Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

Posts

A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#1

A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

Bill Tindall

Among some there is a notion that kiln dried (KD) lumber is inherently defective, inferior or what ever and that the cure to these ills is to use air dried lumber. The two issues that are most often raised by the advocates of air dried lumber are color and stability. The purpose of this post is to challenge these myths with facts about KD lumber.

Stability: Modern kiln drying operations have from several hundred thousand to several million bdft capacity to dry lumber which translates to several hundred thousand to several million dollars at risk in these kilns. Any company that chooses to stay in business will devote what ever resources are necessary to ensure their KD product meets the needs of their customers.

A factory turning KD lumber into wood products places no less demands on the workability of their lumber than the individual woodworker. These companies have the experience to know when lumber is not up to specification and the clout to make claims against the supplier when it is not.

It therefore logically follows that a modern KD operation runs their kilns to provide the best product they can to their customers. When it comes to stability "best" means that the rate at which moisture is removed from the green wood is precisely controlled to avoid stress. As an example, the large KD facilities in my area put lumber on sticks soon after it is sawed and then move this lumber to a controlled environment, for example a predrier, where drying conditions can be controlled. When this predrying process is complete the lumber is moved into an environment where the temperature and air flow can be regulated to uniformly remove precise amounts of water from the lumber each day. The rate of water removal is precisely controlled to avoid excessive moisture gradients in the wood that would result in stress. This last process is called kiln drying. To some, I suppose, KD may imply that the lumber is baked in an oven till its done, which sounds bad, and it would be.

An individual drying wood in their back yard has little control over the rate at which moisture is removed from a lumber stack. It is certain that the rate will not be uniform through out the pile. If the lumber drying fastest in the pile dries slower than the rate in a commercial predrier and kiln the product from the back yard can be as good as the KD product. However, if the drying rate is too small discoloration can occur.

Color: The popular example here is walnut. Air dry advocates claim that air dried walnut has colors and variations in color that are more attractive than the brown of KD walnut or the more uniform brown of steamed and KD walnut. Most commercial walnut has been steamed. (I have seen no difference in KD- not steamed and air dried walnut on a fresh planed surface)

The colors of walnut are fleeting when it is exposed to sun light. Fresh off the saw walnut can be yellow or green. It soon turns to purples, reds and browns. Eventually it turns brown and eventually light yellow-brown. Several times I have posted a picture of matching pieces of walnut air dried vs steamed and KD after a few months exposure in a sunny room. There is hardly a detectable difference between them. After a year there will be no detectable difference. I can post again if there remains a skeptic.

Commercial operations get their lumber on sticks quickly. They may even dip the lumber in antifungal chemicals. As a result lumber from these sources remains bright and stain-free.

There are lots of valid reasons to air dry lumber, access to a kiln being the most common. There is no need to rationalize one's desire or need to air dry lumber by claiming a mythical quality advantage.

That said it is certainly possible to screw up a load of lumber in a kiln, or the air drying before the kiln. In my experience these screw ups occur in tiny KD operations (small, package dehumidification kilns) with distressing frequency. They would be rare to nonexistent in the large KD facilities.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#2

JL

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

JL

I don't think that kiln dried lumber is substandard or inferior to air-dried lumber.

In terms of disease and insect infestation alone, kiln dried lumber is by far superior to air dried lumber.

The only issue I have with kiln dried lumber is in its steam bending properties. Once the lumber is "set" by the kilning process, it is exceeding difficult to steam bend consistently.

My failure rates for "irrecoverable" defects is as follows

Green lumber - 5% or so

Air dried lumber - 15-20%

Kiln dried lumber - 65-75%

I define an irrecoverable defect as one that would cause severe structural or cosmetic issues with a piece.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#3

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

Jesse Cloud

My experience with steam bending is similar to JL's. I always try to find air dried, but when that's just not available, I will use kiln dried. I have found the higher failure rate in walnut, cherry, and maple. If anyone knows a workaround for this, I would love to learn it!

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#4

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

TomD

"Among some there is a notion that kiln dried (KD) lumber is inherently defective, inferior or what ever and that the cure to these ills is to use air dried lumber."

First off, that is a straw man. You are using the word "defective". The true claim is that there are differences, and that to some these differences are important. That is a very difficult claim to counter.

In my case that would certainly be true, but it would be a case a where I choose KD for some stuff, and not for others. A third major issue would be price. Air dried wood is cheaper under some circumstances.

" The two issues that are most often raised by the advocates of air dried lumber are color and stability. The purpose of this post is to challenge these myths with facts about KD lumber."

