrid

Re: Router collet questions

#2

Re: Router collet questions

Tony - memphis

I started with a 1/4" and eventually upgraded. One reason I upgraded was that there were some bits that were only available in 1/2". Also, with a 1/2", you can use a collet to use 1/4" bits.

For reference, I use a Hitachi M12 in my table and a Bosch 1617 for everything else. The Bosch kit is pretty nice (fixed and plunge bases and 1/4" collet included - came with an edge guide too).

Now, depending on what you are going to build and how far into woodworking you will venture, the new smallish routers (Bosch Colt and DeWalt come to mind) are really nice. I have the Colt and love it. I will buy th eplunge base fo rit when it is available (just announced). They are 1/4" and you can do lots of things with them that don't require the extra hp or larger bits. Check some of the magazine reviews for more info.

Enjoy your new toy! Be careful. Even a simple table is a good idea (Rockler has a neat mini router table - you can build one easy though). Take a look at Bill Hylton and Carol ??? (darnit - can't recall her last name) books for tips, techniques, and above all safety information. Watch your feed direction and your fingers. Especially with the smaller routers, they can be held with one hand ans it is too easy to get a finger close to the bit.

Tony

Re: Router collet questions

#3

Re: Router collet questions

roger lance

Get a router that has both 1/4" and 1/2" collets....most good routers do. The reason that a 1/2" collet is preferred is that router bits with a 1/2" shank have 4 times the mass of a 1/4" router shank and are more stable and generally give a smoother cut. There are certain router bits that only come in 1/4" shanks and so its best to have a router that also comes with that size collet.

Re: Router collet questions

#4

Re: Router collet questions

RobCarr

Yes. Both 1/4" and 1/2" collets are what you'll want to get. It only takes a minute to switch collets .

You can even get routers that have both plunge and fixed bases like the Porter-Cable 893PK shown here...

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B0000DCBK7/awh

Re: Router collet questions

#5

Re: Router collet questions

Jerrid Edgington

Should I get a fixed or plunge router ? What is better for a starter at woodworking and what are the benefits for each ? Sorry for all the questions I just want to get the right equipment.

Jerrid

Re: Router collet questions

#6

Re: Router collet questions

Merle

Tony, were you thinking of WC's very own Carol Reed, aka The Router Lady in a former life?

Re: Router collet questions

#7

Re: Router collet questions

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

As has been said the 1/2" collet is smoother, also many larger bits are not even offered in the 1/4" shank as it would bend or break. I have several routers. I would recommend you buy a router package consisting of a router motor, a fixed base and a plunge base. These run around $200 for the set. Stay away from the cheap Black and Decker, Craftsman and Skill sets as they are far from rigid and do not do a good job. One set of Porter Cable is http://www.amazon.com/Porter-Cable-693LRPK-Fixed-Router-Plunge/dp/B00006411C/ref=sr_1_28?s=hi&ie=UTF8&qid=1348270962&sr=1-28&keywords=router

Re: Router collet questions

#8

JL

Both.

JL

(Whatever does he mean...) I have a Porter Cable 890 series router. It has several different available bases in which the router motor can happen to fit. You just switch the router motor back and forth.

They work pretty well. I've got several 890 series bases. Porter Cable is currently working a deal in which you get a PC 390 K random orbital sander when you purchase a router.

I have a Dewalt plunge router that I also like.

Re: Router collet questions

#9

Joe Bradshaw

Re: Router collet questions

Joe Bradshaw

Jerrid, I agree that you should get a set with both bases. However, routers arte like Pringle Potatoe Chips, You can't have just one. Buy a router and use it. Then you will have a feel for what you need. I think that I have around 16 in various sizes. It is easier to change routers than to change router bits.

Re: Router collet questions

#10

Bob

Re: Router collet questions

Bob

Tony - memphis hit the nail on the head. The only other reason I can think of is you have a better selection of routers to pick from.

Re: Router collet questions

#11

Re: Router collet questions

Bruce, a MN Galoot

For starters, get a 1/2" router with a 1/4" collet, plunge for absolute certain. I'd also recommend one with a soft-start feature. Variable speed is nice, too. That combination will last you for a very long time. Then when you start to buy bits, get only 1/2" shank bits unless what you want only comes with a 1/4" shank.

