Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Wipe-on Poly question

Posts

Wipe-on Poly question

#1

Wipe-on Poly question

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I have a sideboard project that I am completing. The client wanted poly on the top so I am using a wipe-on satin. The product is fresh and humidity is not bad. The problem is that when I go back and touch up places the finish seems to cut in to the cured finish and create a dull drag. Quickness with application helps but generally the result is uneven areas of sheen.

I have tried waxing and buffing a small area but that wasn't much help. Is there a trick to top coating the poly to achieve an even result?

Thanks...T.

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#2

When I Was Hand-applying

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

poly in any flavor, the "rule" was recoat the entire surface to the first hard edge; spot treating defects only resulted in lap marks and witness lines regardless of what I tried. The advantage of shellac and solvent lacquer shines in this situation.

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#3

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

Dick Coers

It's definitely a "get it on and let it alone" type of finish. I wouldn't try to sand or wax unless there would be something like 5 or 6 coats, with a week of cure time. I've had better luck on something like a table top, to just thin regular poly about 30% and then I have a film thickness that I can sand and smooth. That also gives it some time to flow out. On my woodturning, I put on 3 coats of thin shellac before adding the wipe on poly so the finish builds faster and that also makes it easier to flow on the film of poly.

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#4

On small things,

Keith Newton

I can sometimes get just the right amount on a small rag, then go at it with lots of vigorous rubbing, and get a faster build than just coating. However, as you have already found, having too much in the rag, will just dissolve what is already there.

However, for a sideboard, I think a higher film finish is a better idea, when it comes to resisting spills later on.

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#5

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

It sounds like your almost geting something like a burn in effect which would make me think that it just needs a bit more time to cure between coats, or maybe add a bit of cobalt oil or japan drier to the finish. I am assumeing you are using a oil based poly. What flavor finish you using?

Robin

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#6

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

Bill White

I've started using Old Masters gel poly for wiping. I've had good results so far, but ya gotta move pretty fast when wiping.

Bill

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#7

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Yeah, it's Minwax oil based wipe-on poly. I have used this stuff before. I know if it gets a week it will hard cure and then easier to go over. But I don't have that kind of time. So I was wondering if I can top coat it with something else just to get an even sheen?

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#8

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

Dick Coers

I have used Abralon on a random orbit, with mineral spirits lube, to adjust the sheen. What surprises me, is with the super fine pad, you can actually get a higher sheen that what the finish gives you from the can. I don't remember if you gave the species of wood used. My method doesn't work well with course grain wood. For that I follow up with steel wool if the pores aren't filled.

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#9

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Thanks Dick,

This is on cherry. I have Abralon pads. Do you apply the mineral spirits to the pad? Does the mineral spirits eat into the poly?

T.

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#10

Re: Different Approach

david in indy

I've used polyurethane with success on flat surfaces, like table tops and sideboard tops, following something Jeff Jewitt suggested (and wrote about a long time ago). I don't use pre-made wipe on poly, but a fast drying oil-based polyurethane that I thin with naptha (which evaporates faster than mineral spirits) - with probably one-third in naptha. I apply the thinned varnish with a squirt bottle that I squirt into a folded heavy paper towel and apply long strokes. Becasue it's thinned, you will need to apply a number of coats, but they go very quickly due to the thin coat and the quick drying chemicals in the varnish.

I use gloss always and if I want a satin finish I do that with steel wool as I wax the piece as the last step.

This isn't as fast as spraying but it works well when you can't spray.

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#11

Agree

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Tommy,

That's the way I finished nearly all of my pieces. The first coat or two seems pretty unremarkable, but each succeeding coast adds more gloss and depth. If one of the initial coats looks patchy, leave it alone and recoat. The next application will even out the look. I scuff with 320 grit wet/dry sandpaper every two coats to remove nibs and any dust which may have been present. I've been using minwax semi gloss thinned 50% with naptha. Application is with a good quality paper towel.

George

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#12

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

Thomas S Stockton

Tom

I mix my own using poly and thinner it seems a little thicker than the pre made minwax stuff which is way to runny in my opinion. I used to use naptha but it seems like it has been banned in CA.

I don't think your ever going to get the finish you want doing spot touch up, poly just doesn't do this well, it will work on early coats but not on final ones.

How I apply it is with a rag, put on three coats one a day and then after the third coat sand it real well with 320 and a small block. It needs to be dry and will turn to powder, if it builds a little on the sandpaper change sheets. Before sanding the finish will be a little rough from dust nibs etc but should be pretty even.

After sanding I put the next coats on a little thinner you can also do two coats a day if the conditions are right.

5 or 6 coats is usually good.

If your having drying problems a little bit of japan drier helps a lot.

good luck

Tom

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#13

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

Dick Coers

I just puddle a little on the wood at first. Very quickly the foam backer soaks it up and you will need to add much less as you progress across the work. Really just enough to lube the pad and keep the heat down. If the poly is more than a day old, the mineral spirits won't touch it. When I first saw Abralon demoed, the company rep used a spritz bottle to fog just a little water. I quickly brought up the idea of mineral spirits since any crack in the finish or wood would cause the water to ruin the work. You don't need the spritz bottle, but it does make adding more fluid easier without shutting off the sander.

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#14

Wet Sanding

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You can easily use canola or mineral oil to lube your abrasive. You won't be breathing mineral spirits, it won't dry on you during use, the slurry wipes off cleanly, and it won't compromise your finish.

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#15

What about using Danish oil???


Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#16

Re: What about using Danish oil???

Dick Coers

I would guess that it will start to get a little gummy if it starts to dry. Just guessing though. I like mineral spirits since I can give it a quick wipe and look at a dry finish. It will show any more work needed almost instantly. Wet oil will give you a false sheen until it dries much latter.

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#17

Re: What about using Danish oil???

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Being a drying oil, I used to use it to make a slurry-cum-pore filler on open pore woods like walnut and ash. Works fine for that, but for just wet sanding I want a lubricant that will carry the dust and then wipe off cleanly. Danish will start "drying" as soon as you put it on and spread it out. Then you have to keep adding more (or back to the stoddard/MS) to keep things liquid. Would not be my choice for a lube.

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#18

That is my method also.

Ray - Middletown, in

3-4 coats 3-4 hours between, wet sand with P400 and naptha. 3-4 more coats and wet sand with P800 and naptha then a couple of quick coats and wool and wax. Jeff taught this at Marc Adams when he was teaching down there. Works like a charm.

Ray

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#19

Bob

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

Bob

I just finished a 38" X 72" table using wipe on polly I use light coats and do not pass over the last part I wiped on. I did 4 coats in 3 days then waxed with 0000 steel wool. With that said my last project I used Arm R seal its a polly and oil blend and does a much nicer finish. When you lightly sand it you should get a white powder then you know its dry and safe to lay another coat.

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#20

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

Richard McComas

I follow what's in this article and it has always work well for me.

http://www.hardwoodlumberandmore.com/Articles/ArticleViewPage/tabid/75/ArticleId/5/Wipe-on-Varnish.aspx

Re: Wipe-on Poly question

#21

Re: What about using mineral spirits

Gene Lair

Hi Dick I tried the wipe on mineral spirits on sanded surface and that does show where mor sanding is needed . It shows up right away . I'm with PAW Illinois