Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

Posts

Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#1

Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

charlie belden

The basic idea of a cyclone dust collector is to having the swirling action move the big stuff out to the walls of the cyclone where it will lose velocity and fall out of the air stream, while keeping the fine stuff - that can get DEEP in your lungs - in the stream that then flows out to HEPA filters where they are trapped. This separation of BIG from small (tiny) stuff prevents the HEPA filter from being clogged up with the BIG stuff.

Now it seems to me that a larger diameter cyclone would cause more of the BIG stuff to fall out of the air stream than a small diameter cyclone. Yet the Dyson vacuum cleaners, with their small multi-cyclones action went the other way - not one larger diameter cyclone but many smaller diameter cyclones.

Is Dyson's small multi-cyclones approach just advertising hype / product differentiation, or something cyclone dust collector manufacturers should be looking at?

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#2

JL

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

JL

Probably money and the ability to get a patent on Dyson's part.

My Oneida is pretty good as a cyclone. It has (obviously) a single cyclone. The majority of all of the particles usually ends up in my drum. I rarely have to clean my HEPA cartridge or empty out the little metal cap below the cartridge.

I would say the cone geometry probably has a lot to do with the cyclone efficiency.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#3

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

I built the mini Oneida dust collector melded to my ShopVac; built a small frame with one wheel in front and attached to the vac with a couple angle clips.....all moving at one time as one piece of equipment.

Now the shop vac had a good suction, but it was enhanced by using the mini dust collector, and I used it sed it to clean up some dust around the bench nice and clean. One 3 gallon bucket is attached to the frame with a screw in the bottom and another 3" bolt/washers& nuts into the vac. Then a 5 gallon is inserted into the 3 gallon and collects the dust and shavings thru the Oneida dust collector which I mounted on a MDF circular board which sits on the bucket top. When the 5 gallon is mostly full all I have to do is take off the Oneida top and lift the 5 gallon out of the 3 gallon and empty it....then return all to its place and continue working......all nice and clean.

Now James Dyson saw this effect when he decided to make his new vacuum cleaners for the lady of the house......did his research and further enhanced the cyclonic effect by adding 7 in the top before it goes into the main cyclone. This cyclonic effect he has enhanced can separate even the particles in smoke before it goes to the HEPA filter. The particles travel at about 900mph inside the cyclone.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#4

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

Brian from Monument

IIRC, I once read somewhere (please don't ask) that a vacumn cleaner and a dust collector work on different priniciples. I don't remember the rest.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

Jesper, Denmark

It is nothing new or just hype - without making specific comments on a particular product. Cyclone efficiency increases with velocity and centrifugal force produced. S the smaller the particle you want to separate out, the higher the velocity is required. This leads to smaller cyclone diameter and higher velocity AND higher pressure drop.

Standard chemical engineering textbook stuff.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#6

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

Alex Grigoriev

Actually, in Dyson cyclone, the first stage is the outer cylinder and it collects large debris and particles. The small cones in the inner space make the second stage. The stages are separated by a perforated cylinder.

If large debris were not separated before small, they would have interfered and possibly clogged the small cones.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#7

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Yes, Alex, you are correct. But the question was asking if there was any difference in a floor vacuum and a cyclonic one. Both do the job they are supposed to do, but the Dyson does it better using the multiple cyclones. Others are starting to copy them now.

I used my Oneida cyclone dust deputy this morning and it is a small wonder and cleans up nicely.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#8

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

charliell belden

I believe vacs use high velocity, low volume (CFM). Dust collectors go with lower velocity and much higher volume. So for the vacuum case, smaller cyclones may slow the velocity down in each little cyclone, probably at the expense of adding turbulence - which keeps both the big stuff and the small stuff in the air stream.

I'll posed the question to Bill Pentz, who has a LOT of knowledge and experience with cyclone dust collectors. Will post back what I learn from him.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#9

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Your analysis is a bit flawed- the goal of all cyclones, regardless of size, is to remove every bit of dust, large and fine, from the air stream. It does this by velocity- the swirling air causes the dust to move to the outside via centrifugal force where it can fall out and into the bin. Unfortunately, depending on the design, cyclones do not remove all the dust, so if you are returning the air to the shop, you must use a filter. As long as you have the required velocity a shopvac + cyclone or a DC + cyclone will work very similarly. It is easier to obtain separation velocity with a smaller diameter cyclone.

The second issue is that shopvacs work on high static pressure (80-100" SP) because they are designed to collect stationary dust by sucking it off the floor or out of carpet They typically pull only about 150-200 CFM but they can do that through a small hose. On the other hand, a DC is designed to collect airborne and moving dust from a machine so must pull a lot more CFM (600+ for one machine) and needs larger ducting (and a larger diameter cyclone) while only pulling 10" of SP.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#10

Are Dyson Vacs any Good?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

They look like Transformers. ;-) But are they good vacs or just hype?