Colour is obviously undeniable, some kiln drying changes colour radically, like sapwood on walnut to brown, which to many is an advantage. In other cases the results sought, and received are probably slight, but in the eye of the beholder. Krenov made this point and is probably the source of a lot of that myth. He worked at the time almost entirely in wood you, nor your KD friends may have ever been in the presence of, so who should one believe. But one should not transfer his perceptions to some domestic woods either. Some of the fabulous woods he worked, had colour based entirely on decay (not talking spalted, but stuff like brazilian). Who knows

"Stability: Modern kiln drying operations have from several hundred thousand to several million bdft capacity to dry lumber which translates to several hundred thousand to several million dollars at risk in these kilns. Any company that chooses to stay in business will devote what ever resources are necessary to ensure their KD product meets the needs of their customers."

That is an opinion, there is no serious technical point there. And obviously given that those customers are irrelevant to me, a complete nonsense. It is like arguing that chinese manufacturers like to aggregate massive amounts of scrap, and that must work for them, therefore I should use scrap to make custom stainless knives.

"A factory turning KD lumber into wood products places no less demands on the workability of their lumber than the individual woodworker. These companies have the experience to know when lumber is not up to specification and the clout to make claims against the supplier when it is not."

Big deal, they might be making flooring, not violin bows, who gives a toss?

"It therefore logically follows that a modern KD operation runs their kilns to provide the best product they can to their customers."

Not really logical, and what does "can" mean, McDonalds does that, and sells food that is poison.

"When it comes to stability "best" means that the rate at which moisture is removed from the green wood is precisely controlled to avoid stress. As an example, the large KD facilities in my area put lumber on sticks soon after it is sawed and then move this lumber to a controlled environment, for example a predrier, where drying conditions can be controlled. When this predrying process is complete the lumber is moved into an environment where the temperature and air flow can be regulated to uniformly remove precise amounts of water from the lumber each day. The rate of water removal is precisely controlled to avoid excessive moisture gradients in the wood that would result in stress. This last process is called kiln drying. To some, I suppose, KD may imply that the lumber is baked in an oven till its done, which sounds bad, and it would be."

I think the process is not necessarily bad, of course most people have no idea what it was, at any given time, or what it means for them. or whether better processes exist for their use, etc... I think the real issue on stability is that the good wood is probably not going there in the first place it is a garbage in garbage out process. Ask them about their guitar soundboards, 8 foot wide slabs for tables, or wood for bows, or arrows. The good stuff never goes through these guy's hands.

"An individual drying wood in their back yard has little control over the rate at which moisture is removed from a lumber stack. It is certain that the rate will not be uniform through out the pile. If the lumber drying fastest in the pile dries slower than the rate in a commercial predrier and kiln the product from the back yard can be as good as the KD product. However, if the drying rate is too small discoloration can occur."

Well just re-write that except substitute some claptrap about their great industrial planers and CNC machines vs. my hands on approach and Japanese planes. I sure wouldn't want to live off my productivity, but quality I have no concern over. You should see the stuff I got out of the beech I harvested 26 months ago. 1) nobody around here sells beech 2) they don't cut it for plane makers, or even know how to do that 3) the stuff dried with zero loss, except a few pieces I moved in front of a window

"Color: The popular example here is walnut. Air dry advocates claim that air dried walnut has colors and variations in color that are more attractive than the brown of KD walnut or the more uniform brown of steamed and KD walnut. Most commercial walnut has been steamed. (I have seen no difference in KD- not steamed and air dried walnut on a fresh planed surface)"

As I say, I think this was all about Krenov, and his tropical woods. I do think there are issues here, but these are minor for most NA woods/users, but the fact the steam cycle can brown sapwood, pretty much makes me want to listen to people who care about these things rather than people who are looking at this as an industrial product. Those are the people that think that drip dry shirts were as good as Egyptian cotton.

"The colors of walnut are fleeting when it is exposed to sun light. Fresh off the saw walnut can be yellow or green. It soon turns to purples, reds and browns. Eventually it turns brown and eventually light yellow-brown. Several times I have posted a picture of matching pieces of walnut air dried vs steamed and KD after a few months exposure in a sunny room. There is hardly a detectable difference between them. After a year there will be no detectable difference. I can post again if there remains a skeptic."

Fleeting and hardly detectable describe some of my favorite things from sly smiles to mayflies. Craft and art are about the distinctions, not the industrial uniformity. Until work finds a soul nobody will give a toss. Even a lot of amateurs know that focusing on making stuff for family. counting on pity rather than the worth of the work itself.

"Commercial operations get their lumber on sticks quickly. They may even dip the lumber in antifungal chemicals. As a result lumber from these sources remains bright and stain-free."

Oh goodness... There goes lunch...

"There are lots of valid reasons to air dry lumber, access to a kiln being the most common. There is no need to rationalize one's desire or need to air dry lumber by claiming a mythical quality advantage."

You're the guy who used my Ouchi chisel as a cold chisel...

