Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Cherry wood questions

Posts

Cherry wood questions

#1

Cherry wood questions

Rick Snyder

Hello,

Is cherry "graded" as some other woods are in terms of being... clear,#1,#2, etc. A customer whose Grandfather had cherry stored for at least 20 years in his barn would like a blanket chest made out of it. They wanted the wood stained with "mid-dark" stain. Problem.... Even with a wood conditioner applied to the wood the stained piece still looks botchley. The conditioner was applied per the instructions and the stain was applied at the proper time. What would be the problem? ( first time I've used cherry, which reminds me of the first time I ate shrimp, I found out real quick that I was allergic to shell fish). Hospital visit!!!! I will say, that the piece does look like the photo example of an antique B-chest they gave me which they really liked.

Thanks, Rick

Re: Cherry wood questions

#2

Re: Cherry wood questions

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Cherry will darken on its own in about 1-2 years, faster if it is exposed to sunlight. I've never tried staining it. If his cherry is really old, it might already be very dark colored all the way through. Try sanding only to 150 so that the stain sticks more to the closed grain areas that appear lighter now.

Lee

Re: Cherry wood questions

#3

Re: Cherry wood questions

Dick Coers

Start of rant: The customer is never right if they ask you to stain cherry!!!!!!!There is almost nothing more beautiful than 5 year old cherry furniture to most. To me, even fresh milled cherry is beautiful. Stain should never touch this gift of nature! End of rant. Cherry grain can wave in and out of the board, slightly exposing short grain. This will soak up stain more than the surrounding wood. Birch can also do this. Try gel stain, NGR stain, or dyes. But please plead with them to show some restraint and wait for it to darken.

Re: Cherry wood questions

#4

check the sanding

Bill Tindall

Cherry staining problems can usually be traced to cherry sanding problems. If at 220 grit the sanding is catching dust in some parts and not others the stain will take dark in the dull places. I sand cherry 120, 180 and 220.

Yes cherry is graded similar to other hardwood lumber but each species differs in details.

Re: Cherry wood questions

#5

Bob

Re: Cherry wood questions

Bob

Here is one of the cherry night stands I made with some 10 year old cherry. I used a blotch control that I got from charles Niel. I did 2 coats and then stained it the sun did the rest Finish is 6 wipe on coats of Arm-r-seal panels are Makore

Re: Cherry wood questions

#6

Shellac?

Richard Jones

I've always applied a wash coat of shellac, it seems to make the color stay as is, and then apply whatever finish on top of that, usually DO or WOP. Has always worked, flat work or turnings. No splotching, and the cherry turns dark and develops its own patina.

Staining cherry is really heresy and violators should be subject to the dunking stool.....................just sayin'.......

I see a lot of cherry kitchen cabinets, all stained, and I think, what a waste..............

But, that's me. At any rate, good luck with your project.

My $.02.

Rich

Re: Cherry wood questions

#7

Re: Cherry wood questions

del schisler

watch this vider on blotching that is what is happening. I use this product on every typw of wood and it works for me. Wood blotche's if nothing is used but stain. here is the link http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IfCYMdrP8rM&lr=1&user=InTheWorkshop

Re: Cherry wood questions

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The REAL problem

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

As others have hinted, the real problem is customer expectations. If you shop mass-produced cabinetry or furniture, you'll find that a "cherry wood finish" is some grotesque deep, dark red that looks nothing like the warm, orange-light brown of aged cherry with a clear finish. That red is what most people have been brainwashed to believe cherry is supposed to look like. Barf.

(Ok, I'll clarify a bit--I don't mind the dark red finish in some applications, just don't put it on cherry--use some bland maple or something.)

