Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

Posts

A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#1

A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

Yonak

All Things Considered had a short piece on this technology. I really don't know much about it and have no connection to the company or David Butler, the creator. I understand it's method of stopping, in contrast to SawStop which uses a mechanical stopping mechanism, is to run DC power into the motor somehow to instantly stop the rotation.

For your perusal . . .


Whirlwind Tool Co.

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#2

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ?

Henry (Raleigh NC)

Looks like simple usage with a good blade guard.

I'd like to see more details! Price? Electrical requirements? Is this on the market already - or is this the preview to reality?

Henry

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#3

Re: not yet on market or priced

Henry (Raleigh NC)

I now see a few answers in their FAQs.

Not yet priced or on the market - but design appears to be "done."

Henry

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#4

Link *LINK*

Yonak

Here's a link to the story :


NPR

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#5

Re: Link

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

He is looking for an investor or licensee. He is not interested in marketing it himself- wise decision.

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#6

Looks like it might work on a bandsaw as well


Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#7

Promising

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Especially the retro-fit capacity. As I don't [yet] understand the "proximity" sensor, but it appears tied to the lights in the blade cover, I have to wonder if the presence of a coating of wood dust inside those hoods would degrade the ability. Also, does not seem to be able to prevent contact if the guard is high (thick stock) so that a hand can slide under the guard.

Bookmarked the site and will follow. Thanks for the heads up.

m

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ?

Jesper, Denmark

It's nice to see some competition to the Sawstop, but I think that 1/8th second to stop is not fast enough in my opinion.

Sensing with a proximity switch also seems questionable - how wil it differerentiate between your digits and other materials???

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#9

Re: Interesting, thanks, but no thanks


Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#10

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Fairly old technology - a similar method has been used for many years on brush type motors, I remember working on an electric lawn mower in the early 1960's (brush type motor) equipped with this style brake - as are all the CMS saws I have used.. When a ac/dc motor is rotating without power being fed to it - it becomes a dc generator. When the motor leads are shorted to each other (Normally a resistor is used between the leads to dissipate the heat and keep the motor from harm) the motor generates a magnetic field, braking the motor. The application of this type braking to AC has also been used in industry - but until recently has been expensive due to requiring a DC power supply. The cost of DC power supplies has been greatly reduced due to advances in solid state components. An alternate method of stopping rotation of industrial equipment has been used for many years - The electric clutch brake - The clutch brake has a movable plate that can be held either mechanically or via electromagnet against the rotating motor disc, when another electromagnet is actuated, the disc is pulled against a stationary plate, stopping the driven equipment rotation. Warner electric is one major brand of these units. These are quite fast but still require an actuation method such as a "touch sensor" or "Proximity sensor". However all the above methods do require some time to completely halt the rotating mass. The only way I would say the mass can be halted very quickly is with some "one shot" method of mechanically stopping the rotation. I do believe this could be done somewhere farther from the blade than the sawstop method. Possibly a cheap repairable/replaceable cartridge between the motor drive and the saw arbor. Another method might be that a replaceable cartridge be used to blow and drop the saw blade to a safe position where its rotation could not cause harm. This doesn't look like it would be an insurmountable design problem but would require somewhat major design changes to the drive train and possibly the saw enclosure.

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#11

Yeah, too restrictive

Yonak

Even considering what little I know about this device, I don't think it would work for me either. The blade guard is integral to its operation. I think the brake is triggered by a finger getting within a certain proximity of the blade guard, not the blade. That's what makes a 1/8 second lag acceptable, as compared to the SawStop's near instantaneous stoppage.

The problem I have is that I can't use a blade guard for most of my operations on the table saw so this black box would be inoperable most of the time.

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#12

Re: In a nut shell ...

Charlie Lenz

I'm not interested in any of this blade stoping stuff, no matter who makes it. Becareful what you wish for.

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#13

Momentum?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I don't get it. It cuts off the electrical feed? What about the momentum of the blade? Seems like you can do some damage before the blade really stops?

Tom

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#14

Re: Momentum?

John McGaw

Momentum, yes, but way less than you'd expect. What they are doing is removing the AC near-instantaneously (1/2 cycle or less?) and replacing it with a high DC current which effectively locks the motor. I'd expect that the motor might actually stop faster than the blade due to belt slip but it will be very quick.

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#15

Re: Momentum?

Henry (Raleigh NC)

There's way more momentum within a BS - as there's is so much more mass spinning on those BS wheels than in the arbor, pulleys and blade of a TS. I doubt the BS reaction times could be as fast as TS for that reason. However, they do show it applied to a BS.

Henry

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#16

Kneale Brownson

Re: In a nut shell ...

Kneale Brownson

At least this one wouldn't destroy the blade or itself.

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#17

I wonder about the blade spinning off.

Keith Newton

It seems to me, that if the motor stops fast enough, the inertia of the blade would spin the nut off, leaving the blade free to find its on destiny.

I know once a long time ago, while changing blades, I stopped to answer a phone call. Came back, and turned the saw on, while the nut was only about half way to the blade. The arbor rotation of course spun inside the nut, but when it got to the washer against the blade, it was hammered on so tight, that well,,,,,,,,,,,,, hammering the wrench was the only way I could break it loose.

Seems to me there is potential for braking the motor too quickly to have some adverse consequences. But they probably thought of that before jeopardizing the well being of that weenie.

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#18

Re: I wonder about the blade spinning off.