I don't think you have come close to proving your point, but why would the making of a myth be a bad thing even if that was all there was to it? Myth is where truth lies in culture. Yeah sure, there is lying also, but we all know that already.

"That said it is certainly possible to screw up a load of lumber in a kiln, or the air drying before the kiln. In my experience these screw ups occur in tiny KD operations (small, package dehumidification kilns) with distressing frequency. They would be rare to nonexistent in the large KD facilities."

Or in my backyard...

You just shot yourself in the foot. Are you seriously trying to impress us with the claim that not only is KD fine but better still it only works at massive scale? Do you really think that is an impressive argument.? There is probably nothing I want in raw materials that is made at massive scale.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#5

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#6

Re: My God, Tom...

TomD

Thanks. I have a lot of respect for Bill, so I am not going to leave much unsaid.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#7

Kiln Question

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Bill and Tom....good stuff!

I do have a question.... Both of you reference kilns. Tom mentions steam as well. But kilns in both writings are somewhat referred to in a generic sense. Over the years I have bought a variety of woods from a variety of sources. I have come to learn that kilns can vary a lot. Even though there are some ideals for kiln operating conditions I have found that kilns can be built and operated in different ways.

I wonder how that affects the conversation?

T.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#8

Re: Kiln Question

TomD

I mentioned that too, in my set-up. One can't generically talk about what kilns will or won't do. And this creates problem for Bill since he is trying to generalize. It also creates problems for craftsmen, who will not know in many parts of the country what a kiln somewhere else is doing (Bill seems to live in an area with resources and craftspeople aplenty). I have used microwave, and vac, or air drying depending on what I was doing. And some hot rooms. But I also buy industrial wood fiber products, like fine plywoods, or framing lumbers, and they all go through kilns.

I would say that what Bill said is largely true, but since the argument has always been over the other .00001 percent, where does that get you?

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#9

Re: Kiln Question

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I get some of my best lumber from backwoods sawmills and the like. The goin' rate is about $.50 bf extra for kiln dried. But those folks down there don't have "fancy" setups sometimes. When it comes to kilns some of those fellas build them "resourcefully" Hey...it's the back woods....waddya expect? ;-)

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#10

When is a kiln a kiln?

Ray - Middletown, in

If wood is placed in a closed chamber, heated and humidity controlled, I guess that to be a kiln. If wood is stacked and stickered under a lean to I guess that to be air dried. What if wood is placed in a chamber/room and just a dehumidifier used, is that kiln dried or air dried? Inquiring minds want to know.

Ray

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#11

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#12

Re: A matter of nomenclature

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I have seen different desgns and heat sources. One I remember incorporated the kiln into a heating system for other buildings...cool idea. But since designs and operating can vary I would imagine that might be considered a variable in the big scheme of kiln drying.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#13

Re: When is a kiln a kiln?

TomD

"If wood is stacked and stickered under a lean to I guess that to be air dried. "

Depends on the lean to, some of those qualify as solar kilns.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#14

I won't argue against KD lumber, BUT

Keith Newton

Some of the things that bigger operations lead to, is un-willingness to do much more than their run of the mill dimensions, due of course to the suppliers only wanting to carry the faster moving common everyday stuff.

I only saw trees for my own use, so I primarily saw thicker than what I can easily find anytime.

As for the benefit, Air Drying is only going to result in 12% MC, which is 4 - 6% above EMC for a controlled atmosphere around here, so I stack and sticker most to air dry, then bring it in to finish off in a hot-box, which usually only takes a couple of days to get on down.

As for other properties, I started carving before I ever worked in a shop. I will say that I had much rather carve AD over KD. Without knowing anything about EMC back then, I didn't like confronting the toughness which made it hard to get those good clean surfaces when I knew I was going with the grain, there would sometimes be some of that tear-out ahead of the chisel edge.

Back in my early years, I assumed that was somehow due to the kiln, rather than the ending MC just making it harder. I didn't know that DRY wood is about twice as hard as WET wood, and the compressibility across the grain can make a huge difference to a carver.

My first job as a furniture maker was back in 1969 in Dallas. I went to work for a French designer who was importing lots of wonderful antiques from Europe, and doing knockoff tables among other things to suit the customers desires. I was amazed at the carving on those antique pieces, and am now convinced that those carvers were probably doing their work before the wood was fully dry. At least that is how I would do it now, if I had a huge carving job.

Through the years carving lots of different species, I feel confident to say that I can carve some woods against the grain wet, and get a better cut than cutting with the grain when fully dry.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#15

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

My question may not be in tune with the rest of this but here it is anyway.

Ever been to home depot or similar and looked through the piles of 2x4s and others and found nothing but pretzel like wood twisted and warped. If this is an example of kiln dried wood, would the same wood have been any different if air dried or did the drying characteristics of the kiln make this wood more vulnerable to twisting and warping?