Jason

Re: Cherry wood questions

#9

Re: The REAL problem

PaulSV

I have used a lot of cherry, and tho I am no expert, I have learned to expect and control the blotching. Cherry will darken quite a bit if, after sanding and before finishing, you leave it in the sun for a day or two. I experienced that unintentionally when I left a chisel lying on a piece of sanded cherry that was in the sun. A few hours later, the wood had "sun-tanned," leaving a very noticeable imprint of the chisel. I have used this method on a few cherry pieces, doing my final sanding, and then letting it sit in the sun a few days before finishing. It seems to darken a lot quicker if you expose it to sun before finishing, but never to the dark red of commercial pieces. Very old pieces get quite dark over time, but that is a matter of years. I have also darkend cherry to a fairly dark tone with, if I recall correctly, a weak solution of lye in water.

It's not a problem just with stain- wipe some mineral spirits on a piece of sanded cherry, and you will see where it is going to blotch. The blotching dissapears when the spirits evaporate. I use that test to see where I need more sanding, usually going to 220 on cherry. The same thing will happen with oil finishes, and even water. You might try sanding to 220, raising the grain with water, and then sanding back with 220. I have used a conditioner, and it seemed to work pretty well, but I can't remember what brand I used. Also, If you are finishing with Polyurethane, you could try using clear poly for the base coat, and then using a tinted polyurethane on top to add color. Whatever you do, you should do plenty of test pieces to get the effect you want. When the project is finished, you can run the test board through the planer to remove the finish, and use if on a later project.

Re: Cherry wood questions

#10

Re: Cherry wood questions

Dave in Bryn Mawr

My favorite for cherry is Waterlox Original. I always sand to 220.

Re: Cherry wood questions

#11

Funny!...

Tony - Memphis

Our kitchen cabinets are "cherry." Actually, they are maple with a "cherry" stain so opaque it is almost paint. They did get a few figured pieces in there though. I showed someone a piece of raw cherry one day and she thought I was joking. I like the color they put on, but after 14 years, I think they are too dark for our current taste. Oh well, I ain't painting them.

The best luck I have had with staining cherry is gel stains. I start with a base coat, then glaze with other colors. The glaze does a pretty good job of evening the color. There have been several good articles in FWW (and others too probably) about this subject. I made a clock for some friends that like mission style. I tried to match some colors of their furniture. The glaze made it all work.

Tony

Re: Cherry wood questions

#12

A contrary view

Bill Tindall



I always stain cherry. Unstained it has a raw, unrefined look suitable for "country furniture" and some modern minimalist furniture. But for a formal piece it needs to be stained. When sanded properly I have no problem staining cherry. I apply the stain, always a mineral pigment stain, with a rubber similar to how shellac is applied. I have described the procedure here many times.


Re: Cherry wood questions

#13

Re: A contrary view

Tony - Memphis

I love that glow that cherry aquires. We went to a show at the Frist in Nashville where we saw some very old TN furniture made of cherry. It was really something. I think the pieces were part of their collection? I built a dining table for our breakfast room in cherry and after about ten years, it is starting to look really nice. I think my next project is going to be an easel for my wife. I was thinking about using cherry. I have a few nice long boards I picked up here and there that should work good.

Tony

Re: Cherry wood questions

#14

Re: Cherry wood questions

George Colonel's Workshop

Hello Rick,

I do nearly all my furniture in cherry, including two bedroom suites. I rarely use dye, except when there is a lot of sapwood in an item which I had to refinish for clients.

I generally put the milled boards outside for a few sunlit days, noting which ones match well after sunlight. It makes it easier to select the proper panel/table top stock. Once the piece(s) are made, they get a few more days of sun. I prefer the look engendered by Seal Coat, topped with satin poly, well rubbed out and paste waxed.

Shop Shots are filled with cherry projects, both natural and stained/dyed.

George

Re: Cherry wood questions

#15

Phshew! Good to see you posting!

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

I must admit, Colonel, Sir--I was a little uneasy when I did not see you add to the Weekend Accomplishment post. You almost always have some event or accomplishment to relate. I was afraid you might be back visiting your girlfriends in hospital. :-) Glad to read another vote for NOT staining cherry.

Re: Cherry wood questions

#16

Always a sunny day when the Col. posts


Re: Cherry wood questions

#18

Re: Cherry wood questions

Rick Snyder

Thanks to the Col. & Bill for their follow-up reply!