Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Steel City benchtop jointer

Posts

Steel City benchtop jointer

#1

Steel City benchtop jointer

Craig Daymon

Another interesting Steel City tool that appears on the Home Depot and Lowes sites is the 6" benchtop jointer with helical cutters. A little confusing when reading the sites, but I am very certain they are HSS cutters, not carbide. I don't know if carbide cutters are available. It is only $300, if bought directly from Steel City. Tempting.

Anyone have one?

-Craig

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#2

Re: Once again ....

Charlie Lenz

for about the same amount of money a better investment would be a used stationary 6" Delta or JET. Or better yet, don't buy a jointer. I've been woodworking for about 30 years and have done just fine without one.

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#3

Bart Goldberg

Re: Once again ....

Bart Goldberg

I partially agree. I would also look for a decent used Jointer. I personally use my jointer a lot and buy rough sawn lumber and mill my own stock. I would not be without a jointer.

Bart

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#4

$300 jointer - helical head

Craig Daymon

A replacement helical head is more than that.

Looking for comments from those that have the mentioned tool.

Yeah, if I had 3 phase and the truck to haul it, I could get a great deal on a 16" wide jointer, but I DON'T have the power, the truck or the space. Also, I really want a helical head IF I get a jointer.

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#5

For my money,  *LINK*

Keith Newton

I would much rather have s big hand held Power plane. You can add a couple of wooden jaws into your bench vice, which cradles it nicely, turning it into a bench jointer. But I find it to be a lot handier, when the boards are really timbers. I also have a nice 12" in my shop, but I often get really large boards which are too large for even that, and or the 24" planer.

I can flatten a long wider board quickly with this than anything else in my shop. Winding sticks on the ends, to take care of twist, then once I shoot one straight 6" pass down one side, I let the out feed bed ride on it, while the plane is held askew, as I work my way down and across large areas. You can't do that with a bench top.

As for helix, you will be faced with a problem of finding someone to sharpen, and for how much, and how long to get it back?

These tools come with an excellent honing guide, and indexing tool for setting the blades perfectly every time. It cuts so nice, you will forget you ever desired a helical head.

I have four sets of knives for mine, so I wait until all are dull to sharpen, unless I just want to touch them up quickly. I grind on my little Rockwell 9" contractor saw, with cross fence, and 1/4" wheel, with Koolmist sprayer. then hone on a huge Japanese stone about 6' x 6 x 12".

I bought mine back around 1980, have never done any repair, for ~ $400 back then, and woodworking has been my profession for over 40 years. I would rather have this than any stationary 6" on the market. And if you are in a small shop, as many posters here are. This tool can live under a bench, rather than taking up floor space.


http://www.homedepot.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/ProductDisplay?productId=203162062&storeId=10051&langId=-1&catalogId=10053&ci_sku=203162062&ci_kw=%7bkeyword%7d&kwd=%7bkeyword%7d&cm_mmc=shopping%2d%5f%2dgoogleads%2d%5f%2dpla%2d%5f%2d203162062&ci_gp

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#6

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

Jesse Cloud

Very interesting. I think the $300 model has been discontinued but I see a $349 model with carbide cutters and granite tables. Its good to see Steel City coming out with some new products. They seemed to be just barely holding on and I've always hoped they could make a go of it and give Delta/PC/B&W and Jet/Powermatic some competition.

On the other hand, I started out with a 30 inch benchtop jointer (Delta) and it was a piece of junk. Very hard to get a decent edge on anything longer than a couple of feet.

Agree with the advice to look for a used full sized jointer. I see them often on craigslist for not much more than what the Steel City is selling for.

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#7

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer *LINK*

Craig Daymon

Not if you check the specs on the Steel City site. I think the carbide cutters are a mistake on the Lowes/Home Depot site (I forget which one, or if both, said carbide). The Steel City site lists HSS cutters for both the granite topped and the cast iron topped benchtop jointers.

A little hard to find, but this link on the Steel City site has the granite top for $299, direct buy. There's an 8" granite floor model with helical head for $1149.99 on that page too. Carbide on the big one. The link to that page below.


Steel City 6" granite $299, also 8" big for $1150.

