Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

DC piping

Posts

DC piping

#1

DC piping

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

I am in the process of planning on installing a new piping system for my dust collection.

My DC is the Shopsmith with 2 1/4" inlets. Now, what size piping would you guys suggest for the overhead piping...and I am planning on using 2 1/2" flex hose to connect to the various equipments thru waste gates.

Overhead....ABS? or metal?

Re: DC piping

#2

Re: DC piping

Larry in nw ohio

Bill First off just how many machines do you have and haw much area are you planing to cover. I think using a Shopsmith w/ a 2 1/2 outlet you are not going to get much sucktion with it. The first thing you should do, if you haven`t, go to Bill Pentz.com/woodworking/cyclone/cycloneplans.cfm

DC sight. That`ll tell you all you need to know about DC, it`ll even tell you more than you want to know. It is the go to for DC. Larry

Re: DC piping

#3

Re: DC piping

Barry Irby

I used PVC Sewer and Drain (S&D) piping for mine. Its similar to plumbing pipe but thinner walled, lighter in weight and cheaper than schedule 40 PVC.

It comes in limited sizes, but the four inch stuff might work for you. The problem is that there has to be enough air flow to keep the chips flying. If you allow them to settle out, the pipes will clog.

Re: DC piping

#4

Re: DC piping

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

I am not really an expert in DC. But what I remember from when I started looking at it;

1. small bore items like the shopsmith sound more like vacumn cleaners than true DC.

2. most DC applications require a good bit of CFM per machinery. Better DC manufacturers will have a nice table about this info.

3. The more splits (Ys) and curves the greater the loss of suction/CFM

4. the sharper the curves the greater the loss.

Bottom line is use short runs to stationary tools and use gates to cut off all other runs.

I have a mobile Delta DC unit for Jointer, shaper and planer usage with short flexible pipe 5inch.

I have a Oneida cyclone for the Table Saw 6 inch metal runs. Could add more to it.

Larger sweep curves are better than sharp ones and short runs are the best.

As for PVC vs Metal, I have metal. Good thing about metal is that it has not static issues.

It conducts charge and current.

Re: DC piping

#5

Kneale Brownson

I just roll my S/Smith DC up to the tool.

Kneale Brownson

While it'll suck through two or three lengths of the flex tube, I doubt it'll pull longer distances. I'd be afraid of clogging.

Re: DC piping

#6

Re: I just roll my S/Smith DC up to the tool.

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

that is what I have been doing for the past 7yrs since I bought it, but was just thinking I could install some 4" metal in the ceiling using long turn elbows and 45deg.Ys, then drop down with 3" to a blast gate and use the flex hoses I already have to connect to the various equipments....one at a time. Presently I am using my Shop-vac for the router and to clean up the floor with the flex hoses and the floor cleaning tools I got

when I bought the Shopsmith DC....it works, but could be better if I had such a system I am thinking of. The shopsmith dc is hooked up to the saw when sawing, and am thinking I will try to install a dust chute on the lower side of the bandsaw to help the dust collection inside the bandsaw housing.

Re: DC piping

#7

Re: DC piping

Rob Sandow

Truthfully a dust collector with 2 1/4" inlets will probably not get you what you need if you want to try running overhead pipes. If you are going to install some overhead pipes, go with 4" PVC and then get a decent dust collector with 4" inlet. They are not really expensive. You will probably spend more on the plumbing than you will on a 1/2 HP dust collector. Just be sure to replace the stock bags. You will find plenty of info on this in the archives.

Re: DC piping

#8

JL

Re: DC piping

JL

To sort of echo what Larry said - go to the website of Bill Pentz.

In a "nutshell".

It sort of depends on how much and what you are ducting.

As a general rule - 6" mains are recommended - but 4" will work if it isn't too extensive of a system. The bigger the ducts (within reason), the better it is.

As an example, I have 7" coming out of my DC up to the start of my ducting in the overhead. I have 6" mains to all of my drops. I reduce to 4" for most of my drops and have 4" going to my tools.