I have seen maple have warps and twists on what I recall was air dried (back in NH).

So my curiosity is peaked by this question.

Is a pretzel like piece of wood the result of how it was dried or the way it was cut?

or something else?

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#16

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#17

Re: The way it grew, then...

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

So kiln drying plays no role or could play a role in pretzel production?

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#18

there are only two ways to operate a kiln

Bill Tindall

The kiln can be operated so that there is only a small moisture gradient established in the lumber and air flow is uniform throughout the kiln,.....or not. In case 1 a stress-free product will be produced and in case 2 the product may have drying defects of one kind or another, or all kinds.

Other variables such as source of heat, whether there is dehumidification, etc are irrelevant.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#19

Why Pretzels

Bill Tindall

Framing is dried to approximately 18 % . Lumber shrinks in the range of about 25 to 0 %. Differential shrinkage along the length or width of a board results in deflection. In the kiln the lumber is constrained from moving much because it has a zillion bdft piled on top of it. The "dry" bundles are banded and it remains constrained. Then it gets put into a rack at Lowes in the winter where the humidity is 30% and the lumber continues to dry unrestrained from 18% to 8% and the differential shrinkage makes pretzels..... if the lumber is susceptible to differential shrinkage. Radial grain shrinks about half tangential and longitudinal doesn't shrink at all. If the board has all three grain orientations, guaranteed around knots, warping, cupping and twisting can be expected.

Less often, just the way it grew, for example leaning, can result in pretzels.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#21

Re: Why Pretzels

Jesse Cloud

I guess the question behind the pretzel question is "Doesn't Lowes care?" and the corollary question is "Don't the framers/builders care?"

I guess as long as we keep buying pretzels for our door jambs, there's not much reason for Lowes to care and improve their product....

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#22

more complicated than I made it

Bill Tindall

Lumber with knots is going to have all three of the grain orientations that have greatly different shrinkage as the board dries. Framing lumber often has the center of the tree included, especially in 2 x 4's which are sawed from small trees. This early growth wood has still more different shrinkage as it dries. Western wood often has a spiral grain orientation which offers still another opportunity for rogue shrinkage.

Even though the board starts out flat it is not going to want to stay that way as it dries and shrinks differently in different directions. By proper stacking in the kiln, or air drying as it doesn't matter, the weight of the pile will constrain the lumber into flatness, more or less. Some lumber is strong enough to resist restraining, more or less, for example yellow pine.

Then add on top of these considerations the fact that the lumber is going to dry unrestrained after it is unbanded at the retailer.

Lowes has yet another problem. They let customers pick lumber. I have watched persons sort through layers of lumber searching for "perfect" boards. After a few sorts what is left doesn't look so good. After many sorts they bundle what is left and sell it at discount to carpenters who know how to use it effectively.

The bottom line of it is that framing lumber is sawed from trees that will yield lumber that is not wanting to dry straight and flat and it is sold not very dry which add to the problem

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#23

Re: more complicated than I made it

TomD

A lot of kiln dried lumber then sits around and gets rained on, and can be wet as if it came straight from the tree. Up here we sometimes get it frozen to boot. There are different grades of lumber out there for framing, and the stuff we are getting in Lowes and HD is really bad at the moment, a few years back it was pretty darn good if one just cut around it a little. On large jobs they buy the whole stack then quickly frame it into place where the sheathing, etc... will hold it straight. But left to kick around the store, some of it will get to look pretty bad.

Wood will return to environmental moisture content sooner or latter, even when encapsulated in high solids epoxy. So KDing it to various fanciful numbers isn't going to get you anywhere.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#24

Re: there are only two ways to operate a kiln

R Payne

Heat is not irrelevant if the temperature is warm enough to set the lignin and may affect other compounds that make up wood. That changes greatly the properties of the lumber and certainly makes a difference.

Re: A discussion of the myths of kiln dried lumber

#25

drying and heat

Bill Tindall

Heat, other than its effect on drying rate and humidity will have no effect on either color or stability, the two issues most often rationalized for air dried lumber. I have never seen a study exploring whether wood dried at120 degrees differs in properties from wood dried at 150 degrees. I suspect there is no significant difference just from the fact that nobody in the industry seems to fret about the final kiln temperature. Other than the impact on cost of operating the kiln I have never heard temperature discussed. The only specification is per cent moisture. If it is 7% or less factories turn it successfully into products and so can individuals.

I know of no chemical basis for the concept of heat "setting" the lignin. The main effect of drying is the collapse of the wood cells and the volatilization of resins and the like.

For wood that has a high concentration of volatiles, for example pine, kiln temperature affects whether the remaining resin is hard or sticky. Wood dried at a very high temperature, higher than any commercial kiln operates, does change physical properties.