Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

Posts

White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

#1

Bart Goldberg

White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

Bart Goldberg

I need to build some garden trellis/ frames for my veggie garden. I don't like using any treated wood, so I'm considering using some hardwood from my local sawyers. I can get White Oak or Black Locust. Any opinions as to which will stand up better for outdoor use. Note they will not be making ground contact.

Thanks

Bart

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

#2

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

Jesse Cloud

I read on another forum that the way old timers knew when it was time to replace black locust fence posts was "put a rock on top of the post and when the rock starts to rot, check the post".

The same article noted that black locust is very hard, heavy and takes a toll on blades.

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

#3

Either should be fine for this.

Keith Newton

Black Locust is the better, but I have a WOak fence here at my shop that I built in 1983, still going strong.

Of course, the sapwood of all trees will decay quickly, so avoid using it regardless of species.U

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

#4

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I like working with locust, in this area it is quite a bit cheaper than Oak - The only issue I have had is that my supplier does not separate the "Honey Locust" from the Black. I have read that they are both great for outside use but the old timers (including me) favor the Black. I have used it to make a vanity for my son's remodeled bathroom. IMHO, it turned out very pretty - and I am sure it will outlast the house! Either should work well but in my opinion the Black Locust will outlast White Oak. When I was young my Uncles farm was fenced with Oak (cut from the farm woods) while a few miles away neighbors had Locust - As I remember the Locust lasted a few more years. The farmers in my home area used to say a Locust post would outlast at least 2 postholes.

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

#6

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

Larry in nw ohio

Larry Since Black Locust is plentiful around your area, are there any sawyers that sell it on line. Or where I could get some. Thank You Larry

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

#7

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

http://hollingsworthlumber.com/

The link above is the yard where I purchased before, they don't always have it on hand as it is cut locally. They do show it on their hardwood lumber selection. As I stated above - they didn't segregate the Black from the Honey when I purchased it in the past. I don't know what their shipping arrangements are as I always drive there to pick up mine. If they don't have it in stock you might search for other sellers around Indianapolis - I think the current price at Hollingsworth is under $2 a bf.

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

#8

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

John Veerkamp

Honey Lucust does not last near as well as black for outdoor use. If you cannot separate out the honey, go for the white oak.

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Black Locust.....

Jesper, Denmark

will last forever. Probably cheaper too.

I have used black locust as "replacement teak" on my boat for ages - weathers to a nice grey like untreated teak, but stronger and wears better.

Just remember to pre-drill all screw holes - and lubricate screws with linseed oil if you waqnt to be able to remove them at any time later.

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

#10

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

Terry Quiram

You have another choice. You could also use Osage Orange. It will last as long as BL. I remember pulling hedge fence posts when I was a kid. Dad was going to use them in the fireplace but they were so hard he couldn't cut them. We eventually hosted a hotdog roast. That fire burnt for a week.

Re: White Oak or Black Locust for Outdoor Frames?

#11

matches my farm experience

Bill Tindall

I make gates from heart wood oak and they last many years. I have had locust posts last but a few years and others decades. In my experience whole tree posts from younger trees don't last as long as posts split from older trees.