Floor model mortising machines
Randy Stukenberg
I am planning on buying a mortising machine soon. Any thoughts/preferences on the Grizzly 0448, Shop Fox or the Powermatic?
Thanks!
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Floor model mortising machines
Randy Stukenberg
I am planning on buying a mortising machine soon. Any thoughts/preferences on the Grizzly 0448, Shop Fox or the Powermatic?
Thanks!
Re: Floor model mortising machines
John in NM
I believe they are all clones, so any difference would be in the details that the various vendors require from the manufacturere, often little more than the paint color.
One thing I would be wary of is those gas piston returns, they wear out quickly and you're left lifting the mortise head back up with the handle. No big deal on a couple of mortises, but it gets very tiresome on a big job.
My favorite import machine used a counter weight instead, but they don't seem to be making that one any more.
Re: Floor model mortising machines
roger lance
I have a Powermatic 719A (the model before the tilting table feature)....wonderful tool....not perfect, but a real heavy duty machine....love the X-Y table.....good stock hold down....I would not want to be without this tool now that I have one.
Re: Floor model mortising machines
TomD
I remember waiting at least 10 years for a mortising machine to make it into the local shops. The first desktop I saw, I bought, it was the Delta which was awesome good quality, made in England but had ridiculous fence and holdown. It was another 10 years before floor models made it out. At the time I bought, FWW had just completed a review in which say, 10 of the models were the solid ones with the metal counter weights, and one was the General International, the first to catch on with all the angle adjusts. (general has a fabulous for real one for factories and stuff that was made in Quebec). That pretty much blew the serious models off the floor, and I was lucky to catch the last one to be sold at my local tool store, on deep discount, as they made way for the toys to follow. Our local store is related to Grizzly and the manager there gripes every time I come about all the ones that have come out since and always asks me if I am ready to sell mine.
So I to would try and find a solid industrial type clone if I could, but in the absence of that, the Powermatic looks attractive. The new paradigm has been around for a while so it should be possible to find a good one. They all make compromises to get all the adjustments in there. One thing I like about the Powermatic is that the vise tilts, which should do less to compromise the machine, and it allows a steep angle, like plane beds, to be cut pretty easily. almost all my mortises are 90 degree affairs, but I can see how a chairmaker might really love some angle adjustments.
Now if someone can just explain to me why a mortiser needs a 2 hp motor to drill a 1/2 hole in a piece of wood.
Re: Floor model mortising machines
TomD
Roger, what is the maximum tilt angle on it?
This is the one I like... *LINK*
John in NM
That ebay vendor is the last to list them, Woodtek used to as well, but no longer. They had been available from Grizzly and Bridgewood about 5 years ago. I suspect the Chinese factory is no longer making them that one with the gas piston now seems to be it other than the heavy Grizzly that's $2k. I've used that one too, its ok, but it seemed the return was awkward on that one as well. It uses a heavy extension spring in the column, and just never seemed as smooth as the counter weighted model - could be it just needed to be bolted to the floor 
http://www.ebay.com/itm/ACCURA-01040-HOLLOW-CHISEL-MORTISING-MACHINE-1-HP-GREAT-MORTISER-SWEET-PRICE-/320908148028?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item4ab79dbd3c
Re: This is the one I like...
TomD
That is the one I have right down to the orange door for chuck access though it is a green colour. Great machine, the only thing is that if you want to make 45 degree cuts you need to lean it up against something. 
Now Wadkins made a nice mortiser, and they seem to be out there in schools and stuff.
Looks like Wadkin still does... *LINK*
John in NM
Make some nice stuff, though I shudder to think of the cost!
The shop where I used that Grizzly with the big spring also had a Wysong and Miles machine that was fantastic, I suspect that is why I didn't much care for the Griz. Accounting for the myopia of memories, I've often wondered what I would think of that Griz and this Acura side by side.
Of course I could do that, more or less. The two machines are in friends' shops about 6 blocks apart 
http://www.wadkin.com/products/browse/-/18/-/Morticers
Re: mortising machines Gas Springs *LINK*
Bob Entwisle in NJ
Nothing to add to mortising machines, but having recently designed a fixture at work that needed a gas spring.
I was surprised at how little they cost, even from McMaster, and also how easy they are to use.