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#8

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer *LINK*

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Here is their summer 2012 sales flyer that has a little more detail on it.

Sure looks to me like the cutterheads are replaceable carbide inserts.

I notice the address is also in Illinois,last I heard they were on the West Coast?


Steel City

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#9

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

Craig Daymon

They are replaceable inserts, but they are not carbide. They are HSS. The word, "carbide", does not appear anywhere in the sales flyer.

Also, the description for the benchtop states that it is the granite topped model (should be 40610GH), but the product code is for the cast iron table model (40610CH). That's probably a mistake, but I'd confirm which before ordering.

On the product information page for both the cast iron and the granite topped benchtop jointers, it states that there are "Number of Knives: 12 Two Sided HSS Inserts". Maybe this has mistakes as well as I would expect inserts to be 4 sided. If they are HSS, it would be nice to know if carbide inserts are available. (I sent off a message to SCT about the cutters. I'll post what I get back.)

-Craig

P.S. Link to product page for granite topped benchtop is http://www.steelcitytoolworks.com/products_tools.cfm?section=2&category=7&tool=40610GH (I couldn't post it using the usual method as the form fields aren't appearing for some reason. Work account?).

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#10

Answers from Steel City about benchtop jointers

Craig Daymon

Steel City replied today.

The inserts are indeed HSS and 2-sided.

Both the granite topped and cast iron topped benchtop jointers are on sale for $299 currently.

Steel City is sampling carbide inserts for the jointers (benchtop) and hope to have them available within 6 months.

-Craig

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#11

Re: Answers from Steel City about benchtop jointer *LINK*

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Craig,

Thanks for the update.I am curious if any of the following items on the link below would"plug and play"

with those jointers??? Any reason one couldn't swap the cutters out?I cannot imagine the danger factor is real high.I bring this up to continue the discussion and to learn why we should not become backyard engineers.


Global carbide

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#12

Re: Answers from Steel City about benchtop jointer

Craig Daymon

If they are the right size, I can't imagine a problem. If I was designing a helical head, I would consider it an advantage to use cutters that were easily available. That said, the HSS cutters are 2 sided. My impression was that most of the cutters provided in helical heads are 4 sided and square, possibly implying that these cutters are rectangular and maybe harder to come by.

Either way, the key is probably to match a carbide cutter to the shape and size of the HSS cutters that come with the jointer. Then there should be no reason for them not to work.

-Craig

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#13

Don't Count On It

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Craig,

Carbide cutters take special screws with heads shaped to match the counterbore shape in the cutter, Use the wrong screws and you're most likely to crack the carbide. If you buy a machine with HSS cutters, it's unlikely that you could use the same screws and then you'll also have to match the "carbide" screw threads to those on the carrier head. Too many variables on which to base a buying decision.

BTW, I looked at SC's pix of the cutter head. They use about a quarter of the number of cutters that others do. I would very much suggest you find someone with this machine and make a test cut before your buy.

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#14

Re: Agree with Mark

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have 2 carbide inserted heads, one is a Grizzly on my 8" joiner and the other is a Shellex head on my 20" planer. The inserts - nor screws are not interchangeable. I cracked one insert on my planer due to a very small piece of debris I missed when I rotated the inserts. As Mark has observed, the Steel City machines also seem to have far less inserts than either of my machines. I would look at Grizzly before purchase or at least try out the Steel City machines.

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#15

Re: Don't Count On It

Craig Daymon

Thanks Mark, I didn't know that about the carbide cutters. I presume that means that when they get a supplier for the carbide cutters there will be new screws going out as well.

I was hoping this post would get a response from someone that purchased one to get a review. Yeah, 12 cutters total didn't sound like a lot, but, on sale, it's about the same price as the Delta benchtop with regular blades.

Larry, the problem with a Grizzly is that the cheapest Grizzly with a helical/spiral cutter head is $750 plus shipping. And it would require floor space.

Hopefully someone that has purchased it, or at least seen it first hand and maybe tried it, will post.

