Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

House surge protector

Posts

House surge protector

#1

House surge protector

Larry in nw ohio

I considering putting in a whole house protector. Is it much of a job to put one in. Also is there a difference between a surge protector and a surge supressor or are they they one in the same. Also same questions about a GFI. Thank you Larry

Re: House surge protector

#2

Re: House surge protector

Barry Irby

I don't know enough about surge suppressors to answer your questions.

I have never heard of a whole house GFCI and do't think you would want one. Some devices such as refrigerators and freezers generate false trips which could cause the loss of everything within. Thus, it is permissible to have a dedicated circuit for one in the garage where all the other outlets are to be GFCI protected. The outlet must be labeled.

Newer houses have AFCI (Arc Fault Current Interrupter) outlets in the bedrooms. These shut down the circuit if arcing occurs. I have never heard of one functioning as intended and saving a life or structure. I take Code training every year and I always ask for feed back. The instructors appear baffled that I want real world results. What I get is people are really ticked by them tripping when they plug and unplug their vacuum cleaner. Since these are breakers only, they have to troop down to the panel to turn it back on.

Re: House surge protector

#3

Re: House surge protector

John McGaw

Your typical whole-house surge protector is going to offer protection to appliances and such but will not be sufficient for delicate electronic devices which really want to have their own protection (and probably Uninterruptable Power Supply too) for maximum safety.

Installation seems very simple to me. The worst of them require you to punch a knockout in your breaker box and attach a few wires to a double-pole breaker and ground. The easiest of them calls for nothing more than inserting a little box in place of a double-pole breaker and attaching the ground wire. An example of the former would be something like a Supco SCM150 while the latter would be a Square D QO (which is what I use). Installing any of these safely calls for one to kill the main power feed and get intimate with the innards of the breaker panel and anyone who finds that thought daunting should probably call an electrician.

Re: House surge protector

#4

Re: House surge protector

Howard Norman

Like John McGaw I have the Square D QO surge protector. It has been in the box about 15 years now. I had one lightning strike that hit a tree in the front of the house and then the ground wire from the circuit breaker box to the ground rod. I lost a laptop power supply and a DirecTV box but that is all.

I along with three workmen were in the house when that strike occurred. It was loud!

Re: House surge protector

#5

Bob

Re: House surge protector

Bob

Most Power companies offer a plan where they send you protectors you plug into outlets and plug devices into them. You can get a number of features for about $5 a month insurance included to replace any electronics that are destroyed if plugged into the device. If you add it up you are way ahead with them.

Re: House surge protector

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: House surge protector

Jesper, Denmark

Barry, like you, I know nothing about surge protectors.

On the other hand, ground fault interruptors on the incoming line is required here by code - and has been for many years. They work very well. Older HFI units were somewhat prone to trip in lightning storms, but the newer HPFI units are super reliable.

They are not effected by any installed downstream equipment, as long as there are no leaks to ground. It might help to understand how they work: In a normal circuit, the hot and neutral - or phase-to-phase - currents are in balance - same amperage on both wires. A ground fault disturbs that balance and the HFI relay detects any unbalance over 20 mA and trips the main breaker.

A typical house installation here is three phase, 380 volt phase to phase and 220 volt phase to neutral.

Power surges are uncommon, as all the low voltage (<11 kV) wiring is underground.

Re: House surge protector

#7

Re: House surge protector

Paul Leuba

In evaluating the benefits/costs of a whole house surge protector vs. point of use surge protectors, I chose to go with the smaller, point of use surge protectors that plug directly into an electric receptical. The appliance then plugs into the surge protector. I purchased a few of them from APC for about $17 each. They come equiped with two LEDs that reveal that the protector is still good, and wether it has been hit with a surge or not. I use them on the TV, Regrigerator, Washing Machine, and any other electronic equipment. The comuters are protected with 400 VA UPS devices.

The primary reason I went with the point of use surge protectors is to provide surge protection when my home generator is in use. I do not believe that generator power is very clean with respect to power spikes.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: House surge protector

#8

Re: House surge protector

John McGaw

Some years ago during my later military career I had cause to attend a multi-day FEMA course on protecting electrical/electronic equipment from surges whether they be caused by lightning strikes or EMP from a nuclear explosion. As you might expect absolute protection is not possible in every case but if your equipment is to stand the best chance of surviving the big one then multi-level protection is a must. That means that, while a single surge protector on the power line may help, several applied at different points some distance apart will probably work better. Their example as applied to an emergency broadcasting station would have protection at the power substation, at the power feed to the station, at the main circuit boxes, at each sensitive device, at each place a signal enters or leaves the building, at the transmitter shack, at the base of the antenna, etc. Obviously this isn't directly applicable to a a home but having surge protectors at the power entry point and at each sensitive device is a good idea. Protection of incoming coaxial and POTS cables by at least using the proper grounding blocks is also mandatory. Really effective surge protection on signal lines is difficult if one is to achieve a balance of protection and signal transmission -- they don't always go together well.

Re: House surge protector

#9

You're Very Right

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The small, gas-powered generators put out "dirty" power with lots of spikes and harmonics. I've used a 6K unit for years, but have my computers and BU drives triple insulated with UPS batteries, surge strips, and switch boxes. Still, the software keeps flagging the generator power as erratic. This is part of the reason we're going to a whole-house standby unit that has filters built into the circuits to smooth out the output and protect all our MP-controlled appliances.

Re: House surge protector

#10

Re: House surge protector

Jay Lombardo

Whole house Surge Protectors are very effective and are now fairly reasonable. i have installed dozens of them and highly recommend them. They come in different values, good, better, best kind of thing. Buy the best you can afford. It is not a bad idea to put another point of use protector on things like computers & especially large (expensive!!) flat screens, in my experience they are more susceptible than other electronics. Nothing will protect you from a direct hit, had to rewire several homes due to this, low voltage stuff like intercoms and speakers were missing 6 ft sections of wire, vaporized. They are very easy to install, turn off power, mount on box, wire to 2 pole breaker and ground.