Re: DC piping

#9

Bob

Re: DC piping

Bob

I have done a bit of research myself and I agree 2" runs are not good. I did a test and found that with my JET 1900 CFM 20' of 2" will not pull enough to keep from clogging up I did the same run with 4" and had better results. 6" mains and 4" drops with blast gates as close to the main as possible seem to be what everyone has the best results with I will only have 2 ea. 2" hoses, one at my router table off the 4" to the box where the router is with a blast gate there as well to regulate how much air I want to pull through the router to keep it cool and one at my miter saw. I would check on craigslist, I picked mine up for $200 I find the ducting and fixtures will cost more then the DC unit. I am going with metal so anyone with a good resource I would be thankful

Re: DC piping

#10

Re: DC piping

Larry in nw ohio

Bob Not to try to change your mind,but I used S&W drainage line w/a oneida 3HP cyclone with air cylinder to open and close the gates at each machine, and it has never given me any trouble in the 10+ years I have had it. Whenever I would want to move anything the PVC is very east to rework. When I use to work for a living, I worked on Dust collection sometimes with metal pipeing and swore up and down I would never use metal when I put in a DC system. But that is my take on things, and I never had any trouble with static whatsoever. Good Luck with your system. Larry

Re: DC piping

#11

Re: DC piping

mdclor

Joseph,

You have gotten some good advice so far, but some of it will require a big step up from your current dust collector. Your 2.5" inlet can only handle a single machine when you have the two directly connected to each other; it will not pull enough air for you to use fixed tubing even with blast gates. The reason for this is that there is friction between the moving air and the tubing wall. The longer the tube, the more friction and that friction will, at some point, slow the air flow so much that it will not be able to keep the dust moving, hence a clogged line. So the question becomes do you want a full blown duct collection system and the associated expense or do you want to move your dust collector from machine to machine as you use them?

HTH,

Merle

Re: DC piping

#12

Re: PVC is much cheaper and

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

IMHO much better for several reasons. I have used metal pipe for furnace installations (contractor for several years), and PVC both as a contractor and as an Engineer at my old job. As an Engineer I designed a vacuum system for several machine for both cleaning and part vacuum pickup. The piping was in some cases near 100' runs - all PVC - These systems had up to 75 HP vacuum pumps in service. We never had any problems with static or debris buildup. The major advantages to PVC are cost (FAR cheaper for pipe and fittings), ease of installation - cut with hacksaw, saber saw, or pvc cutter and install with PVC cement. Total seal at all joints, smooth interior of pipe and fittings promotes better air flow and no catching of debris. Ease of modification of system, a hacksaw and tee and cement will add a drop in little time. I have my shop dust system (3 hp Grizzly cyclone) piped with pvc and have had zero problems in 5 years. Joe, I do think you are trying to do too much with your existing dust collector, as you add length and pipe size, you really need to up the Horsepower to do an effective job of removing sawdust and debris.

Re: DC piping

#13

Re: PVC is much cheaper and

Larry in nw ohio

Joe If you would choose to use pvc, do not glue them, because if for some reason you want to move or add some then you`ll have a very hard time taking the joints apart. Besides you can get a tight fitting joint just by pushing the fitting together and if you want to, use some caulk to seal the joints. That is what I did and I have had no trouble as I said before. If you would live anywhere around NW Ohio, you or anyone else is wecolme to stop in and see what I have, as long as you are careful walking around my shop, so you don`t get hurt. Larry

Re: DC piping

#14

Re: opinion on gluing

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I understand why you didn't glue, but I tried to seal joints without glue and had problems with some of my 7' x 6" drop lines loosening. So I glued all the joints in the system. To add or change the lines all I need to do is cut out a section and if I need to add, install a coupling (less than $2) or insert a Y or tee etc. Gluing made it a lot easier to install across 30' of ceiling 10' high as well as keeping the system ridged.

Re: DC piping

#15

Bob

Re: DC piping

Bob

Thanks Larry, You know I was not happy with the idea of spiral duct really. I was thinking PVC would be quieter as well. Is it cheaper? and can you get it in 6", 4" & 2"? I think the main issues were the fitting sizes and can they mate up to the DC and Machines easily? I will be mounting the main on the wall, no sense going up 10' to the ceiling if I don't have to right?

Re: DC piping

#16

Re: DC piping

Joseph Mulherin, sr

OK, have received some very good advice on the piping and sizing. Have decided to just keep what I have for now and just move the DC to the various machine connections as needed. And, after some research on the Shopsmith DC I find that the motor is not adequate enough HP wise to give me the required vacuum for an overhead system.

As it is now, I hookup the saw to it, maybe install a chute on the bandsaw later and just use the shopvac for the router setup. I installed the delay switch so the vac stays on for 7 seconds after the router is shut down so it vacs out the dust better.

