Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

resaw bandsaws

Posts

resaw bandsaws

#1

resaw bandsaws

McKay

I am considering getting a 2nd band saw that would be dedicated to re-sawing only. When I taught, I had a Laguna w/ a carbide blade. This dedicated system worked very well. I got a bid for a Jet 18 and it is 500 higher than a Grizzley. I do not know if the amount of re-sawing that I would do would justify a $2000+ band saw. What is the collective wisdom of the WC?

Re: resaw bandsaws

#2

Re: resaw bandsaws

Dick Coers

I would gladly pay the extra for the Jet. I bought a Grizzly 19" Extreme and it was horrible. The lower cast wheel was cast so badly, it could not be machined all around the faces. It had 4 weights on one side, and 10 balance holes on the other. It still shook so badly, nothing would stay on the table with it running. After replacing that wheel, I found the top wheel was about 1/2 as bad. I also found that they welded the saw to a fairly thin base pan. The thin sheet metal let the saw go into a resonance, and amplified the vibration problem. You'll hear that a lot of people are happy with a Grizzly, but it was the worst band saw I have ever run.

Re: resaw bandsaws

#3

Re: resaw bandsaws

William Duffield

The JET bandsaw is well made. Because of the trapezoidal cross section frame it is quite a bit stiffer than other bandsaws of equivalent size and weight.

The Lagunas are even better, especially the Italian made ones, but be sitting down when you see the price of those. A significant advantage, especially when trying to steer a wide board on edge, is the significantly lower deck height. Up around elbow height is great if you are cutting out a chair leg, but not when resawing.

When you are evaluating bandsaws, make sure you look at the table supports. Long, heavy boards put a lot of stress on the table trunnions. Check the materials, the mass and the placement. IMHO, support in front of the blade is a lot more important, especially with long heavy boards, than the convenience of being able to remove and reinstall a blade without turning it 90° to get it out of and back into the table.

The blade makes more difference than the saw (but the saw must be properly tuned, and that's not trivial, but you probably already know that). For carbide tipped blades, rumor has it that you can't do better than the Lenox, but protect your investment, and buy a good metal detector, and use it.

Re: resaw bandsaws

#4

Bob

Re: resaw bandsaws

Bob

As the saying goes "buy your last tool first"

Re: resaw bandsaws

#5

JL

Re: resaw bandsaws

JL

I purchased an 18" Rikon a while back. I use it as a resaw bandsaw. It has a 2 1/2 hp motor (wired for 220 V). I've been quite happy with it. A couple of years ago, I purchased a lot of #2 common cherry. Let it suffice to say, it really was #2. I've had to resaw it so I didn't spend the time planing the defects away. The Rikon has handled it quite nicely.

YMMV - I think it is a good, somewhat inexpensive saw.

Re: resaw bandsaws

#6

Re: resaw bandsaws

Larry in nw ohio

I`ve been buying my bandsaw blades from a different place lately. It`s called Supercut bandsaw Co. and I think they have better blades or just as good as anyone and just as well priced. They don`t have prices on their site but they will send a catalog. They have quite a few carbide covered. I thinl Del has bought some and he said he liked them. I have no affiliation with them. Larry

Re: resaw bandsaws

#7

Your righ Larry Suppersaw cut A+++

del schisler

i use them and they are best so far but i havent use the Lennox blade's so they may be better or just as good. I used to use woodmiser and they worked but i found they didn't stay sharp . I use suppersaw cut blades and they work so i guess i am not going to be buying more to just to testing.

Re: resaw bandsaws

#8

Bob

Re: resaw bandsaws

Bob

I forgot to mention that I found a 16" laguna band saw at IRS Auctions and got it for $600.00 I bought a 1" 2 tpi King blade so you may want to look there. Be prepared to spend a few hundred dollars for the blade. here it is

Re: resaw bandsaws

#9

Re: Your righ Larry Suppersaw cut A+++

Larry in nw ohio

Thanks Del, I`m glad to hear you like them. I`m surprized that I found something for once that works well. They do stay sharp. I nwish I could get them to be a sponser here. Larry

Re: resaw bandsaws

#10

I have a Lenox Trimaster 1/2",

Bruce, a MN Galoot

which is carbide tipped, and it is very good. It tracks well, cuts anything easily, except a hardened drywall screw. The only drawback is its fairly wide kerf. It lasted three or four years of use, usually pressed into duty for nearly anything except tight curves, until I hit that screw. Then I was pretty much screwed.

Lenox says they can't be resharpened, but they can, and if someone is interested, I'll dig up the company that did it. As I recall the resharpening job cost around $40. The new price is around $140 but I got a good deal on it.

BTW, I have a Delta 14" BS.

Re: resaw bandsaws

#11

Re: resaw bandsaws*pics

James Hisebert

I'll be willing to spend the extra bucks if it's worth it. I have this saw in my shop and it cuts like cutting cheese: http://utilitybandsaw.com/images/image/gll2aa1s.jpg

Re: resaw bandsaws

#12

Re: resaw bandsaws

James Hisebert

I once came across with Supercut band saw but didn’t continue the purchase for blades because they don’t have prices displayed. So I got to another source online and found this: www.sawblade.com. Their blades were well priced and looked good. I tried one and tested the blade. Their blades are awesome! I just felt like I had a lucky catch!

Re: resaw bandsaws

#13

Re: resaw bandsaws*pics

McKay

I can not tell from the pics what brand it is. Would you enlighten me? Thanks

Re: resaw bandsaws

#14

Re: resaw bandsaws*pics

James Hisebert

It is a trajan saw. Model no 914. The heavy weight machined table helps eliminate vibration, with a fabricated steel base, horizontally mounted guide arms, and adjustable roller blade guides. Hydraulic control for feeding stock at variable rates and a independent feed shutoff allows you to stop the saw head at any position without changing the feed rate. I got it running for 3 years now and still without failures or replacements. Though it really depends on how often you use the saw. The manufacturer said it is designed for longer use. This is the site where I got it: http://utilitybandsaw.com/trajan-914.cfm .

Re: resaw bandsaws

#15

Re: I have a Lenox Trimaster 1/2",

Larry in nw ohio

Bruce How long is your Lenox carbice blade, I wouldn`t be afraid to bet a blade like it from where I get them would be cheaper and just as good if not better, If you would be interested.Larry

Re: resaw bandsaws

#16

I'd be interested

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It's a standard Delta, 92-1/2, but I have a riser block I'm going to install when my current crop of blades is shot. I think that makes the length 103 or something like that.

Hook me up!

Re: resaw bandsaws

#17

Re: I'd be interested

Larry in nw ohio

Bruce A 92.5 inch would be like $24 and a 103 would be something like $25 in a 1/2 wide blade 3tpi with carbide impregnated teeth. That what my catalog has, but to be sure call them @1-800-356-9918. If you go to their site. www.supercutbandsaw.com look up the blade you would like and let me know and I can price it for you. While your on their site you can order a catalog. Hope this helps Larry

Re: resaw bandsaws

#18

Re: small, but important, correction

William Duffield

Delta 14" BS takes a 93-1/2" blade. With a riser block, it takes a 105" blade.

Re: resaw bandsaws

#19

Re: small, but important, correction

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Actually, I have a couple of each 92-1/2 and 93-1/2.

Re: resaw bandsaws

#20

Re: small, but important, correction

William Duffield

Of course, there's plenty of adjustment in the Delta, but I wouldn't be so sure of it's various and sundry clones.

Re: resaw bandsaws

#21

Re: small, but important, correction

Bruce, a MN Galoot

No, and the shorter ones have caused a bit of a problem, too.