Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

Posts

OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#1

OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

Stuart Johnson

What gas grill do you recommend? I used to use a smoker but now we are looking to purchase a propane grill. Online reviews leave a lot to be desired and after reading a couple articles about compensated reviews I don't trust them.

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#2

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

Nat Robison

I have a Weber Genesis 310 and I'm very happy with it. Cost was about $700 but this grill seems built to last 20 years, maybe longer if you keep it under a roof.

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#3

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

Tony - Memphis

After much research, I settled on the Weber Spirit. I've been very happy with it over the last year. Plan to use it a lot this weekend.

Tony

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#4

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

I've had two Broilmasters (can't remember the model number, but will look it up if you need it) and have been very happy with each. The first I bought at a local dealer in Illinois about 30 years ago. We had it hooked up to the house gas and it sat outside on the deck, summer and winter. We left it there in '99 when we moved south.

When we bought this house in '03 we started to get the grilling urge, and after seeing the cheap stuff at the borg and the unimpressive stuff at the local specialty stores, looked online to find our old partner still being built (and improved, too, by the way). I got it from an online vendor near Chattanooga (which I'll also look up, if you need it). It was on the order of $700 eight years ago, but well worth it. It runs on LP. I bought a roll around base for it, which was surprisingly and amazingly sturdy, rugged, and well engineered.

I've had a couple of service issues that were taken care of promptly and courteously. The first might have been through the dealer in IL. The second, I think was through the manufacturer, but maybe it was the dealer.

Very pleased with the product, and will buy again, should circumstances require. Wholly coincidental, but it turns out my next door neighbor has one, too. She doesn't buy crap.

Rod

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#5

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

Paul Leuba

We have had a Weber Q grill for about 6-7 years and love it. It's has a cast iron cooking grate an a thermometer in the top. Both features I consider essential. The cast iron cooking grate provides a very even heat throughout the grill. No hot spots, no cold spots. And, the thermometer permits a very accurate and repeatable capability to cook items to their desired temperature. It's also easy to dissassemble and clean. I do this thoroughly each year at the beginning of grilling season, and I believe it will extended the life of the unit considerably. I see no discernable signs that the grill is wearing out or diminishing in function. Also, it seems quite efficient with propane use.

It's a quality product that, as I recall, cost us about $270 with a stand. It's can be used in a portable manner, but we bought the stand and use it on our deck.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#6

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

paul in AZ

I have had a Weber Genesis Silver for several years. Rock solid construction quality. I think that model has been discontinued.

If I had a complaint it would be that it is underpowered -getting a good sear on a steak is difficult. But it has only 26,000 BTU so that shouldn't be a surprise. It is at it's best with longer, lower, slower cooks although with the heavy cast iron grates it does cook things quickly once warmed up.

If I was to do it again I'd recommend getting something with around 40,000 BTU. Like closet space, more BTU is useful; you don't have to use it flat out but have it if you need it.

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#7

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

RobCarr

My opinion on gas grills is this - the food that comes off it tastes like it was cooked in an oven broiler... there is no smoke flavor and has no resemblance to something cooked over charcoal or a wood fire in both texture and tastes.

I had a CharBroil gas grill about 35 years ago - had lava rock over the burners - used it about 10 times then it sat for ~30 years, ended up giving it to a neighbor, who couldn't believe it was 35 years old because it was so clean and new looking!

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#8

Well said


Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#10

same here

Bill Tindall

I abandoned mine and bought a Weber kettle. After 30 years of weekly use it is beginning to rust a bit. We also use the very small size for small cooking. I found the medium size to not work as well a either the larger of smaller. I think it doesn't have enough air flow. With a chimney lighter the coals are ready in 15 minutes. We shut off the air when done to extinguish the coals and get 2 cookings per charge of charcoal. Cheap, convenient, tastes better, cooks better.

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#11

Re: same here

Stuart Johnson

Well this could make some of the threads over on hand tools look tame if we get very deep into BBQ and slow smoking. In my two stage smoker I only used wood, never charcoal. In the past I've used everything from a homemade hibachi, cheap gas, large smoker that would hold two briskets and several slabs of ribs. All have turned out good tasting food. I no longer eat anywhere the amount of meat or drink as much Jack Daniels as in the past. Plus, I no longer care to spend an hour getting the smoker started or twelve hours tending it off and on while the meat smokes.

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#12

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

steve mackay

Sear's Kemore. 12 years ago it was the $120.00, bottom of the line model. I'll say that again. . . twelve years. NEVER had a problem with it. Still works and looks like new. Biggest tip for ANY outdoor grill ? Shell out for the heavy duty $50 cover and USE IT ! EVERY time !

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#13

+1 On The Weber Spirit 


Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#14

20 years

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is how long I've had my Weber Genesis. Replaced the "flavor" bars once, still on the original burners and spark igniter. I grill 2-4 times a week year round, so can signify as to the brand's durability although I do take care of it and it's in the garage when cool. I also use various woods in one or two smoker boxes (often from whatever I'm turning at the time) and the three-burner configuration gives excellent control and options. I can sear steaks at 600° direct, or slow cook and smoke poultry at 300°.

You haven't had prime rib until you do one on this grill.

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#15

Re: 20 years

Rob Sandow

I have a Weber Genesis that is well over 10 years old with no problems at all. I think it is reasonably powered, getting to over 600 degrees in a hurry with all 3 burners on high. My only issue with it is that even with just one burner on the lowest setting, the temperature inside with the lid closed is still about 300 degrees. That makes it too hot to do any slow cooked BBQ. Smoke bombs (small scraps of wet wood wrapped in aluminum foil with holes poked in it) work reasonably well if placed down between the "flavor bars" so that they get some fire on them. I do miss the old gas grills that used lava rock though. This worked a lot better with them because you could just soak the wood in water and throw it right on the lava rock when it was fully saturated.

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#16

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: 20 years

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Mine's about the same age. I grill about twice a week, winter or summer, and the grill sits out, uncovered, in whatever the prevailing weather is.

I replaced the flavor bars with stainless steel ones, and the grates with porcelain coverd cast iron ones.

Original burners, but on about the third igniter.

I converted from propane to natural gas about six or seven years ago, and was surprised when I called Weber to inquire about the conversion, and they pulled up my name and address immediately, and offered me a discount on the conversion parts. Remember, this was on a grill that was already about 11 or 12 years old! Great customer service, eh?

If this one ever dies, I'm buying another Weber!

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#17

Re: same here

Gary Bindel

I have a Big Green Egg smoker that my wife picked up at a garage sale for $20. It works well and turns out great tasting BBQ with true smoked flavor. I usually use it when I'm going to be outside doing yard work, so it's easy to monitor.

Re: OT: Gas Grill Recommendation

#18

$20, Now That's A Gloat!