I've had the same router for nearly 30 years, a 15 amp Makita plunge model. There are times I would like to have one dedicated to a router table, plus a trim router, but there's no hurry :)

Re: Router collet questions

#12

Re: Router collet questions

Jerrid Edgington

Would this be a good starter router for me to use ?

http://www.harborfreight.com/2-1-2-half-hp-plunge-router-37793.html

Re: Router collet questions

#13

Re: Router collet questions

Kurt

I would have second (and third) thoughts about the Harbor Freight router unless it were for VERY occasional use; Harbor Freight plug-in tools have checkered reputations. Some are fine, some self destruct after a few uses. How about this?

http://bigskytool.com/Hitachi_KM12VC_2-14_Peak_HP_Variable_Speed_FixedPlunge_Base_Router_Kit_%28Reconditioned%29___i307.aspx

1 year warranty through Hitachi. I've bought some reconditioned tools - not from that outfit though - and couldn't tell the difference from new. I've seen better user reports about Hitachi power tools than Harbor Freight power tools.

Re: Router collet questions

#14

craigd

Re: Router collet questions

craigd

A somewhat contrarian view: I find my PC 690 big and awkward for the stuff I do. I dearly love my PC 3101 trim router. I also have a DW 611 "compact" with two bases that is nice. Both these are ¼" only, which hasn't been an issue.

Re: Router collet questions

#15

JL

Friends don't let Friends buy HF.

JL

Avoid HF "tools". If you need/want a disposable tool - then fine.

I prefer "investing" in a tool. You buy a good (or great) tool once - even if you have to save. I made the mistake of buying an inexpensive router. It was difficult to get repeatable depths among other things.

What you want/need can be determined by you.

IMO - here are some things to look for.

Two collets - 1/4" and 1/2" - those cover the vast majority of router bits. The 1/2" router bits can be more "massive" and you can get more control and larger profiles. The 1/4" router bits are less expensive and work well for smaller things (not that the 1/2" bits won't).

Variable speed - I don't care if can't be "dialed" between several speeds (such as five) or has variable control. Smaller diameter bits can take the 23,000 rpm. Larger bits take less speed. THIS IS IMPORTANT! You need several speeds for safe operation.

Buy "reputable" - I don't care if it Bosch, Makita, Hitachi, Milwaukee, Porter Cable, Dewalt, Triton - etc. A router is going at 23,000 rpm. That's a lot of speed on the bit. You need a well machined router that works well.

Your money, your choice.

Re: Router collet questions

#16

Craigslist can be your friend

Bruce, a MN Galoot

There are a bunch of people who went out and bought good woodworking equipment, thinking that woodworking was going to be their new hobby. Then they never used it. If you aren't in a hurry, keep a lookout for one of the good models, gently used. I'm looking for a router to be dedicated to a router table, and Craigslist is going to be where I will get it.

But I wouldn't get a HF router, unless I intended it to be disposable.

Re: Router collet questions

#17

2 nd on the PC 690 items

del schisler

i have 5 routers and 5 tables and have the 690's 2 of them and a bosch 1617 a couple ridgid with tables for my dovetales ect. and the router work shop table the main one . I would check into the router work shop web site for more info http://www.routerforums.com/

Re: Router collet questions

#18

Harbor Freight not my shop for tool's

del schisler

i don't own any of the Harbor Freight stuff i wouldn't waste my time with their stuff. that is me so don't blast my post ??

Re: Router collet questions

#19

Re: Router collet questions

Jerrid Edgington

Thank you all for the input. I'm just trying to make sure I make the best choice before I go and buy the equipment cause I'm not a millionaire and don't want to waste money.

What is the difference between the plunge router vs fixed base ? Do I need both or can one be used for multiple purposes.

Do I need both the 1/2 inch collet and 1/4 inch collet or could I use the 1/2 inch collet for everything ?

Again, thanks for your input.

Re: Router collet questions

#20

Re: Router collet questions

Jim Dillon

Jerrid,

I find I use my plunge router far more than its fixed base companion. You will discover that, as your experience grows, a plunge router will enable you to do a lot more things that you never contemplated before. Be sure to get one that has both 1/2 and 1/4 inch collets as that router will then meet all your current and future needs. The router is such an important woodworking tool that I would stick with a name-brand, rather than Harbor Freight. The holiday season is soon approaching so, if you can hold off that long, good deals/rebates are likely to be found. Good luck!

