Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

Posts

Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

#1

Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

Barry Irby

I stopped by he Habitat of Humanity Restore yesterday to look around. I bump into people who seem to gush about all the wonderful stuff you can get there cheap. (I must go there on the wrong day)

They had some of the four foot skinny fluorescent tubes. T-8 I think. I bought some for a buck a piece. They appear to be used, slightly darkened ends. The lady in the store thought they were new, but really did not know. The question is can I put them in my old fixtures that I have been using the older fatter bulbs in?

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

#2

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

John McGaw (Bodger)

Not so easy nor so cheap as just changing the tubes.

http://forums.mikeholt.com/showthread.php?t=113397

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

#3

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

walta

If you try them using the T12 ballast it is unlikely they will light.

If they should light the lamps will have a short life.

Walta

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

#4

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

They should work fine. Whether you can put them in or not is a different question.

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

#5

same story I got from a lighting engineer

Bill Tindall

I find what people do with fluorescent lighting astonishing. There is a huge difference in the appearance of stuff under lights of any kind that depends on the kind and quality of the lamp(bulb). In the case of fluorescent lamps the range of appearance is especially great.

The lamps work by exciting mercury atoms with an electric discharge. The mercury emits invisible ultra violet light. The tube is coated with various minerals, which vary with lamp type and lamp quality, which turn the invisible light into colored light. The colors emitted depend on the minerals coating the tube. By diddling with the mineral content the mixture of colors the lamp provides can be varied from red to white, and the illumination varied from something similar to incandescent to bright sun and everything in between.

People often complain that they don't like fluorescent lighting. It may be because they chose the lamp with a color output they found objectionable. Indeed, things look awful under cheap "shop light" and I don't want to face a 5000K sunlight lamp in the bath in the AM.

Fluorescent lamps should be chosen according to the lighting need. Most people will be more content with a redder 3000 to 3500 Kelvin lamp in the kitchen and bath. But it is best to experiment with different lamps to see what you like best. In the shop I mix 5000 K( resembling sun light) and 4000K (redder/softer) lamps of high quality. The quality is indicated by the CRI number. 85 or higher is a good lamp.

Unknown lamps would be relegated to the garage or barn.

BTW, T12's will no longer be manufactured after Jan1 according to the local lighting store. As a practical matter most are no longer manufactured now and stores are working off inventory.

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

#6

Re: same story I got from a lighting engineer

Barry Irby

Bill, I was obviously behind the curve on this (and many other things). I thought the 12 and 8 referred to the diameter of the tubes. Since the pins appear identical I thought they were interchangeable.

Are you saying that tubes for my older shop lights won't be available soon? Stunning to me that with the millions of similar fixtures in use there will be no one making the bulbs.

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

#7

Re: same story I got from a lighting engineer

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

Barry,

You are correct. The "T" number refers to the tube diameter in eights of an inch. IE: T8 = 8/8" or 1". T12 - 12/8" or 1 1/2".

T12's (or any other lamp) are not specifically banned from manufacture or sale. The requirement mandates the level of energy efficiency and, so far, on one has come up with a way to meet the efficiency standard with T12's and other fluorescent tubes.

The same is true for incandescent bulbs. 100 watters weren't banned. It is simply that they don't comply with the energy efficiency requirements.

Sl

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: same story I got from a lighting engineer

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Barry, physically the T12s and T8s are interchangeable--they both fit in the same fixtures, using the same tombstones, with the same pin configurations. The problem is that the ballasts drive the bulbs differently and are not interchangeable.

I swapped out a dead 4-lamp T12 ballast in our church for a 4-lamp T8 ballast (can't get 4-lamp T12 ballasts anymore, at least not locally nor easily). This is how different they are: both have multiple yellow, red and blue wires coming off them, so I thought it would be quick and easy--just match up the colors and be done with it. Not even close.

After several unsuccessful attempts, a couple hours, some words I shouldn't have thought at church, and a few wire swaps, I finally looked at the schematics on both ballasts, plus broke out my multimeter to use the continuity tester on the fixture to find out how the tombstones were wired. In the end, since it was a troffer fixture in a drop ceiling, I would have rather spent the extra $10 for a whole new fixture versus just a new ballast.

Jason

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

#9

clarification

Bill Tindall

What I have been told is that the T12's we currently can buy will no longer be made after Jan1. In fact they are not being made now in most cases. The expectation is that the market for a T12 lamp will then shrink quickly. While something that will be compatible with a T12 ballast will likely be made the volume will be smaller, the availability of lamps of this or that color will be much less, and the cost likely significantly higher due to smaller volume. All this suggests that when you have a ballast fail it should be replaced by a T8 ballast. It also suggests that if you have a favorite T12 lamp, in my case it is the GE SPX35 for living area, one should stock up now.

Yet another example of our giving up our freedom to live as we prefer.

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

#10

Re: same story I got from a lighting engineer

Larry in nw ohio

Jason If by chance you want to keep the T12`s for some reason you can get ballast`s off ebay, and they are pretty cheap. I got a few to just keep mine going till I run out of bulbs. A few years ago I got a very good buy on the old bulbs. Like the dummy I can be at times when I get good buy, I stock. I suppose I have enough for my children. Speaking of a good buy. I was in Lowes Thurs and saw that they had the 18V Porter Cable Drill and the impact drill for $129 AND PLUS 10% OFF for military discount, so that came to something like $116. So that was agood day, untill we got home and about an hour or so later got a call from our daughter the new mother and all excited that her 4 year girl fell off the new swing set they got just that day and maybe broke her arm. So we rushed over to babysit the others and she got her to the clinic and sure enough it was broke. But it was at least a clean break. I`m done Larry

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

#11

Larry, sorry to hear about the broken arm.....

Barry Irby

Hope she heals quickly and well and forgets all about it. We were luckier, my almost one year old granddaughter tumbled down the carpeted steps but was not hurt.

I bought one of those 18 volts PC sets from Lowe's and it has turned into a saga. The one I bought was discontinued from there display. They had it marked down to $150 and I asked if they could do better. $100? I'll take it. The batteries were no good. I went back and they gave me two of the over-sized ones. I was tickled, but they were no good either. Lowe's gave me a different charger. No help. Took it to a service center and they kept it for a month and announced the batteries were defective and out of warranty and that the place I took them was not really a factory service center and they could offer no further "help". I hunted down a number for PC. They sent me to another service center but said I needed to take my receipt to prove I had not been sitting on the batteries for three years. I got Lowe's to print one out for me as by this time I had no idea where the original was. Drove to the service center and as I walked through the door they announced it was the charger, that they had had a lot of them come back. I told them the other place said it was the batteries. They grabbed the batteries and went to the back. Came back in about a minute and typed out a ticket that said they were sending me a new set of batteries and a new charger. A few days later I got one battery and a message stating the charger was on Back Order. I called them about the other battery and they were a little snapish but sent me another one. It came within forty eight hours. I still have no charger. The saga continues. I assume that eventually I will have two new extended life batteries and a new functional charger, if I live long enough. What I actually wanted out of it was the circular saw. Someday.....but it will have cost me. Hope yours works well.

Re: Question on T-8 fluorescent tubes

#12

Re: Larry, sorry to hear about the broken arm.....

Larry in nw ohio

I`m really glad to hear that yours granddaughter wasn`t hurt. For no bigger than they are they can really scare the ever living daylights out of a lot of people. Larry