Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

1st table saw

Posts

1st table saw

#1

1st table saw

david b

I'm a new home owner, who likes to build projects but don't have a huge woodworking background. I'm looking to buy my first table saw. I'm wanting something that can handle a dado blade but don't want to spend huge $$. Any suggestions?

Re: 1st table saw

#2

JL

Re: 1st table saw

JL

Buy used - or at least think about it. You will want a "contractor's saw" as opposed to a job site saw.

My preferences are for cast iron top and wings (as opposed to stamped steel). They can be "webbed" - but cast iron is preferable. You will want at least 1 1/2 hp (IMO).

If you buy new, consider the Ridgid R4512 at Home Depot. Lowes has the Porter Cable PCB270TS. I don't know enough about what Sears has to offer.

Those are the two "low price" new table saws.

As for used - you'll have to hunt around on Craigs list or other places.

Re: 1st table saw

#3

Re: 1st table saw

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Dave,

I'd suggest you look around for a used contractor's table saw. It will do what you want, and not too expensively. Be aware of the value and convenience of accessories like jigs and mobile platforms which may be offered with the saw. A good used Delta, Jet, Powermatic, Grizzly, etc on Craig's list is a good place to start.

George

Re: 1st table saw

#4

Re: 1st table saw

Hal

Good advice from both. Also look at the fence. IMO a Biesemeyer can't be beat, but other "T-square" type fences can be good as well. Good luck. Hal

Re: 1st table saw

#5

Re: 1st table saw

AZ in Colorado Springs

Look at the woodworking magazines for tool reviews. You've narrowed your search (appropriately) by identifying that you want to use a dado set, but there are many other features to consider. By looking at some TS tool reviews, you'll get an idea of what to look for and to avoid (placement of controls, size of the top, etc.). You'll likely have a good list of features on this thread too, before too long. That's the information you need to tell the saws apart. Also, don't just think of what each saw features, but consider whether or not you're likely to use it (and want to pay extra for it).

Anyway, that's some philosophy. I have a Craftsman 10" contractor saw. I love it. Also, consider getting a used saw (I paid $50 for mine -- I was real lucky.)

Good luck.

Re: 1st table saw

#6

Re: 1st table saw *LINK*

Dave Paine

You do not state the kinds of projects you want to do.

If you feel you will be doing a lot of cross-cutting then consider a sliding compound mitre saw.

If you will be doing a lot of ripping then a table saw is the way to go. I would get the biggest table size you can afford. Same for the motor.

My first table saw was a Sears "hybrid" a contractor type saw, but with the trunnions mounted to the cabinet and not the top. At the time (2005) it was made by Orion for Sears. Orion later became Steel City Tool Works. The link is the latest Sears offering. The granite top feels like this may now be Steel City model. Almost the same as my old machine, except mine was cast iron tope and had the Biesemeyer Professional fence. This was perhaps the best feature. This saw has 1 3/4 HP motor.

The motor was adequate, except for thick stock (> 6/4 stock) e.g., hard maple or cherry was too much, even though I used a thin kerf blade.

I built a much larger outfeed table around the flip-up table. For my projects working alone, it was a big help so that long pieces were supported after the cut.

I agree with the other recommendations to try and find a used machine. Better bang for the buck.

The fence can make a major difference in the performance of the machine. The contractor saws may not have as good a fence as the cabinet saws.

Some people like the Rigid contractor saw. I have not used one.

You do not state if this can be in a fixed position or needs to be movable. Even large cabinet saws can be put into mobile bases, you just want to do this during the initial installation.

My first saw was installed in a mobile base. The replacement is not. I do not often need to move the saw, only when ripping long boards, and the choice is move the tractor and bucket or move the saw. I now go with the former.

Other than the big box stores, it may be difficult to "kick-the-tyres" on a machine. If you are driving distance to a Grizzly Imports showroom, I highly recommend a visit.

Grizzly has perhaps the best price on the cabinet saws, and several models. Many people have Grizzly machines. I almost went with Grizzly for my replacement. I ended up with the new Delta Unisaw.

I have other Grizzly machines.

You mention needing to use a dado. I have a dado blade, but find that my preference is to use my router table. I can fine-tune the fence and depth adjustment better than on the table saw.

Also consider zero clearance inserts. This can save a lot of splintering of cuts, especially with plywood.

I would plan on dust collection. Cabinet saws have better design for dust collection than the contractor saws due to the latter having the big hole at the back to allow the motor to swing back as the blade is lowered.


http://www.sears.com/shc/s/p_10153_12605_00922116000P?prdNo=6&blockNo=6&blockType=G6

Re: 1st table saw

#7

"It's about the fence"

ronster

I have a friend who fortunately bought a TS 1 year before me. He advised me "It's all about the fence" after blowing that part of his research before his purchase. That advice turned out to be very important for me when I was looking for a contractors saw (last century). You want great repeatability and rigidness on the fence. Ease of use is nice as is the ability to take on add-ons such as sacrificial wood faces. My Delta 34-445 has served very well.

