Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

OT Lawn Tractor

Posts

OT Lawn Tractor

#1

OT Lawn Tractor

Gary Smyth

Long. Wrong site I know, but looking for opinions.

Need advice. Straight up!

Cub Cadet 1450, 1978.

On March 14 I sent my tractor to a dealer to finish work begun last fall. I have a oil leak of approx 1 quart every four acres mowing or five hours operation. This is the list to be done.

Cub Cadet 1450 -- Serial Number 635621, born September 1978

PROBLEMS TO BE CORRECTED

1. Oil leak

2. Rough running, choke made adjusted and loud operation reduced

3. Engine reset and braced and dampened.

REPAIR/REPLACE/EXCHANGE

New front and rear seals

New motor mount plate installed with motor isolation mounts front and rear (items supplied)

Engine tuned -choke and throttle adjusted.

Oil pan replaced with cast iron one (supplied).

Brake tightened/adjusted

Welded if and where necessary (I thought that I saw a frame crack, but now I cannot locate it.)

Tubes for rear tires.

New coil and points, plug replaced, and spark plug wire (provided)

Flexible joints checked

Steering rods installed but only if necessary (rods supplied)

Idler ratchet installed (provided)

New fuse holder and fuse to permit headlights/evening operation.

Camber of wheels checked and corrected if necessary.

I have only one tractor and when it is in repair nothing gets done.

Because many of the parts/items were supplied earlier I was faced with an estimate of about $700 for the work.

After three weeks sitting, today the dealer drove the tractor into the shop. He called and informed me that I need to have the engine bored, new rings, and “likely” a new rod. I’m now looking “at least” $1600 to $1800. I have to add here I’m not made of money.

I’m 66 years old, realistically I’m looking at ten more years of cutting grass. I know this tractor. Had it a long time. I’ve done all I know how to do to keep it running and I have no intention of giving it up.

Still, my grass is calf high, the neighbors are anxious (me too), and in addition I see (admittedly) lesser quality tractors out there for about the $1600 the dealer wants for my iron horse. I’m asking for alternatives. Should I bring it home and live with the leaks, only do some on the list and do the remainder over time (1. I have no truck and 2. it will be a total learning experience with only internet sites to assist), buy a new or used replacement? I’m really having a hard time with this. Help? Suggestions? Opinions?

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

#2

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

Barry Irby

I can sympathise. I tend to buy things I want and then keep them long past the point of diminishing return. I drive my cars to death, revive them and then drive them to death again and again. Strangely, I am loyal to my tools. I doubt they reciprocate, but I find it difficult to let them go and move on.

In your case, you can buy a lot of oil for that kind of money. Perhaps you could try some of the high mileage type oil and slow the leaks that way. I don't know enough about this particular tractor to know if it is significantly better than he stuff that's out there today or not. You could keep feeding it oil and watch Craig's List for a better used machine.

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

#3

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I recently traded in my eight year old John Deere L110 (42" mower) that had just over 300 hours on the meter. It was having engine problems - no 'sudden stoppages' but still it was popping the shear key on the flywheel and going out of time so it wouldn't run until I disassembled the top. removed the flywheel, and replaced the half moon key.

It also developed an oil leak down a valve stem and into the cylinder. I kinda figured that this caused a hydraulic lock in the cylinder, and maybe that caused the flywheel key to shear. Anyway, repair estimates were in the thousand dollar range, on a tractor worth about $500.00. (The L110 was one of the low end JDs - equivalent to the D110 model today - that $1600.00 model you mentioned... and is mainly marketed at Lowes and Home Depot.)

Anyway, I ended up trading the L110 in for a new X360. Cost me a small bundle, but the difference in low end and upper eschelon is huge, and I'm quite happy with the deal.

BTW, my tractor dealer for the new one was Hartville Hardware - yeah, the woodworking tool dealer - and I couldn't be happier with the service I got from them. They're sorta local (40 miles away) to me.

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

#4

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

Dick Coers

The cheap tractors seem like they are throw-aways. I did some maintenance all along, but when something major goes, it looks like the whole machine is shot. I can't remember exactly when I bought an MTD special (many names, sold many places), but I think it was 12 years ago. It did pretty well, but barely worth scrap now and that equates to about $75 per year. How long do the expensive ones last? Maybe about the same money one way or the other for me. Now a big yard would probably be a different story. At your age, you might just need one that will last another 20 years!

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

#5

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

Ron Jones

Is it a leak or is it burning oil? I'm guessing it is burning oil from what repairs were suggested. It will continue to get worse and lose power if the rings are not sealing properly. Check with your local auto parts store or discount store to see if they have an additive that might improve the seal between the cylinder walls and the rings. I have seen the product(s); I just don't remember the brand names. I would try that for $10 or less before giving the go ahead for the repairs.

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

#6

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

The old cub cadets are a good macine capable of pulling attachments such as a powered rototiller, a scraper blade or other soil engaging tools. The low end new models are not designed nor are they capable of pulling soil engaging tools. for many of the same reasons the lower end models are also not good for mowing on anything but slight inclines. They will mow on hills but the rear ends will not hold up to that kind of use like the much more expensive models.