-Craig

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#16

Re: Don't Count On It

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Craig, don't know - you may already tried this but the local (Indianapolis IN and nearby area) Craig's list seems to have quite a few joiners and planers listed. As joiners are pretty long lived and require very little maintenance, you might find a good used one reasonably priced - maybe with spiral head. Planers do suffer more issues but after a thorough inspection and tryout, I wouldn't be afraid of a used one.

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#17

Re: Don't

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

"Yeah, 12 cutters total didn't sound like a lot, but, on sale, it's about the same price as the Delta benchtop with regular blades"

Craig,

Don't shop with pennies when nickles are needed. Buying a power tool on price is almost always a waste of the money. Don't fall for the "helical head" routine, especially when you can see the reason for the cheap price. If 12 cutters provide comparable performance to 48 cutters, do you think the other manufacturers wouldn't have gone that route? Your response indicates you already see a very suspect design. Bench-top tools are at the low end of capacity and functionality anyway. Don't degrade your choice further. There is so much used woodworking iron in local classifieds, you'll do much better, both economically and functionally, picking up a used machine, plus you'll have an easier time unloading it when you decide to upgrade.

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#18

Re: Don't Count On It

Craig Daymon

I'm not in Indiana anymore, just haven't changed my profile here.

Floor space is a major issue where I am. No room for a floor model and the benchtop might prove useful for a number of things...if someone that has one would give some positive feedback. I'm not worried about reselling it.

I have one outlet where I am now and numerous extension cords. Limited space. I have a bandsaw coming and will be getting a contractor's saw. Those are the tools that will get floor space. I would like a full-size drill press, but will go with a benchtop because of space.

-Craig

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#19

Re: Here is your customer review

Charlie Lenz

http://www.amazon.com/Steel-City-40610GH-Granite-Jointer/product-reviews/B0055NKDQ8/ref=dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt?ie=UTF8&showViewpoints=1

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#20

Re: More customer reviews

Charlie Lenz

http://www.lowes.com/pd_89252-26463-40610CH_4294927152+5003716_40_?catalogId=10051&productId=3351700&Ne=40&identifier=Bench+Jointers&N=4294927152+5003716&langId=-1&Ns=p_product_prd_lis_ord_nbr|0||p_product_quantity_sold|1&storeId=10151&searchQueryType=1

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#21

If space is the consideration...

John in NM

I would go with some good hand planes and a bench heavy enough to use them. Bench doesn't have to be huge, just heavy and stiff. You get a lot more versatility from this set up than with a tiny jointer. You can also edge joint and surface with a router and some jigs, though I'd still go with a couple planes myself.

I've had heavy benchtop drill presses for years, and only now and then do I wish for more mast. They are about the one bench tool I don't consider to be a pretty serious compromise between space and utility.

Its always a tough call, small machines for limited work spaces, vs. waiting for a bigger space to use proper machinery. I've been in that situation before and it's still hard to say what's best.

As to helical heads, yes they are nice, awfully nice :D

But I still get along fine with straight blades, and you can too. If you want the helical head, wait for one that takes carbide tooling and lots of it - it will be worth it.

Now I know none of this is what you asked for - actual experience with the machine you're looking at - but maybe the lack of anyone here who owns that particular machine should be telling you something as well :D

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#22

Re: More customer reviews

Craig Daymon

Thanks Charlie.

The reviews look pretty good...except for the one that sounds a bit more like an issue with Amazon than the tool. I wouldn't expect a $300 benchtop jointer to have the feel of a 12" floor model, so the "cheap" feel is probably what I would expect. I don't know of any maker of a benchtop jointer that makes one with a "substantial" feel. They're all pretty light weight. The ones that liked it seemed very pleased. (One bad, 4 good.)

Just a quick side thought. I do have a 4" (I think it's 4") Hitachi power planer. (Someone suggested mounting one of these upside down in a bench vise as a jointing solution.) I wonder if anyone is making one of those with a helical head. Might have some value in certain applications.

-Craig

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#23

Re: I've got an idea...

Charlie Lenz

To me it sounds like your pretty hell bent on buying the Steel City Jointer, so buy it, then come back and give us the review. Ofcourse we would also have to have pictures.

Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#24

Kneale Brownson

How do you edge joint?


Re: Steel City benchtop jointer

#25

#7Stanley +a shooting board