Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

Posts

Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#1

Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

Craig Daymon

I'm looking to get a contractor's saw and deciding between the RIGID 4512 from Home Depot ($499) or the Steel City 35990SS ($615 - Stamped Steel wings) from Lowes. (HD sells Steel City as well, but for about $100 more.)

Anyone have either? Any pluses/minuses? I'm sort of leaning toward Steel City, though I don't know what their quality is on this level of tool.

Thanks,

Craig

P.S. PLEASE, No SawStop posts. Not interested in the arguments or willing to spend the cash. Plain and simple, I WILL NOT buy one.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#2

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35

Dave's Not Here

IMO it's 6 of one half dozen of another between these two saws. I do wonder though why you would prefer to spend all that extra money on the Steel City and still end up with stamped steel wings? In this case, I don't think you'll be giving up anything by spending less money.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#3

Re: Neither

Charlie Lenz

A much better investment would be a used American made Delta Contractor's table saw. If you get lucky you'll find one with a good fence, such as a Biesemeyer, or a Unifence. I've had a Delta 34-444 with a Unifence and a mobile base since I bought it new in 1995 and it will probably be the last saw that I'll ever need.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#4

JL

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35

JL

If you are going to buy a contractor's style saw - buy the heaviest you can with cast iron wings and the largest motor.

I prefer cast iron wings - either webbed or "solid". IMO, stamped steel are just too lightweight. YMMV.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#5

Bart Goldberg

Re: Neither

Bart Goldberg

Absolutely agree. Here is where buying a better quality used saw is a better investment then buying new. Saws can last a lifetime and a used saw is likely to be in very decent shape. Look on Craigs list or ebay for a decent used saw.

My 2 cents

Bart

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#6

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35

Craig Daymon

The stamped steel wings are fine. The saws with them are over $100 cheaper, if not $200 cheaper than the cast iron winged versions. I have 1" thick phenolic sheet that I can replace them with if it proves a problem. Heavy and flat. Besides, we're talking about the wings and not the table. Granite seems nice, but fragile without reinforcement and, again, $100 to $200 more.

Anybody have either of these saws?

-Craig

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#7

Re: In reading both of your posts ...

Charlie Lenz

First of all I think that your rude and unappreciative. I also think that your trying to put together a shop with a couple of new machines on the cheap, and that you don't have a clue as to what is good, nor do you want to listen to any advise that your given by people that have experience. If you want customer tool reviews, go find them and read them. Goodluck !

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#8

His Mind's Made Up

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Don't try to confuse him with your opinions.

Seriously gents, the man asked a simple question; Saw A or Saw B? If y'all can answer his question, fine. If not . . .

He didn't, after all, ask a general, open-ended question about what's the best contractor's saw.

Getting pissed off because the guy ignores someone's sage advise that he didn't ask for to begin with is out of line, IMHO. We could just as easily have said, "forget those whimpy contractor's saws and get yourself a full-blown, Real Man's cabinet saw like the Big Boys have," or some equally inappropriate response.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#9

Re: His Mind's Made Up

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Mark,

I could not agree more with your comment.

Craig,

I have not seen either of these saws in person,nor side by side comparisons but if Ridgid is still offering the lifetime warranty and the money saved can buy a spare blade or possibly a start on an upgrade fence I'd lean towards that way.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#10

Re: I was waiting for the Cabinet saw sales pitch

Charlie Lenz

Way to subtly throw it in there Mark.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#11

You Just Don't Get It, Charlie

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

My comment had absolutely nothing to do with cabinet saws.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#12

Chill out charlie.


Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#13

craigd

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35

craigd

I have rev 2 of the Ridged, (outboard motor), several years old now. I haven't had any problems with it, it took a while to assemble but has stayed in adjustment and is pretty easy to adjust. I dearly love the supplied casters. It's quiet (ish), the ridged belt drive (ie I don't think you can use a link belt) has been trouble free, it is *not* over powered, dust collection is ok but not great. For my use, I'd really like the inboard motor (takes less room when shoved up against the wall) and a riving knife. I'm happy with the fence. I like the cast iron wings, probably just personal preference but stamped wings just don't make as nice of an assembly table.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#14

Oh I get it


Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#15

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Let's try to get this back on track...

Firstly, I've owned four contractors saws over the years, with both stamped and cast wings. My preference is cast, but either one will work quite well. I really don't see the cast wings being worth the 100+ extra bucks.

As for the saws themselves: The Steel City is a nice saw, but I've been hearing some "availability and support" stories about them that would worry me a bit.