Jim

Re: Router collet questions

#21

Re: Router collet questions

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

To answer your questions a "plunge" router does exactly what it says - When the router is in the "non-plunged" position the bit is above the base of the router - not cutting anything. As you push the router lower (plunge) it into the work, it begins to cut, an adjustable stop allows you to set the depth of cut when you plunge it completely down. This action allows you to make cuts that do not extend to the edge of the work. The standard base has some advantages in that it is normally better balanced and is easier to adjust for depth, but does require entry from an edge or hole in the workpiece. The other major use of a router is a router table. This is anything from a plywood board with a router screwed to it from the bottom and a fence (board) clamped to the plywood with wood clamps - to a dedicated router table with cabinet and micrometer adjustable fence. As you are asking questions that are pretty basic to router operation (only way you learn) -before you purchase anything, I would advise you to read a few books and / or watch some Utube demonstrations before laying out money for a router.

By the way I have several routers - mostly Porter Cable and have more money in bits than I do in the routers. My routers range from the largest PC plunge (3 1/2 hp) Model 7539 (I think) to the PC trim router.

Re: Router collet questions

#22

Re: Router collet questions

Hank Knight

Jerrid,

I'll try to answer your question about the difference between fixed base and plunge routers.

The motor on a fixed base router is fixed once the depth of cut is set. The bit protrudes below the base at the pre-set depth of cut. To make the cut the bit is presented to the work either from the edge for edge work, or by lowering the router onto the work for cuts away from the edge. Fixed base routers excel at edge work, like cutting edge profiles (round-overs, ogees and such) or flush trimming with a bearing-guided bit. Because placement of the spinning bit into the workpiece is imprecise, they are not so great at work away from the edge, such as cutting mortises or excavating inlays.

The motor on a plunge router slides up and down on two posts. After the depth of cut is set, the business end of the bit remains above the base. It is presented to the work by sliding the motor down to the pre-set depth of cut. To begin a cut away from the edge with a plunge router, you place the router base on the workpiece, line it up correctly, depress the off-on switch to start the motor and "plunge" the bit into the workpiece by sliding the motor down to the depth stop. This allows you to be much more accurate (and safe) when lining up a cut away from the edge of your work piece. For this reason plunge routers excel at such things as cutting mortises and dados away from the edge of a workpiece.

There are several devices on plunge routers that allow you to lock the motor at any position along the plunge travel. Once the motor is locked, the router effectively becomes a fixed base router. Consequently, plunge routers perform all the functions of a fixed base router, PLUS they give you the option of the plunge feature for work away from the edge - the best of both worlds. The only downside, if you can call it that, is that, because of the plunge mechanism, plunge routers a bit larger (bulkier) than fixed base routers. That's why some manufacturers offer the option of purchasing the router motor as a kit with interchangeable fixed and plunge bases. I started with a Bosch fixed base router many years ago. I used it a lot until I bought my first plunge router. Nowdays my fixed base router is seldom used; my plunge router does all the work.

As for which collet to purchase, I agree with others who advised purchasing a router that handles both. Router bits with 1/2" shanks are much sturdier than those with 1/4" shanks. They give you a cleaner cut and you don't have to worry about snapping the shank in the middle of a difficult cut. On the other hand, 1/4" shanks are fine for light work with small bits and shallow cuts. Some smaller bits only come with 1/4" shanks, so you need both size collets.

My $.02. Hope this helps.

Hank

Re: Router collet questions

#23

Re: Router collet questions

Jerrid Edgington

I appreciate your input Hank. Getting into woodworking as a hobby and I have a ton of questions it seems.

Jerrid

Re: Router collet questions

#24

Many have both collets available

John in NM

Even if it doesn't come with both, you can usually buy the other size too -- unless the motor is considered too small by the manufacturer to handle the bigger bits that often are available as 1/2" shanks only.

There are also reducing bushings available for around $10 that go from 1/2" to 1/4", I have several and they work fine.

Get a plunge router rather than a fixed base. More expensive but more versatile - it will do everything a fixed base router does and a lot more.

Personally, I don't use routers much outside the router table (which I just upgraded to the biggest P/C model). The can be handy if you don't have a jointer though, I used to use one for straightlining boards before I got the jointer.

Re: Router collet questions

#25

Ooops...

John in NM

Replied to the wrong post... oh well... :D