T.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#11

Re: Are Dyson Vacs any Good?

Jim Goldrick

My wife loves hers. It's a good vacuum.

JimG

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#12

Re: Are Dyson Vacs any Good?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Yes they are far advanced than the other vacs IMHO. Wife bought hers about 4yrs ago...early model and it still picks almost all of the dust that collects weekly here in our desert climate.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#13

Re: Are Dyson Vacs any Good?

Randy Gleckler

I really like ours as well. Had it about 3 to 4 years. Think it does a great job, easy to clean out and works like a champ.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#14

Re: Are Dyson Vacs any Good?

frank ashmore

Looked at them a few yrs ago.The store we saw them at had more of them on the reconditioned shelf than new in the box .Kind of put me off.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#15

Is the multi-cyclone applicable to WWing?

charlie belden

OK - so those with a little mini-cyclone hooked up to a shop vac like them. And Dyson vacuum cleaners are great - though a bit pricey. And Onieda cyclones with the stacked HEPA filters - with the removable to clean out bottom pan are nice to have and work.

We've also learned that vacuum cleaners are for sucking dirt and dust out of a rug or off the floor, operate at high velocity, low pressure and low CFM, while dust collectors are for catching dust etc. out of the air, being kicked out by a power tool or from a sander, operate at lower velocity, lower pressure but much higher CFM - about 600 CFM for most stationary power tools - at the source - including loss of CFM in the piping, fittings etc., NOT right at the impellar inlet (which is what most manufacturers advertise and may or may not provide the static pressure for that reading).

My question was about the applicability of the Dyson multi-cyclone, scaled up, for a woodshop dust collector.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#16

Re: Is the multi-cyclone applicable to WWing?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I see absolutely no advantage to a "small diameter cyclone". In fact just the opposite is true. The statement above referring to increased velocity resulting in higher centrifugal force is true, however the larger the "cyclone" the higher the velocity for each revolution around the outside of the chamber. The distance around the chamber is determined by the formula Pi (3.1416) X radius squared. Therefore if the chamber is quite small like the Dyson, the air and derbies must rotate around the chamber many more times per second to obtain the velocity. IE: A chamber 3" in diameter would have a circumference of 1.5 X 1.5 X 3.1416 or 7.0686" while a chamber 16" in diameter (similar to a cyclone dust collector) would have a circumference of 8 X 8 X 3.1416 or 201.0624, therefore the derbies would have to move roughly 28 times faster to achieve the same centrifugal force. This would be a whole lot noisier, and a smaller chamber would also be far more prone to clogging up. If you look at the cyclone industrial applications, many are several foot in diameter. I reserve my opinion of the Dyson vacuum, however comparing them to a dust collection system is comparing apples and oranges.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#17

Wrong formula

AZ in Colorado Springs

You're calculating area. For circumference, use 2 x pi x R. Your argument holds, but the numbers are smaller.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#18

Re: Duh! Your right of course.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Don't use the formula's all the time like I used to, obviously wasn't thinking clearly - mainly was trying to show the relationship between the small VS the large diameter units and didn't do my homework. Guess I'm getting a little old and stale - and need to use my old reference sheets. Thanks.

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#19

Re: Is the multi-cyclone applicable to WWing?

Larry in nw ohio

I haven`t read all the posts here. My wife has a dyson, against my objections. I always thought it was a gloryfied little cyclone and not very good at that. I still liked my Sears vaccum. Also IIRC Consumer Reports liked Sears better than the Dyson when they compared them. My memory may have it wrong, but that is the way I remember it. I have always hated that creepy Dyson sound. Larry

Re: Dyson Multi Cyclones Dust Collector?

#20

Re: Is the multi-cyclone applicable to WWing?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

First, one correction, vacs work with high static pressure, not low.

Second, shopvacs with mini-cyclones do not do well collecting dust from full-size woodworking machines- they are best used with handheld routers, sanders, biscuit jointers, etc. that have small ports and where high static pressure is important.

As to your revised question- "the applicability of the Dyson multi-cyclone, scaled up, for a woodshop dust collector."

The answer depends on how you "scale it up". You must scale the cyclones up enough and use the right size and type of blower (material handling blower not a shopvac blower) so the unit will draw enough CFM for the most demanding machine while providing enough static pressure to overcome the static pressure resistance created by size and length ducting and/or hose you plan to use.

It is a multi-part problem- First you need to know the CFM and SP requirements. Then you need to figure out how many and what size cyclones to use and what size motor blower unit - hp and impeller diameter.

I doubt you will find the information you need so you will need to do a lot of experimenting. All this data is available for units having a single cyclone and material handling motor blower (see "fan curve"), so I question the advantage of using a scaled up Dyson.