Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Dust collection cold to hot

Posts

Dust collection cold to hot

#1

Dust collection cold to hot

Dustmaker Mike

Howdy all I have the walls all up in the shop and painted electrical all done windows trimmed out as well as the door. I started laying the floor yesterday but ran out of steam. The ready for use inspection should be done this week and away I go. So here is my question.

My dust collector will be in my garage insulated (not heated) to run it into my shop I figured I would run it under the floor into the crawl space which is insulated (not heated) then up into the shop (heated) will I run into any problems with condensation on the pipping? Schedule 40 SD pipe is what I will be using.

I also plan on running my air lines the same way but I will have a 4 foot drop to the quick connect with a drain value under it to get the water out of the line.

I am doing this before I move my equipment in.

Thanks

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

#2

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

DC should be OK.

You're likely to have a problem with the air if I understand you that your line will start out at the compressor, then go down under the floor, then back up to your air station with a drop and valve. I'm also concerned that you didn't mention a material for your air line.

PVC for air lines is absolutely prohibited and dangerous as has been documented on this forum more times than I can count. The other problem with your air line under the floor is that condensation from the compressor will collect at the lowest place in the line. You'll have no way to drain that line. To avoid this, run your air high, then bring down the drop line to the drain and branch off that with a reverse loop to the regulator, like this


You can also help both the compressor and the lines if you put an auto drain on your compressor. McMaster-Carr has a good one for $50, their part No. 4919K13. I've had one in use for over 10 years.

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

#3

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

NickinMass

I can't see any problem with your DC ducting in terms of condensation (any condensation should be on the inside, and I would expect the airflow to take care of it. The one concern that jumps to mind is makeup air. Because you have your DC in a different room, you will be removing air from your shop - air from some adjacent (most likely unheated) space will move into to replace it. This is really problematic if you have any vented appliances (gas hot water heater, furnace, boiler, etc.) in your shop space. I suppose you could rig a return duct from the DC back to your shop if you haven't dealt with the makeup air issue otherwise.

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

#4

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Mike, My DC trunk lines are in the (insulated, not heated) attic of my shop, 4" & 6" PVC S&D, and I definitely have a condensation problem during the winter months. I keep the end of one of the main 'drops' (a flex line) in a bucket, and quite often find upwards of a pint of water in the bucket. BTW, there's about 40 feet of ducting up there.

For the air lines - I'd use black pipe (a hassle), copper (expensive!) or PEX. That said, I don't have any hard-piped air lines in my shop. Everything is done with a couple of hoses, straight off the compressor.

Sched 40 PVC has gotten a pretty bad rep for air lines. Supposedly, it gets brittle and will shatter. I say 'supposedly' because I've never see it happen, or heard of it happening from any local, reliable source. There seem to be a lot of stories about it, but none ever seem to be firsthand accounts.

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

#5

Kneale Brownson

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

Kneale Brownson

"Sched 40 PVC has gotten a pretty bad rep for air lines. Supposedly, it gets brittle and will shatter. I say 'supposedly' because I've never see it happen, or heard of it happening from any local, reliable source. There seem to be a lot of stories about it, but none ever seem to be firsthand accounts."

I know a guy with a big scar on his thigh from a Schedule 40 air line that burst. Had it hit him in the neck, he'd be dead. I didn't see it happen, but others did.

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

#6

PEX For Air?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hi Jim,

Do you have info on the use of PEX for high pressure air? The only thing I've seen is its use in low pressure [20-90 psi] water plumbing systems, and that water systems must have a relief valve with a max of 150 PSI installed. That would seem to say that it can't be used for air distribution, but I'd be interested in any information you may have.

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

#7

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: PEX For Air?

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

http://www.plumbingzone.com/f2/pex-compressed-air-line-6019/

or: CCsi.canon.com/ near the bottom of the page

I haven't used it myself, but probably will when/if I ever get around to reconfiguring my setup. Regarding the relief valve - there's generally one on the compressor, and most small (home) compressors are limited to ~125psi. Bigger compressors will likely have a higher pressure relief valve, though.

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

#8

Air

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Seems like lower pressure air [under 100psi] is OK so long as barbed fittings are used; that takes a more expensive joiner tool. Since 90 psi in my minimum [up to 150 on refill] I would have to question it for any extension of my type L copper system.

ps: Thanx for the links, although the CC doesn't work.

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

#9

For what it's worth...

John in NM

I've seen the PVC fail firsthand - but only where exposed to several months of Tucson sunlight. Inside the building or in shaded areas, the stuff had lasted for years :D

Could also try CPVC, it's supposed to fracture radially rather than longitudinally like white PVC. More expensive than the white stuff, but not like iron or copper.

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

#10

I'd sure try it...

John in NM

Because unlike PVC's, PEX is pretty flexy. As with any plastic, keep it out of the sun, and it should be fine. Most likely mode of failure is blow by at a crimp, or maybe pop off a fitting entirely.

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

#11

Thanks All

Dustmaker Mike

I was not sure what material I was going to run for airlines. I have enough rubber or plastic airline hose to the job so I figured I would just use it because it goes around things easier.

As for the DC I am thinking I was going to put a open vent into the garage to help keep it a little warmer in the winter time. This should be enough to make up the return air. It is insulated on two side and the top so I would have to just use blown in insulation to finish the last wall and do something to the door.

Re: Dust collection cold to hot

#12

Re: Thanks All

Larry in nw ohio

Michael Noone has brought it up, but when you run your air do not run small air lines and then go to a larger line. Start at the compressor with something like 3/4" or 1" and go off that with your line that will be used for the work tool. If you use a small line and then go big you will starve the tool you are going to use. I didn`t know if you new that or not but I wanted to be sure. The way I read your last post is that you have some odds and ends on hand you are going to use. I have also used PVC and have had no problems after 10 years of use. Of course I protected the lines with a 2X6 or so just in case it would blow. Good Luck and be careful. Larry