We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I am not fond of minimally finished walnut so I always stain it with a mineral pigment stain. But I am making something that will have holly string inlay( a first) so it can't be stained as I have done in the past or I will loose the holly contrast, I suppose. Plenty of stuff is made with holly inlay so there must be lots of experience out there. What are the finish options?
I am going to suggest something non-traditional, General's HP Poly. It is a water based poly acrylic with a uv inhibiter. I know you are not big on using water based finishes and knowing this I would still recommend this finish to you for this project.
Years ago Fine Woodworking did an article on the new breed of water based finishes and General’s hp poly came out on top for its crystal clear clarity and abrasion resistance. I have been using it for about 4 years or more and it adds less color to a piece than anything I have ever used. You probably won’t care for it for the walnut because it will come out looking more like it does right now as far as color but so will the holly. It does not darken at all over time and after about a month becomes very tough.
In application it sands more like nitrocellulose than anything else and rubs out exactly the same way as well. I typically apply 2-3 coats with a good synthetic artists brush before sanding back the raised grain. I then follow with another two coats, all coats are very thin. I use the gloss formula and I don’t care for the glassy look it has so I knock it back with some #0000steel wool and then hit it with a coat of past wax. I have never sprayed it but it is supposed to be formulated to be able to spray as well as brush.
If you insist on an oil based finish a top quality tung oil such as Southerland Wells will add the least amount of color.
thanks for the suggestion. I need to try this material for something as I have heard so much favorable about it. I know the formulations chemist at General and he is a no BS sort of guy. He was quite proud of this material.
I don't mind a bit of yellowing as this is a 1720's looking piece, but I can't stand to stain, at least the raw wood for it will adversely color the holly. I have gotten a finishing schedule from a Period reproduction shop and they use a burnt umber glaze after a coat or two of shellac. They claim the glaze will not take on the dense holly but will richen up the walnut.
Pictured incorporates "white" sapwood with heart. Finish is 2 spit coats of Ultra Pale dewaxed shellac then 3 coats of General's Enduro Clear Poly. Application is HVLP and the finish is "off the gun"; no rubbing called for.
Sneak Peek: This is my #1 Grandson's crib which will be the topic of a Shot Shot when I get it written up.
The General HP Poly that Robin uses is a bit warmer where the Enduro which is water-white. The Enduro is designed to be sprayed but the HP can, IIRC, be hand applied. Do not, however, use foam brushes with the waterbornes as the brush entraps to much air in the finish. The General cross-linker is expensive ($35/pint) but increases chem and abrasion resistance by a factor of 4.
In either case I suggest you go with the gloss and then adjust the final surface as you wish. The gloss will give a clearer film with more visual depth.
I admit I hadn't heard of this before and after investigating doubt I will ever use it.
One of the great benefits of shellac in my opinion is the ease of repair / cleaning and re-coating. I remember in the 40's and 50's of "spring cleaning" and gentlemen "refinishing / refreshing" the shellac coated woodwork. This consisted of a cleaning with water/soap, rinsing and drying and then wiping down with a thin shellac / alcohol mixture. the woodwork shown like new and this treatment could be continued forever. In the event the woodwork was scratched, repair was very easy. The poly's (which shellac with cross linker added becomes) could only be repaired by sanding off the old finish and re-staining, and re-coating which IMHO never quite matched the old finish. If I want to use a poly, I will just purchase Minwax and use it. I do remember hardwood floors coated with shellac - same situation as the woodwork. Didn't hold up near as long as poly's - in my opinion looked better and could be re-coated like new in a very short time. 10 years down the road the shellac floors and woodwork looked like new while the poly's definitely showed all the wear and damage.