Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

Posts

Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

#1

Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

tom

My wife and I cycle and ride a tandem. It is made to be diassembled and fit into 2 cases. While specific cases are avaible there are quite $$.

I am considering fabricating the cases using 1/4" plywood along with West System epoxy and fiberglass cloth. Then using extruded aluminum fittings to finish up.

My question is how much stronger with the panels be by using this type of system? I know it is usued for boat building.

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

#2

How strong does it need to be?

Keith Newton

Questions which are too brief, will lead to useless answers, or require book size answers that cover all the bases.

Briefly, yes glass over ply will make it stronger, but maybe not a lot. Strength increases with thickness. Doubling a thickness usually means quadrupling strength, but may double the weight. To get around that, boat builders, beat that, by using light weight cores, like balsa, with glass on the outer faces.

You may double the strength just by going with 3/8" or 1/2" ply, for less money, and lighter than glass over 1/4", and a whole lot less time.

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

#3

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

john lucas

There are too many factors involved. Molded plastic cases can have strength areas molded in to increase stiffness and still keep it light. I think wooden cases will be strong enough in most cases. The most likely thing to damage your bike will be crushing or compression and the molded cases are just as vulnerable to this as your wooden one. I don't think the fiber glass cloth will strengthen it enough to prevent this problem. The epoxy will make it water proof and probably help bond the aluminum to it but won't really affect the crushing damage either.

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

#4

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

Bob Lang

Way back in the 1970s I used to make speaker cabinets and cases for band equipment out of plywood + fiberglass. What you propose will be stronger than plywood alone and lighter than thicker plywood. I don't know exactly how much stronger, but it seems appropriate for what you want to do.

You'll be a lot happier if you use fiberglass matte instead of cloth. Matte is non-woven fibers bonded together in a sheet, and that sticks much better to the wood. Cloth makes a better finished surface, but tends to bubble when you try to roll it down, in my opinion you should always use matte first, and the matte alone leaves a decent textured finish, good enough for travel cases unless you want them fancy.

Epoxy as the resin is probably overkill, polyester resins will be good enough in this application and cost a lot less. Attaching the aluminum extrusions to the plywood may be an issue. You'll have a hard time getting screws to hold in the thin plywood. Options would be to use machine screws with a washer and a nut, or pop-rivets with large washers. Either one of those will stick out so you'll need to provide some extra room for that inside the case.

If it were me, I'd make a small prototype to test your construction methods and techniques. You'll be dealing with some stinky, itchy stuff that isn't cheap or pleasant to work with.

Bob Lang

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

#5

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

tom

Each case will max out at about 50lbs.. This case and contents. As for "crushing" I have seen some who use some "props" inside the case to provide additional support.

I will check out the polyester resin route.

Thanks!

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

#6

Foam core

Tom Dunlap

If 'glass is strong enough consider using foam for the core instead of plywood. You can add ribs of foam to give strength.

Strip canoes don't rely on the stripping for strength, just shape.

I wonder how strong FRP is to crushing and puncture??? I'm using it to panel my camper for other reasons. When I'm at my shop I'm going to go after some scrap with my mondo ball peen hammer!

Tom

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

#7

more info

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

In the more info department how about listing the cost of the available cases. I used to make a lot of high performance epoxy laminate molds and would use $25/ square foot as a base line for materials when bidding a job. This was surprisingly acurate and included mixing buckets, brushes, and al the little things along with the epoxy resin and cloth. My molds were much heavier than your cases and used much more exotic materials then you will need but what I am getting at is that it may be cheaper to buy the cases than to make them.

Robin

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

#8

foam and polyester resin don't play well

Dick Coers

Most foams will dissolve with contact with polyester resin. My friend still uses it for casting patterns for custom motorcycle parts, but covers it with green dish washing liquid as a barrier and then a layer of aluminum foil with foil tape on the seams.

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

#9

Re: Foam core---trailer building *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

There is lots of info here about building with foam. Mostly successes and a few failures too. Boats have been foam core built for a long time.


Foamies

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

#10

Re: foam and polyester resin don't play well

Bob Lang

It depends on the foam. One of the other wacky jobs I had in the '70s was building scenery for an amusement park. We had a gun that shot a two part polyurethane (I think) that we would spray over chicken wire/wood forms, then cover with fiberglass to make rocks and waterfalls. But you can't put polyester resin or acetone in a styrofoam coffee cup. Well, you can, but not for long.

Bob Lang

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

#11

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

Gary Evans

If these cases are going to be used for shipping the bikes, I would make sure they have a base that would force the loaders to stand them upright. Much less likely for anything to be stacked on top and thereby conduct an unwanted test on the crush strength of the sides of the case.

Gary

Re: Plywood Cases + Fiberglass?

#12

Re: Foam core

TomD

"If 'glass is strong enough consider using foam for the core instead of plywood. You can add ribs of foam to give strength."

Others have said not to do this, but it will work well with boat grade foam, though that is not always cheap either.

"Strip canoes don't rely on the stripping for strength, just shape."

That is a misconception, the strips are critical to strength, the amount of glass they are covered with is not strong enough to replace the interior strength provided by the wood, and the weave of the glass is relatively open compared to what is really needed. That said, the strength is mostly longitudinal, and that means the wooden strips would be more appropriate in a spar configuration like a mast or a beam.

One thing one can check for oneself is the success of all glass and foam canoes, they are often horrible since the weight budget does not allow enough materials even to keep the skins fair.

There are also quite a few things that can be done to improve both wood contribution, and glass contribution, but most people are not willing to do them on strippers since that is mostly a look project for makers, not an engineering one. It is also easier to improve heavier loaded structures since the weight budget provides a lot more alternatives.

"I wonder how strong FRP is to crushing and puncture??? I'm using it to panel my camper for other reasons."

Not as good as some other alternatives, but good at the price. I have seen studies done dropping ball bearing on sheathed panels, and glass polyester is the low end. Good epoxy like west is better (cheaper epoxies can be sub polyester). Kevlar is better still. The resin is quite instrumental in absorbing impact of other compression loads.

On another subject, mat polyester is garbage. It drapes well, and makes nice structures for speaker enclosures that get carted around in cars, but it is a horrible structural material.