Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

OT - tile

Posts

OT - tile

#1

OT - tile

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

In our current remodel, we have an alcove 45" wide by 15" deep, backed by 2x4s framed on 16" centers, covered with 1/2" plywood nailed off on 6" centers. A freestanding gas heater will be going in this alcove, with about 5" clearance in back and 9" clearance each side - significantly more than the minimum clearance the manufacturer specifies.

We'll be tiling the bottom four to five feet of this alcove. I'm weighing whether to use 1/2" cement board or 1/4" Hardiebacker. The 1/2" is presumably stiffer, but the 1/4" will bring the tile closer to the same plane as the drywall above the tiled area. While there'll be a fairly chunky picture rail separating the tile and the drywall, I'm wondering whether it will look odd to have the tile "higher" than the drywall, or if it won't be noticeable thanks to the picture rail.

Why am I thinking of Barry Irby as I post this question?

Re: OT - tile

#2

Bob

Re: OT - tile

Bob

I believe you only need cement board if there is a potential for water or dampness issues.

Re: OT - tile

#3

Re: OT - tile

Larry in nw ohio

Speaking of Barry, I haven`t seen him post lately, has he run out of projects or, I hope he`s OK. Barry are you OK. Larry

Re: OT - tile

#4

I use hardy board

Dustmaker Mike

all the time. The only time I use cement board is in a shower area. Now I don't do this for a living nor did I ever play a tiler on TV but it has served me well over the years. I use a sharp razor knife to cut it I used to use a circular saw and TS but it will kill a blade fast. The knife cuts I back it then break it this makes a clean fast cut. Good Luck

Re: OT - tile

#5

1/4" should work fine

John in NM

Going over plywood I don't think you need to worry about stiffness. I've even tiled right over drywall in dry areas without problems.

Hardibacker is pretty much interchangeable with cement board, and I find it easier to work with. I usually cut it with a diamond blade on an angle grinder, because I usually have one around. A masonry carborundum blade would work fine too.

Re: OT - tile

#6

Re: OT - tile

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Three or four years ago, I was looking into installing ceramic tile on my open (roof covered) front porch, and ran into a retired tile installer at the contractors counter in Lowe's. A discussion ensued about what backing is required behind / under tile. He said he had installed almost all of his tile directly over drywall without any problems in 40 years. His statement was that properly installed and grouted tile was completely waterproof and the only thing the hardboard was needed for was if the tile leaked. I am a sure not an expert, but I did install tile on my porch directly over 3/4 T&G treated plywood. I have had zero issues in the four years it has been down, even though snow, rain and ice sometime is blown onto the floor. In your case, since there is no possibility of water, I would use drywall or if you prefer cement board in whatever thickness works well for your job.

Re: OT - tile

#7

Re: OT - tile

NickinMass

If you're only talking about the walls, you can use CBU, hardy or drywall. Stiffness is not an issue because the wall surfaces shouldn't be subjected to any dynamic loading (this is an issue for floors, but the tiling substrate doesn't really contribute - it's all in the framing). I'd use whatever you're most comfortable with.

Re: OT - tile

#8

Kneale Brownson

Picture Rail should hide any difference


Re: OT - tile

#9

Re: OT - tile

Justin Szeliga

The real problem you face is the effects of the heating & cooloing & the subsequent expansion & contraction of the tile, adhesive, & whatever you attach it to. I'd put it up on Hardiboard, leave plenty of room at the edges for expansion, & get a real good thinset (the expensive stuff) from a tile supplier, not from a chain store. Mapei's got some stuff that'll glue tile to anything & even move a bit, & good grouts too.

I like using Hardiboard just because it's easier to keep the dust under control than all the little concrete crumbs for the Durock. A diamond or an abrasive blade will cut either quite nicely.

Best place to get tile info is here-

http://www.johnbridge.com/vbulletin/index.php

Great bunch of folks, the Woodcentral of the tile biz.

Re: OT - tile

#10

I am not dead, yet.

Barry Irby

Nothing like being a few days late. Tile is not my strong suit, but I agree with John. I think your biggest concern is the heating and cooling/expansion and contraction.

I just worked on one of my rentals. Had electric baseboard heat. The drywall basically delaminated and fell apart above some of the heaters. The paper faces fell off both the front and back and the core crumbled. This is a low budget house and the same one the tree fell on. So we were repairing the tree damage and then got drawn into repairing everything else. I don't know for sure, but it appears the heat "cooked" the drywall.

So I would go to the John Bridge site and ask. Short of that I would go with the heavier/thicker backer and excellent thinset and leave room for expansion. The further the tile is from the stove, the better. I would be concerned the thinner backer would buckle.