Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

glue out at the corners

Posts

Re: glue out at the corners

#26

Re: Mitered plywood

eliot d

Well, I started gluing up these mitered plywood boxes; and all edges --except one -- are just about perfect. Unfortunately, the one edge, on these audio speaker cabinets, has a very small gap all along one vertical FRONT edge. What a bummer! I just can't have it this way. So here I am about to go with your router/ inlay approach. But even before I try it, I thought I would try simply to put a very slight round over along that edge. I mean, the miter is very tight; the edges just don't quite come together along the very front edge along the length for this one joint. (It's a complete mystery to me why all the other edges are really great.) So I'm thinking that this slight round over will cut through the open part and make a perfect tight line and look just fine. The only problem, as I see it, is that there may be a very slight showing through of a little bit of the plywood grain. Now , if I do have to go with your inlay technique, my question is : should I use the same furniture grade birch plywood in the sense of a repair, or should I go for a contrasting wood in the sense of a new design element?

Re: glue out at the corners

#27

Ellis Walentine

Purfling

Ellis Walentine

I was suggesting using solid strips of whatever your face veneers are, or a contrasting wood for that matter. If you use 1/8" x 1/8" strips, you can put a 1/8" roundover or chamfer on them. Use larger cross-section strips if you want a heavier edge treatment.

Ellis

Re: glue out at the corners

#28

Re: Purfling

eliot d

I understand the purfling idea completely. My question was whether or not it would be sufficient to merely round over the bad edge, as it is, to hide the slight ( 1 mm) gap. I'm a bit loath to start in with a router and purfling strips unless this is the only way to hide the imperfection. I may even start with some glue/sawdust fix because a 1 mm gap is fairly small.

Re: glue out at the corners

#29

Kneale Brownson

Re: Purfling

Kneale Brownson

I've used sawdust off the veneer on scraps and glue to fill gaps like that as a roundover when using mitering on that type of plywood. If you assemble the next box starting at the front, that gap probably will appear in the back.

Re: glue out at the corners

#30

Re: Purfling

eliot d

You know, if I live to be a 100 , I won't figure out what happened. It's not a question of accumulated errors. I did one edge at a time -- not the whole box-- the and all the other edges are perfect, just perfect. I've gotten a little nuts over this thing. Now I plan to make up a test piece and try sawdust mixed with (1) yellow glue,(2) white glue,(3) CA glue to see which one looks best. And , as I have said, if that doesn't work, I 'll see what a very slight round over does. And if that doesn't work, following Ellis, I go with purfling. I've done it for guitars. I'm still thinking about whether to use the same wood as in a repair or a contrasting wood for a design change. I should post a pic but I'm sort of hopeless at that.

Re: glue out at the corners

#31

Ellis Walentine

Rounding over sharp veneered corners

Ellis Walentine

Most face veneers are very thin these days, say 1/40". That means that even a 1/16" round-over is going to be starting to cut into your substrate layer, so whether or not the joint is perfect, you'll have to do some touch up work on the exposed substrate. But, the best reason NOT to design things with veneer corners is that these edges are fragile and vulnerable. I'm not saying that speaker manufacturers don't build things this way, only that I don't. If you're not worried about damaging these delicate edges and you want to avoid the extra work, that's a valid decision, too.

The other upside to inlaid edges is that you don't have to be so fussy about all those miters, because the edging will cover any gaps or misalignments nicely.

You make guitars?

Ellis

Re: glue out at the corners

#32

Re: Rounding over sharp veneered corners

eliot d

I agree with everything you said. These speakers are for a relative, a nice guy who knows somethings about audio but not much about woodworking, and he wanted mitered, birch plywood cabinets. So I took it on. Big mistake! Far easier to have used MDF with veneer -- and I believe the audio qualities of MDF are superior anyway. I'll NEVER again use miters and plywood together. (Although I do have to admit that when the edges come together it's a nice look; and, once together, not so delicate.)

Yes, I made two guitars: the first was a plectrum guitar entirely of the Martin design. I did it in a week-long class at Peters Valley in New Jersey years ago, run by two very experienced Martin guitar makers. In a sense, THEY made the thing, although they never touched it. But I did every step according to what I was told. (Just like the Krenov plane I made with David Fink.) My second one I did entirely on my own , but it was not a plectrum; it was a classical guitar. Would you believe that I THOUGHT the first one was a classical guitar because it was an acoustical instrument ( i.e. not electric) .That's how out of it I was. I couldn't even tune it. I started taking lessons with it and the first thing the teacher asked me was , "Who do you want to be?" I didn't know what he was talking about but finally got it and said, "O.K. Segovia". The teacher then told me I had the wrong kind of guitar. So I asked him what do I do now,and he said I guess you'll have to make another one. So I did. They both really are extremely fine instruments. I showed the classical one to some hotshot , who exclaimed how excellent it was and then gave me the bad news, which was that it would take me another 20 years to do it again as well! Something about the first one being better than expected and then really hard to get back there.

Re: glue out at the corners

#33

Re: Purfling

eliot d

You were right; I was wrong. After I get to the last part -- the bottom as it turned out, there was a significant gap. I was horrified! I had worked really carefully to get all the parts exactly square. Still, there was a bad gap at the end. I'm depressed! I'll have to use Ellis's method of routing a rabbet and inserting an inset. At this point I'm sorry that I didn't use MDF and veneer. AND I still have another one to do(stereo)! Bummer! (What's really ridiculous is that I let woodworking get me down like this. Is there such a thing as TLC around here?