Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Cry uncle on coves

Posts

Cry uncle on coves

#1

Cry uncle on coves

Stephen Kirk

I've finally had some free time to cut the coves on the large top pieces of the bookcases I'm building. I tried to waste away material on the table saw, but these are too unwieldy and it felt very unsafe. So, I routed away most of the waste, took some more off with a block plane and started cleaning up with a gooseneck scraper. The board here is 2 nights work. My hands and shoulder are already killing me. The wood is red oak. I don't have any moulding planes to use on this and I'm not sure I want to try and find something just for this.

I'm thinking I like the look of the coves, but perhaps I should make cove moulding and wrap 3 sides. I can cut that on the table saw or router and I'll be pretty sure they'll all match. Heck, I might even pick up something good looking (I know, cheating!).

Question - If I wrap three edges in moulding, when doing the sides, should I add a bit of glue by the front then just one or two tack nails at the back? I figure small nails have enough give to handle wood movement.

This is one top, with 2 short edges somewhat refined. I still have to do the long edge, then I have 2 more tops.


Re: Cry uncle on coves

#2

Re: Cry uncle on coves

John in NM

You need a set of hollow and round planes, or at least the one that will cut that cove.

Re: Cry uncle on coves

#3

Re: Cry uncle on coves

Barry Irby

When I cut a number of similar coves, I found my ROS to be very useful in sanding and smoothing them. Mine were all long grain in curly walnut.

Re: Cry uncle on coves

#4

Re: Cry uncle on coves

Stephen Kirk

Would you go at it with a pretty coarse grit first? I thought of the ROS, but I worried it'd mess things up in a hurry.

Re: Cry uncle on coves

#5

Re: Cry uncle on coves

Stephen Kirk

Yeah, at some a set of moulding planes would come in handy, but there's only so much time and money.

It is, however, a big flea market weekend, so ...

I notice many people are making their own planes again, too.

Re: Cry uncle on coves

#6

Ellis Walentine

Go with moldings

Ellis Walentine

Crown moldings would seem to be the answer. As for your wood movement question, your suggested approach is a time-tested one and should work fine.

I'm not sure why you decided against using the tablesaw to create these coves. I guess it might be unwieldy on a 10" tablesaw, but an outboard roller stand or table extension should make it more comfortable.

Ellis

Re: Cry uncle on coves

#7

Re: Go with moldings

Stephen Kirk

At 45" long and 18" wide, I didn't have good control, even on my big cabinet saw. I probably would have made a big sled to support them.

I thought I'd try it this way as its at least a learning experience. Without some good molding planes, though, maybe its not the best way. Just routing away the waste is a good deal of work.

I need about 25' of molding. If it was a lot, I might just call Mike Peters and see what he could make for me. He's considerably more well set up for that activity than I am.

Re: Cry uncle on coves

#8

Re: Cry uncle on coves

Barry Irby

I have the older PC 5" ROS with the standard pad. (Not one of the thicker softer pads.) I started with the coarsest grit I had and worked my way down.

I have done several large panels and several boards I turned into moldings. I used my 10" contractors saw. I have a home made roller stand and set the saw up so that the pieces lay flat on the top of the saw and ride against a temporary fence clamped onto the table at and angle. I usually angle the blade slightly and then raise it very slowly, less than a 1/16" for each new pass. I put a cover over the area of the blade to keep errant fingers out of the danger zone. Its a little unwieldy, but actually not "dangerous" to the wood. What I mean is that you can't take off too much because the blade is below the table and the fence limits the amount that is exposed. So if you bobble the piece slightly you don't take off an excess, you leave a hump and just have to run the piece again. The last pass is a very light one or even just running it again at the same setting. Then the goose neck scraper and the ROS make pretty quick work of it.

I drew a line across my saw table to "remember" the angle and wrote down the other settings to be sure I could duplicate the shape again. Changing the angle of the fence and the angle on the blade changes the profile of the molding or cove.

Be prepared for a huge amount of saw dust.

Re: Cry uncle on coves

#9

Re: Cry uncle on coves *LINK*

William Duffield

The biggest problem you will have with your method is getting the end grain to take the finish the same as the long grain. Any differences will definitely show up, right up there where your eyes are drawn. But, there are other potential problems as well. Scraping end grain is much less effective than scraping long grain. If you are making a complex molding, especially one with small details like a bead or astragal, it is very easy to chip some of it off on the end grain. Even running the wide, heavy board through your table saw and router, especially if it starts to warp a bit after you've glued it up, is goint to result in inconsistencies.

You're much better off running mouldings in straight grained stock and learning how to tightly fit the miters. Save your highly figured wood for panels and drawer fronts.

If you are tempted to make more complex mouldings, that you can't buy a router bit to match, a good free place to start to get an idea of what might be involved is Matt Bickford's blog.


Musings from Big Pink

Re: Cry uncle on coves

#10

Re: Cry uncle on coves

Stephen Kirk

Those are really good points. Since I worked on the short grain first I can definitely see it is harder to shape and more prone to splintering, plus coloring can be a big issue.

I've settled for making the long grain crown molding and applying it. Once I square up some stock and set up fences/blade tilt it won't take long to make a bunch.

Re: Cry uncle on coves

#11

Ellis Walentine

An old rule of thumb....

Ellis Walentine

... when you don't have the right tool for the job is to get someone else to run the molding for you. There are shops around with scads of molder and shaper cutters that will cut just about any cove or molding profile you ever could need, at a perfectly reasonable price. The better part of valor in this case would be to have someone else do it.

Ellis

Re: Cry uncle on coves

#12

Did you thin about trying a hand held circular saw

Keith Newton

I often use my circular saw, cutting side-ways, for hogging off lots of wood quickly. It would of be hard to make a sub-base, to hit the final pass with precision, and have the blade cutting down the slope of the grain.

A bandsawn shaped sanding block with a thin pad, starting with ~80 grit, would be my preference to follow that, then a random orbit after several grit changes of the hand block produced a fair shape.

Re: Cry uncle on coves

#13

Re: Cry uncle on coves

Lee Brubaker

Rather a simple operation if you happen to own an RAS. Have cut a lot of cove moldings using mine. Moldings for fireplace mantles, picture frames, wooden toy grader blades, etc, etc. No problem.

Lee