I do not do very much work lately, but I am going to complete those chairs(7 of them) for my family...kept the first one for myself after a learning process on the techniques needed to produce the chairs. Found out I can modify some aspects to make the construction easier

Re: DC piping

#17

Kneale Brownson

Re: I just roll my S/Smith DC up to the tool.

Kneale Brownson

I mainly use the Shopsmith for the table saw and bandsaw. I have a connector cut into the lower door of the bandsaw to connect to the dc. For my planer and jointer, I use a 3-phase collector and fan with a 55-gal drum intermediate separator. I plumbed up a 6-inch system to that collector for the cutoff. But I use the Shopsmith for saws I might move to differing locations depending upon length of material.

Re: DC piping

#18

Re: DC piping

Larry in nw ohio

BOB I live in NW Ohio, I don`t suppose you antplace close, because I`m not the best at explaining things very well, but I`ll try. If you watch where you buy, I think S&W is cheaper, it`s the fittings that can bite you. For S&W you can use a couple two different fittings, real S&W and the 40 gauge PVC, the 40 is about twice has thick. Also when you do curves like a 90 degree use two 45 degree with a foot or so inbetween the two. Also I don`t think it was brought up PVC is smoother and so air will move easier through the piping. I found that out when I tested my system. Your other questions like the sizes, they come in about any size except odd size like 3-5-7-9 inch. Also you can do about any kind fit together to anything you want if your a little inventive. If you do this and run into a problem just email me or post here and someone will come up with something. Good Luck Larry

Re: DC piping

#19

Re: opinion on gluing

Larry in nw ohio

Larry One thing I left out on fitting PVC piping together is that I would push them together and then run a couple or three screws in the fitting just so they do not go thru the inner pipe so it would not be a catching type thing, but even if it would stick thru a little I don`t think it would hurt. Then I caulk around the outside, with that I never had any trouble. Again I would never glue, but of course that is just me. Larry

Re: DC piping

#20

Re: DC piping

Joseph Mulherin, sr

After viewing the Bill Pentz website I have decided to use his instructions and build my own DC for the shop.

I am not going to purchase the really toooo expensive DCs but but some sheetmatel from HD and use the designs to cut and fabricate the cone, baffles, inlets and outlets. Already have a 1 1/2" motor which can be used for the unit, but probably will have to purchase an impeller fan 15-16") for best vacuum results.

Re: DC piping

#21

Re: DC piping

mdclor

Joe, I hope this won't cut into your chair making time too much. ;)

Also, you need to remember that the expense of the tubing can be significant. When I did my shop 5 years ago, I found S&D PVC to be lower cost, but that may have changed with the cost of oil. Keep your runs as short as possible which means locating the collector close to the center of your machine locations. The fittings can be VERY expensive so try to minimize them as much as possible. However, do not use any 90* elbows; use 2 45* with about a foot of tubing between them to make any necessary 90* bends. Most machines have a 4" inlet at best. If you run 6" tubing, the best strategy is to run the 6" as close to the machine as possible, then drop down to 5" flex tubing and, finally, reduce to the machine size in as short a distance as possible. I used metal to reduce from 5" to 4" because it gives a smoother transition.

If you have any questions as you proceed, don't hesitate to ask. I am not an engineer, but I did sleep in a Holiday Inn Express once. :D

Re: DC piping

#22

Re: DC piping

Joseph Mulherin, sr

No, the chair making is not going to be affected. I am presently in the process of redoing my shop to get things I have accumulated over the years.....hoarding I think they call it....out of the way and get rid of a lot of things in the drawers and cabinets I do not use or need anymore. Drew up a "map" of the shop and placed tables, benches, Shopsmith, band saw, and router table on it according to their individual sizes.

Wonders....I will have some room to move around again.....YEA!!! Also am going to reinstall some 4ft lighting fixtures I have set aside. The vacuum system I am just going to use my DC from Shopsmith (330CFM) for saw and band saw and my Shopvac for the router table setup

I finished the first chair about two weeks ago...decided to keep it for myself and go back and do the others according to Hal Taylor's instructions more closely.

Figured up the material cost of this chair and it came to almost $400 total for wood, bolts, glue, epoxy. But I found a dealer in used wood in my local area(56 miles) where I can go to and obtain some good slabs for a reasonable price....still each chair is still going to cost about $300 before finished.....but they are for my family....7 chairs...5 large, 2 medium. Have plans for small and children's chairs but do not figure on making them.