Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

Posts

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#26

Why predriers became popular

Bill Tindall

Some years ago it was common to see literally acres of drying lumber piled outdoors at lumber drying facilities. It was being "air dried". The only difference between this air drying lumber and that in some woodworkers back yard was that it was probably stacked and covered better. When the moisture content was reduced sufficiently it was moved to a building that would supply a source of controlled humidity air circulated uniformly through the pile, aka a kiln. The lumber was reduced to something less than 7% moisture and then equilibrated back to 7%, often with steam.

While cheap, the air drying rate was at the mercy of the weather and wind. And the lumber suffered defects as a result of this lack of control of the drying rate. The goal is to have all the lumber drying at the same constant rate, something that is hard to achieve in a stack out doors. As customers became more picky (I expect it was the export market that was most picky ) drying operations needed to change their operations to reduce drying defects. To eliminate the drying defects from air drying, predriers were adapted. A predrier is an arrangement to control air flow, and possibly temperature, to be able to control drying rate in the early critical stages of drying when the lumber begins to shrink. It may be a building with fans, for example. During this critical drying stage moisture must be removed at a rate fast enough to prevent mold and other color defects, but not so fast as to generate moisture gradients in the lumber at any place in the stacks. With great care these requirements can be met in your back yard. They are always met in a well run predrier.

When the drying rate in the predrier becomes inefficiently slow, the lumber is moved to an environment where the humidity of the air can be lowered to increase the drying rate and achieve the specification of 7% moisture content, aka the "kiln". The task of the kiln is to 1.maintain all the lumber in the kiln at the same moisture content and 2. remove a certain amount of moisture each day balancing the need to get the job done as quickly as possible without generating excessive moisture gradients anywhere in the kiln. The humidity can be lowered by heating the air (common when wood waste is available to make steam) or by a dehumidifier.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#27

A typical kiln drying schedule

Bill Tindall

Here is the schedule for a particularly huge KD operation where I have contacts:

After the predrier the starting kiln temperature target is 85 degrees. Depending on species and thickness temperature is raised so that the humidity of the air in the kiln is reduced by a prescribed amount each day which in turn lowers the moisture content of the lumber each day by a prescribed amount, depending on species and thickness. To get the lumber below the target of 7% the final temperature is 160 degrees. The top of my lumber shed can reach 140 degrees for comparison. When the lumber reaches the target moisture content it is "soaked" at this temperature in high humidity air to soften it which relaxes any stress acquired anywhere in the drying process. Keep in mind that the lumber may be mashed flat under tons of other lumber. This last step is like steam "unbending" and the lumber will assume permanently what ever shape it is in, presumably flat.

There are lots of ways to load or operate a kiln improperly, just as there are lots of ways to screw up air drying in your back yard. The difference is that any operation that screws up much is out of business. Picky customers have no hesitation to return a truck load, or ship load, of lumber that isn't dried properly.

The bottom line of it all is that there is no theoretical advantage of air dried lumber over KD lumber for typical furniture making. The odds favor the KD lumber as being better quality.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#28

Re: A typical kiln drying schedule

TomD

Perhaps part of the problem here is the sense that air drying takes place out of doors. I really do not like storing wood out of doors, I have done it, and in my case it has lead to larger losses.

One place I store wood is a shed with open doors so the air circulates. I experience certain affects around the doors, there is a roof overhang, but in general it works very well a little further back in. I just added doors, and I now will have to see what happens to my wood. For one thing we had temps of 45 C, back in Ontario.

So in general my air drying occurs indoors but not in any kiln, though there can be very elevated temps at times.

"The bottom line of it all is that there is no theoretical advantage of air dried lumber over KD lumber for typical furniture making."

To be really truthful, there is no advantage to solid wood over manufactured products for typical woodworking.

There certainly are advantages to non-KD wood for companies that steam bend parts, and that is pretty common.

I don't really care about factory operations, but certainly operations that do reasonable volume "hand made" work, often use air dried walnut, I can think of several better names in that category.

Air drying will normally lead to a slow drying gradiant by definition. Kiln drying is intended to accelerate the process within certain parameters. It is about speed.

"The odds favor the KD lumber as being better quality."