If the rear end on your cub cadet is still good you might want to look at pricing a replacement motor and it dosn't necessarily need to be a factory replacement.

I ended up doing all the research on this a couple of years ago and then ended up finding a great deal from a Sears service guy that rebilds stuff on the side.

Robin

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

#7

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

RobCarr

Let me give you another take on it - after 34 years it's time to put her to rest... just last year I traded in my '80 Cab Cadet, I don't know what model it was, but it was probably very similar to your it was 2-cylinders, shaft-drive, 5-port hydraulics and power steering. it had a lot of hours on it and gets used all year long; I had a snow blade for it and a rear mounted plow for the vegetable garden. The only reason I traded it was because it started to smoke during use, it was smoking after startup for years, but began smoking all the time a couple of years ago and it just got worst to the point it was leaving a blue haze.

I know a lot of people like to rag on new equipment but I have to tell you my new Cub is every bit as good as the old one, if not better; the 2-cylinder engine runs very smooth and is much quieter, electric power steering, so it's not robing from the hydraulic pump, the old one had electric clutch engagement on the mower deck, the new one is vacuum operated and engages so much more smoothly without the jerk the old one use to do.

It was hard to let the old one go, but I couldn't be happier with the new Cub.

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

#8

Where are you located?

Dustmaker Mike

If you are close enough I could rebuild or replace the engine for ya for the cost of parts and a few more. I am in the Cleveland OH area. If you have a High School with a machine shop they might do it for parts just to learn how as well maybe a Vo Tech would do it.

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

#9

Re: Where are you located?

Gary Smyth

Right longitude (about) but in Southwestern PA, near Washington, PA. It's a bit of distance, but a straight shot up Interstate 79. Allow me to consider your generous offer a bit more. Going to the dealer today to see where I stand with timelines and what I can minimally do until I can make more permanent choices. Also attempting to make arrangements for cutting for the present and checking Craigs list for something that might get me through the time it will take until I decide how to get set -- at least spring and early summer. Thank you though. Perhaps we can talk in detail after Easter.

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

#10

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

PaulSV

I have a John Deere 140 of about the same vintage, with the same engine. (Kohler K321). It is a pretty easy engine to rebuild, with all the parts easily obtainable, and they seem to last forever. The same is true of the tractor. It is a great deal more solid and repairable than any tractor you will get today for less than about $5,000 or more. If the hydro drive unit is in good shape, and there are no other major problems with the tractor, I would go for the rebuild.

You might consider rebuilding it yourself. Take the motor out, tear it down, bring it to a machine shop to bore and hone the cylinder, have them check the crank, put in a new piston and rings, and rod if needed. While you have it off, re-build the carb. Should be able to do all that for under $500. Here is a John Deere site that has a lot of threads on rebuilding the 321. Look under Forums/Restoraion and Repair/Hydrostatic Drive Tractors, or do a search on K321.

http://www.weekendfreedommachines.com/

The Kohler rebuild manual is available free on-line, I think at Kohler's website. Google K-321 manual.

Another option is to buy and install a rebuild, or remove the otor and have it rebuilt. You could call and talk tho these guys:

http://kustomsmallengine.com/KOHLER-ENGINES-REMANUFACTURED_c4.htm

They sell rebuilt K321 short blocks for about $700

All that said, my Kohler has been burning a little oil since I got it 7 years ago, and it starts and runs perfectly every time, all year round. When I retire in the next five years, I'll rebuild it. Oh, and one other thought. If you are using a lot of oil, but don't see a lot of smoke, and can't find an obvious leak, take a look at the crankcase breather. They get dirty and blocked, and pressure builds in the crankcase, pushing a little oil out of various places, including the filler tube.

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

#11

Update

Gary Smyth

Cub Cadet 1450 update

Thanks to responders..

This AM I went to visit “old paint” at the dealer. The tractor was torn apart and the piston was available for viewing. I have to say that it is in trouble. There is a visible gap at the bottom of the stroke and while it is less apparent at the top, it is present none the less. Piston, rings, rod and possible crankshaft are in the future if I expect it back in form. I can’t afford the repair all at once. I told him to replace front and rear seals, install the “H” engine frame and change out the mounts. He will bring it back. I’ll have to switch from woodworking to tractor working this summer. Oh how I wished I would have been taught more about engines when I had the cash to make errors. In any case it will be a long haul. Much of what I planned with parts will wait until I can get at the basic engine. After that, I’ll do it glacially, bit by bit. Maybe it will keep me out of bad company and off the streets. As for now, I’ll check for someone to cut for a few weeks and look for something I can use to cut as a temporary replacement. Craigs list, estate sales here I come. By the way, the dealer thinks the bore might be as much as .030. Can an engine take it? I’m in new territory here. I've always liked adventure just didn't think it would be in a garage.

Re: OT Lawn Tractor

#13

Got that location.  Thanks