Re: 1st table saw

#8

Where are you located?


Re: 1st table saw

#9

Last table saw

Neal in San Jose

You might consider a little higher-end saw with all of the features you might need for all future projects before you decide. Personally, I've upgraded twice when I "outgrew" my saws. Both times it cost $$, I had to remake the jigs and fixtures that wouldn't work on the new saw, and I had to deal with selling and moving the old one out and the new one in.

You've gotten some good advice. I think the fence and safety devices (dust collection, can I turn it off with my knee, convenient blade guard, riving knife) are the two highest priorities.

Re: 1st table saw

#10

What do you consider "huge $$"?


Re: 1st table saw

#11

Re: 1st table saw

mdclor

David, I will dovetail on Dave P's suggestion of making dados on a router table. In addition to his accuracy comment, you will be able to make stopped dados with less chiseling than would be required if attempting to do so on the TS. I just saw a jig you can make that would be great for dadoing book shelves, etc. using a router without a router table.

There is also a school of thought that a band saw can take the place of a TS. Band saws are safer to use than a TS, especially if you are not familiar with using a TS. Also, the BS can perform tricks that a TS can't, e.g. cutting curves, resawing, etc. However, a BS is not good for cutting large pieces if you intend to make cabinets (break plywood sheets down to "close" with a circular saw and a straight edge, then cut to exact with the TS.)

Tell us more about your intentions and we will be able to offer more assistance.

HTH,

Merle

Re: 1st table saw

#12

been there and done that

Bill Tindall

Then I bought a Unisaw and it will do anything I ever need to do and will last for generations. I recommend people look for a used professional saw which around here sell for about what a lesser grade of new saw sells for.

Re: 1st table saw

#13

Try . . .

steve mackay

I'm going to be shunned and cursed on Wood Central but here goes . . .

Go down to Sears and get the $140.00 Craftsman TS. If you're still a weekend Warrior it will serve you well enough for now. It'll pretty much do what you ask. You'll be able to learn what a TS will do (much more than you think it will, I promise !)and will not do. But most of all . . . you'll find out if you REALLY want one. With weekend duty it will last you three or four years plus. Belive me, I know ! I went through two in six years before deciding I could justify the big bucks. If you decide this wood thing ain't for you, you can still justify the 140 just cutting molding a couple times a year. And you won't feel bad. There is nothing worse than a $1,000 machine sitting idle that mocks you every time you walk past it. And once you decide the wood thing IS for you and you want to up-grade, you'll know the features and size that will fit your style.

Now the crowd may feel free to begin the stoneing ! :D

Re: 1st table saw

#14

Re: Try . . .

Nat Robison

I tend to agree. If you look at it like your kid came to you and told you they want to play hockey but they've never skated before, you're not likely to drop $1500 on new equipment. You'd get them a cheap pair of used skates to see if they even like skating.

I believe most motivated woodworkers can produce nice work on lower-quality equipment if they choose to.

Re: 1st table saw

#15

JL

First cast stone....

JL

Yes, it's $130 on sale. But...

A good used saw will run $100-200. A contractor's saw with a decent fence and a decent blade is so much better and safer.

I know where you are coming from. It is more palatable to shell out $130-$160 for a portable table saw and see if you "get the woodworking bug". A reasonably decent contractor's saw will run ~$200. I just searched on Craigslist and found one hybrid for $400, one old Craftsman for $150 and a Rockwell for $200 and that was on the first page for my area.

Re: 1st table saw

#16

Re: cheap & the frustration factor

Carol

When the tool is too cheap, the frustration of trying to use it may well discourage you budding interest.

Buy a decent used tool to avoid that and then if you really want to move on, you have the opportunity to resell your investment.

With table saws, it is mostly about the fence. A decent fence can make all the difference. I had a bench top saw I built into a cabinet to be able to use a Beismeyer fence. Used that set up for years successfully before I got a cabinet saw. The fence was more money than the saw! But the original fence was a total piece of crap that nearly drove me insane before I bit the bullet for the fence.

Re: 1st table saw

#17

been there done that

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I did the same thing for my first saw. I built a larger table out of weded angle iron and droped in the little POS table saw I had, I then welded up a copy of a biesmeyer fence. and ended up with a very usable tool. That set up made me a lot of money. I'd still have it but the trunions finaly gave up and it wouldn't even hold to 90*. Not bad for a lower then bottom of the line mid 80's delta.

Back then I had more time than money and I had been making my living on a table saw for long enough to know what what features I needed but couldn't afford. If I had it to do over I would have at least looked for a better quallity little saw to start with. some of those vintage saws are worthy of spending the money that a new fence costs.

Robin