OT- Round-Up
Thomas Norton
I was wondering about how effective generic type Round-Up vegetation killer is? I bought some Ace Hardware brand and it does not seem to be as effective.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
OT- Round-Up
Thomas Norton
I was wondering about how effective generic type Round-Up vegetation killer is? I bought some Ace Hardware brand and it does not seem to be as effective.
Re: OT- Round-Up
John Veerkamp
Check the strength of the active ingredient on the label. Often the generics have a lower percentage of the active chemicals.
Re: OT- Round-Up
Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI
In cool or rainy weather, it may take a week for the effects to show, even with the real McCoy.
Re: OT- Round-Up
paul in AZ
I've used both Roundup and the generics. For whatever reason the generics may state the same concentration but don't work as well. It could be whatever additives are in Roundup that makes the difference. My experience is that generics are false economy.
Weeds in the desert are tough so I use the concentrate mixed up at about 50% stronger than recommended.
Its all the same chemical
Bill Tindall
used at the same concentration it does the same job. Chemistry is predictable which is why its is science and not art. That said, there can be differences in formulation which could show up in subtle ways. A bit of surfactant will improve effectiveness for some plants.
Be sure the concentration of what you are using is the same. 4 Tablespoons of 50% solution per gallon of water is about right....what ever that works out to as a %.
I buy the generic stuff at the Ag store. 2.5 gallons of about 50% is only $50, or less. Silly to buy the premix if you use much .
Re: Its all the same chemical
John McGaw
In many cases the 'inert' chemicals in the glyphosate concentrate have a strong influence on how effective the diluted spray is. In particular the surfactant/wetting agent can make the difference between healthy and dead. I try without fail to at least knock back an abundance of English Ivy growing in the woods front of my house -- probably 1/8 of an acre (and spreading). Regular Roundup, even at the strongest 'set phasers to kill' strength has essentially no effect because the plant's waxy cuticle prevents it from getting in. The only help is to add a goodly dose of dish washing liquid to the sprayer which allows the active ingredient to get past the wax and be absorbed.
If I thought that they'd eat it I'd fence in the area and borrow some goats...
Re: Its all the same chemical
Doug Ridley
After using Roundup for several years I switched to a brand called Kleenup. I don't know the relative strengths but it costs quite a bit less, seems to be more effective, and lasts longer. FWIW
Doug
Re: Its all the same chemical
roger lance
John....now we need a botanist....plants have different cycles as well....and there are periods during the year when that waxy protective coating is at a minimum and that is the time to use the Round-up....just have to know when....generally in the fall is the time up here in the north....I think the wax helps protect the plant in the heat from excessive water loss....but I'm no botanist.
Re: Its all the same chemical
John McGaw
I have sprayed the ivy in the Spring, Summer, and Autumn and under various weather conditions and the result is pretty much the same. I've been told that if I was able to mow/weed-whack the ivy down to the roots and then spray the new shoots that the glyphosate herbicide would be most effective. The big problem there is the actual mowing/weed-whacking process. My next step is to find a really dangerous (to many plants anyway) herbicide called Clopyralid which is supposed to work a treat. At the price they charge it had better!
Re: OT- Round-Up
steve mackay
'Bout once a year I talk myself into one of those big jugs with the sprayer atatched. There has NEVER been an instance when I said to myself "well, THAT was money well spent !". EVER ! I've watched my father in law go through three or four of said jugs in a summer. I've NEVER noticed it doing ANYTHING. AND I've never heard HIM say "Well, that was money well spent". EVER !
all the ivys are resistant to herbicides
Bill Tindall
It must have more to do with their biochemistry than simply a rain coat as the one I am trying to manage in my pasture has not wax.
I think there are a few all but unkillable plants
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
in the world, including ivy, blackberries, and acacia.
Re: Its all the same chemical
Dale Stansbery
I'm with Bill on this issue. I use generics on the farm and if I follow mixing and application directions, it works the same as Roundup. You need to read the list of plants that it is or isn't effective on, and the time of year to spray. It's works best on young actively growing plants. You may have to apply twice on tougher vegatation. As for English Ivy, the most effective control at ground level is deer, they love the stuff. But once it gets up a tree where they can't reach the leaves, it keeps on going up. I have a huge Hackberry that's covered with the stuff all the way to the top which is probably 60 or 70 feet. But the deer keep all of the leaves cropped off for the first 5 feet off the ground.
Re: Its all the same chemical
RobCarr
Used motor oil mixed with gasoline mixed to about a 1(oil):3(gas) ratio will kill just about anything and keep it from coming back for the growing season. It's cheap, very effective and readily available. I've been told that straight diesel fuel will work too.
Re: Its all the same chemical
John McGaw
May I borrow your deer herd for a while? I promise to send them back well fed...
NO MOTOR OIL!!!
Tom Dunlap
Someone lives downstream or downhill from you and will drink the oil runoff.
The beauty of glyphosates are that they become chemically inert after their work is done. Oil does not!!
Tom
Re: Use White Vinegar instead
Dennis E Peacock
Use it full strength on a warm sunny day. Works as good as Roundup, for far less money, and it is also eco-friendly.
The peril..... gasoline propeties
Bill Tindall
I won't enter the environmental discussion on the "off- label" herbicides, but there is a safety issue here. It is not well appreciated but gasoline has components whose boiling point is less than typical outdoor temperatures (butane and pentane) for example. These components are there to provide enough vaporized fuel to start the car when it is cold.
If gasoline is exposed to the air these components flash off and instantly become an ignitable mixture that can ignite with explosive force. Spread gasoline on the ground and a spark will turn the vapor into a fire ball tens of feet in diameter. These vapors being heavier than air can travel along the ground for some distance to find this spark.
There is a fund raiser going on for a local kid who was carrying an open jug of gasoline outdoors when a spark found the vapors trailing behind.
not cheaper
Bill Tindall
It costs me less than $0.60. gallon for generic Roundup buying the concentrate at the ag store and mixing to recommended strength.
The soil pH is going to take a serious hit from your treatment., but not a problem if it is the driveway.
Re: not cheaper
Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI
I've never heard of ph effects from Roundup. Can you elaborate?
Re: OT- Round-Up
PaulSV
This may not be your problem, but I have found that if you store roundup over ther winter and it freezes, it loses its effectiveness.
Try Crossbow. It should handle the ivy.
Tim Greif - West of Chicago
We use it to control any trees (or other woody plants) on the farm waterways. Sometimes, needs multiple applications, but gets the job done. Crossbow is reportedly very effective on any Ivy. Should be able to get it at any farm store.
Re: Try Crossbow. It should handle the ivy.
Barry Irby
My son, the horticulturist in the family, said Crossbow would be good or brush killer with dicamba. Spray it when lust and green with a surfactant in it (dish detergent)Once you get die back, cut it away, forcing it to flush again and spray again on the new growth.
I think he's talking about vinegar, not Roundup