The Ridgid saw is essentially a continuation of the famous (or infamous, depending on your point of view) Sears contractors saw. It's been around for a long time, and although it has its faults, it's essentially a 'tried and true' design. Parts and service should be readily available, too.

Were it me looking for a new contractors saw, I'd likely go for the Ridgid, and install a set of PALS adjusters on it to make keeping the alignment easier.

OTOH, if I were looking in the used market, I'd try to find a used Delta, Jet, or Powermatic 64 (NOT a 63!). With luck, I might find one of those for about half the cost of the new Ridgid.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#16

JL

HD donated one of the Ridgid saws to a local

JL

organization. House raising volunteers in a neighboring county.

I checked it out.

1) The miter gauge is not the best. It will work - but then again, how often do you use a miter gauge?

2) Motor is okay. Not the best, not the worst. With a good blade (which this one definitely was not) - it should do fine.

3) Fence - okay fence. Not the best, but quite serviceable. Pretty stable - looks to be easy enough to adjust.

4) I wasn't too happy with the tilt wheel. I think it is a bit too high - knuckle scraper.

I REALLY liked the ease of movement. I remember what a PITA it was to move my old Sears contractor's saw. The mobile capacity of this one is a definite plus.

YMMV. I might buy this saw if I were in the market.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#17

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35

Craig Daymon

Mark,

Thanks for understanding.

New has the benefit of a riving knife, something I think worthy of having. Used is far less likely to have that and not with the models mentioned. Yes, cast iron wings beat stamped steel, but my phenolic will make for very good replacements if I feel it's necessary.

Jim and craigd (hey!) thanks for the feedback. Appreciate it. I like the lifetime warranty of the Rigid, but I've read there is a set screw issue. That might be something that's been fixed. Steel City was started by a bunch of Delta guys (from the story I remember) that wanted to create the quality tools they felt were no longer being made at Delta. I'm hoping that is the thinking for the contractor's saw. Really like to hear some feedback from someone that has one before I decide.

-Craig

P.S. I have great blades - rip, crosscut, plywood - (Leitz) and a good miter gauge (Woodhaven). I use to have a JET cabinet saw. (cast iron wings) Not no more and no space for one right now.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#18

What to look for....

Bill Tindall

I have not compared these saws but I think I tried one out at IWF show. I have stood before a table saw a great many hours and the following is what I consider important. Look to see how snug the miter fits in its slot. What ever I tried had a sloppy miter and I showed the demonstrator the unsatisfactory results of a sloppy miter in test cuts. See how smoothly the up/down and angle blade adjustment works. The fence should lock securely and be easily adjustable to be parallel to the blade. It is too much to hope for that any blade guard is useful so use 7 1/2" narrow kerf blades to be safer sawing(vastly greater safety improvement than a riving knife). The only thing likely to break on a saw is motor and bearings. Some saws have specialized motors that may not be readily replaceable years from now. I junked an otherwise good Sears saw for this reason. The on off switch should be handy and logically located.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#19

Sloppy Miter Tip

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

For those who have a bit of play in their miter slot (any saw) when using the gauge for cross-cutting, you can take the slop out by applying a strip of aluminum HVAC duct tape to the side of the gauge bar. Do one side, carefully smooth it with a piece of soft wood, then wax the aluminum surface. If this doesn't eliminate the problem, do the same thing to the opposite side of the bar. The aluminum is easy to replace if it wears too thin or tears from use.

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#20

Re: Sloppy Miter Tip

Guillaume Dery

Another way to address sloppy miter gauge fit

Use a hard point pin and hammer points every 1.5" or so within 1/8" of the edge. This basically deforms and spreads the metal. The steel is very soft so it is a very quick job. Test fit and hammer more if still sloppy or judiciously file back if too tight. I've done this on quite a few miter gauges because I am too cheap to spend a couple of hundred $ on an aftermarket. It is actually longer to describe than do and it works like a charm.

Guillaume

Re: Contractor's saw - RIGID 4512 or Steel City 35990

#21

Re: Sloppy Miter Tip

Larry in nw ohio

This is going to sound pretty far out, but I have done thid a few times, mostly when I was working yet and we had a dozen or so table saws and they all had lose mitre drivers. I took the bar and bent it the ever slightest side ways, of course the slightest is all it takes to make it tight in the slot. After I did that on the TS at work no one complained again on those. I also did it on my old Craftsman and it worked real well on that also. Larry