Re: The REAL problem
PaulSV
I have used a lot of cherry, and tho I am no expert, I have learned to expect and control the blotching. Cherry will darken quite a bit if, after sanding and before finishing, you leave it in the sun for a day or two. I experienced that unintentionally when I left a chisel lying on a piece of sanded cherry that was in the sun. A few hours later, the wood had "sun-tanned," leaving a very noticeable imprint of the chisel. I have used this method on a few cherry pieces, doing my final sanding, and then letting it sit in the sun a few days before finishing. It seems to darken a lot quicker if you expose it to sun before finishing, but never to the dark red of commercial pieces. Very old pieces get quite dark over time, but that is a matter of years. I have also darkend cherry to a fairly dark tone with, if I recall correctly, a weak solution of lye in water.
It's not a problem just with stain- wipe some mineral spirits on a piece of sanded cherry, and you will see where it is going to blotch. The blotching dissapears when the spirits evaporate. I use that test to see where I need more sanding, usually going to 220 on cherry. The same thing will happen with oil finishes, and even water. You might try sanding to 220, raising the grain with water, and then sanding back with 220. I have used a conditioner, and it seemed to work pretty well, but I can't remember what brand I used. Also, If you are finishing with Polyurethane, you could try using clear poly for the base coat, and then using a tinted polyurethane on top to add color. Whatever you do, you should do plenty of test pieces to get the effect you want. When the project is finished, you can run the test board through the planer to remove the finish, and use if on a later project.