I think in general your summary confuses processes with quality control. There are a lot of people air drying very high quality wood. tonewoods do come to mind. Usually air dried is slow food, so there is really no reason to loose a lot, or have it come out at less quality. What you can't do without a lot of space is push a lot of wood through. The real issue is not quality, but getting as many turns out of your capital invested as possible. Industry is about profit, not quality. They can go hand in hand, but it is of no interest as long as profit is maximized.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#29

Re: more complicated than I made it

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

Bill,

Are you suggesting that allowing customers to sort through a stack of wood is part of the conditions that make pretzels? After I search, I always restack as orderly as possible, given the encountered wood and pretzel like wood. I tend to leave the pretzels on top whenever possible. Occasionally there is some moisture visible on the wood. This suggests that the stack of wood has either been precipitated upon while in transit or was not really dried fully. Note I only got to see it once open inside the big orange box building.

My local pretzel distribution location is HD and the lumber once opened is entirely indoors.

Here in colorado, doubt that we have tremendous moisture contents.

But we do get pretzels.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#30

Re: Why predriers became popular

Ray - Middletown, in

Miller Lumber still air dries for a couple of weeks before hitting the kilns. And, as I recall control the temperature within the kiln carefully. It has been a while since the tour but those two I do remember.

Ray

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#31

Dale Lenz

Much of the framing

Dale Lenz

lumber found in lumber yard/Boxes are only dried down to 19% to keep critters from growing during transent/before customer gets it home. As the lumber is picked through and not put back neatly all the downward force of lumber cris-crossed in the pile can have something to do with board warpaged plus uneven moisture drying within the boards.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#32

Re: drying and heat *LINK*

R Payne

Here is a paper, while not on wood generally, does show that heat changes the bonding ability of lignin (among other things). It shows a change in dry lignin in some form starting at 125 and at lower temperatures when wet.

I found that with 10 minutes of searching and reading.

It sounds reasonable that if heat can change the properties of lignin when it is extracted from wood, then it can change the properties of lignin within the wood.


The physical chemistry of lignin

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#33

Re: Why predriers became popular

Bill Tindall

Each site has its own economics. Two weeks typically will not result in lumber reaching a moisture content where it begins to shrink. It is not til it starts shrinking that bad stuff can happen. The operation you describe appears to be doing in the kiln what others do in a predrier. And indeed some operations, especially those not exporting may do even more drying outside.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#34

No

Bill Tindall

Are you suggesting that allowing customers to sort through a stack of wood is part of the conditions that make pretzels?

No. A certain amount of the pieces in the pile will have grain orientation and the like that will result in pretzels when it further dries unrestrained in the store. In CO many times of year it is going to dry.....a lot. After a bit of picking the pretzel concentration is going to increase in what is left.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#35

Dale Lenz

YES!

Dale Lenz

As my above post said, it doesn't help. I agree with your post but, my post still STANDS!

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#36

Re: YES!

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

That would tend depend upon the anchor for your post.

Did you put it in concrete or just dirt.....

Sorry the devil made me post it.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#37

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

charlie belden

Could it be that the air dried lumber has a higher MC to begin with than the KD,especially towards the middle of the board so it's not air dried vs kiln dried but MC at the beginning of the steaming process, and the MC of the middle section of the board?

I'm not familar with what the chemical and physical changes steam causes in the wood. Does it temporarily weaken the lignen between the wood cells, thus letting the wood cells move without rupturing?

Anecdotal evidence just tells you what a few people's experience has been - often without any specifics about dimensions, type of wood, grain uniformity, measured MC, whether the end grain was sealed before air drying, the amount of curvature over length, the rate at which the steamed wood was bent to achieve the desired curve, the ambient conditions of the environment when bending, etc.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#38

The action of steam

Bill Tindall

I don't know what effect steam has on the lignin but its effect on the cellulose is to weaken the bonds between cellulose molecules which enables the molecules, and hence the bulk structure, of the wood to move in a plastic like fashion. There are chemical treatments that reversibly accomplish this same goal. Steaming out a dent employs the same phenomena. The wood is plasticized and the compressed fibers spring back to their original position, more or less.

I know someone that makes ladder back chairs, dozens per year, and they steam and bend the back slats and legs from KD lumber with good success. This observation does not deny that less dried wood bends more successfully. I have no personal experience in bending.