Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

Posts

Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

#1

Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

doug f, san clemente, ca

I'm just finishing up a farmhouse table for my son's girlfriend and I'm undecided about an edge treatment. Anyone have an opinion on what's typical; beveled, rounded slightly, bull nose, square. She said "Whatever looks nice.:D "

The wood is clear fir, 2" stock and the top is 36" X 90".

Thanks for you help.

Doug

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

#2

Kneale Brownson

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

Kneale Brownson

I'd use a simple Ogee treatment of the upper edge.

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

#3

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

roger lance

Doug....I'd go for making the edge comfortable for placing your forearms on the table when people sit and talk after eating....a simple round over top and bottom works for me.

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

#4

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

John Veerkamp

Looking at a couple of tables right now. The edges are slightly rounded, about 1/8 round over. Farm house furniture was practical in nature, not fancy, usually constructed on site from materials at hand. In 20th century with the advent of mail order, it was no longer self or locally made but still simple and economical.

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

#5

You guys are the best!

doug f, san clemente, ca

Thanks for the input; I think we're just going to go with a round over top and bottom.

Doug

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

#6

I agree

David Yoho

Two inches is pretty thick for a top of this size but I'm guessing you wanted the heft or you would've gone a little less. Nevertheless, I like the look of a simple but slight round-over. In fact, I have a router bit for 1/8" round-overs just for times like this. It eases the sharp edge enough to be comfortable.

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

#7

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

Barry Irby

Last one I did I used a thumb molding on the top and a round over on the bottom.

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

#8

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

William Duffield

I agree, mostly, with those who recommend simple round overs. However, I'm an inveterate table leaner, so I like a top round over with a bit larger radius, either 3/16" or even 1/4", because I find it a bit more comfortable. Another treatment to consider, if you think your table top looks too heavy, is to put a chamfer on the bottom edge, maybe 1/2" high and 3" wide or so, and then round off the bottom edge.

A fancier style table would call for a fancier edge treatment.

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

#9

Ellis Walentine

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

Ellis Walentine

I'm not clear on what the farmhouse style actually is, but I agree that it should be simple, almost devoid of shape, appearing as a plain vertical edge, maybe 1" - 1 1/4" in thickness, with a slight roundover (1/8" to 3/16" on a top this size) to dull the sharp edge and provide a better surface for holding finish. Sharp edges wear too quickly. To reduce the visual weight of the 2" edge, I would do as William suggests and put a long bevel on the underside of the edge.

I have not seen the complexity or character of the rest of the detail you're including in this table, nor have I seen the context (the surrounding room and furnishings) that it will reside in, so my comments are pretty generic.

Ellis

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

#10

Re: Edge treatment on a farmhouse table

AZ in Colorado Springs

I'd suggest a pair of roundovers -- 1/4" on the upper edge and 3/8" on the lower egde, or 3/8" upper and 1/2" lower (instead of a bevel on the lower edge).