Barry Irby

My ancient B&D chop saw has the blade stop that uses the DC pulse built into it. Every once in a while it will spin the blade loose. It will actually make light cuts with the blade loose.

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#19

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ?

David Butler

Hello WoodCentral Folks,

I'm the "Whirlwind table saw safety guy," and was invited by Yonak to chat and maybe answer some questions here that you members might have. Ellis very kindly gave me permission to do so without turning this into a free commercial.

My goal has always been to have these issued and pending patents preferably assigned (i.e., sold) or alternatively licensed to established machinery manufacturers ASAP to offer other possible answers to help bring down the terrible accident record of consumer grade table saws and similar machines. My financial goal from this is short term and very modest.

If you folks are interested, I’ll check back and answer questions here or chat. Please remember, some technical information must remain proprietary pending commercial negotiations. I’ll check back soon. Nice forum!

David Butler

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#20

Questions

Yonak

David, one good question was asked by Keith Newton, whose message is just above yours, namely : When the motor comes to such a sudden stop after spinning at such high RPMs, is there any provision to keep the inertia from loosening the blade locking nut and continue the blade spinning free (as Keith aptly puts it, "to find its own destiny") ?

Also, is it true that your safety device activation is in the blade guard and, if the guard is removed, it would render your device inoperable ?

Thanks for coming by to clarify.

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#21

Re: Questions

David Butler

Yonak, let me answer in the reverse order.

Yes, the flesh-sensor is in the blade guard/enclosure. The sensor may be disabled with a supervisory key and the guard may then be left in place for dust collection and anti-kickback features. Or, the guard may be entirely removed and the saw operated in that manner. I strongly suggest with at least a riving knife. My design concept is that all the most dangerous operations can be done much more safely with the flesh-sensing guard in place. If the guard must be removed for a particular operation, it is probably to accommodate a large workpiece or assembly. In that case the operator has a much greater safety margin as the operator’s hands need not be placed dangerously close to the blade in those circumstances. I’ve built a lot of furniture and never found need for a tenoning jig and never saw one in four years of trade high school cabinetmaking. I mention this only because many have raised the "cannot use a tenoning jig" issue.

The arbor nut loosening is a multi-answer topic. I have experienced this happening and though it has not posed a safety issue, it needs to be dealt with. The simple solution is to add a second arbor nut and carefully tighten both arbor nuts separately. The second solution which I like is to employ a thread locking compound such as LOCTITE “271 High Strength.” Then if you wish, add the second nut for both a “belt & suspenders” approach. The locking compound takes some time to fully cure so be sure you do not trigger the blade brake before it cures. The inconvenience here is that it takes much more torque to later loosen the arbor nut with a wrench for blade changes, but I don’t change blades very often so it is not a problem I’ve found objectionable..

The third answer I’m working is a proprietary method suitable for solving the problem in newly manufactured machines and I encourage any budding inventors to also tackle this interesting problem.

I hope this helps a little. -- David

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#22

Re: Questions

Larry in nw ohio

Ever since the saw-stop came into being I have looked and looked at it, and one thing keeps nagging at me. I know there is a very simple answer to this thing and the answer is just starring me right in the face. When the saw stop is triggered, it drops at a terriffic speed, why does the blade have to have something ramed into it. I would think that since the blade is circular and as it drops the teeth are being placed at a farther distance away from the finger also. So the way I look at it, I don`t think the blade would need to be sacrificed. Would not the speed at which the blade drops and also the blade teeth are at a farther distance away giving it a little more time at getting away from the fingers. I would think the speed of the drop and the teeth getting farther away would be enough. What am I not seeing Thank You Larry

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#23

Behind the headlines *LINK*

Bob Lang

What you aren't seeing are the intricacies of US Patent Law and the dysfunction of the US Patent Office in recent years.

The device you describe, where the blade simply drops below the table to spin to a stop out of harm's way was developed by a joint venture of the Power Tool Institute, and awarded a patent a few years ago. However, Stephen Gass has been awarded so many patents on the SawStop (70+ and one was amended and awarded to cover the PTI technology after it was filed) that it is a major effort just to wade through them all, let alone bring any technology to market that is even remotely similar.

Gass has promised to fight any competing technology should another manufacturer bring it to market, citing the broad reach of his patent claims. If the CPSC decides to require "flesh-detecting technology" the rule could be referred to as "The Patent Attorneys Relief Act of 2012".

I've written way too much about this on the Popular Woodworking Magazine Editor's blog, you can find that by going to the blog and searching for "Table Saw Safety."

The link below goes to the Power Tool Institute's website for their side of the story.

I am not on either side of this issue, I'm just a reporter trying to cover this complicated and thorny issue. The sad part is that this has little to do with safety, and much to do with how much money is at stake, and who can get most of it while keeping their back sides covered. There aren't any good guys to side with.

Bob Lang


Power Tool Institute

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#24

Re: Questions

David Butler

Hi Larry,

(Sorry, my sketch didn't copy here, I'm a novice at forums).

This is my humble opinion of the SawStop and why it must “take out” the blade in protecting the operator. If you can visualize this sketch, I think you will have your answer. The blade doesn’t simply drop below the table by gravity, it driven below the table with great force and speed to prevent further injuring the operator who has contacted the blade. When the mechanism fires, it drives the sacrificial billet with great force into the blade, and forms a fulcrum point at the circumference of the blade around which the saw mechanism will force the blade below the table. The combined forces absorb the energy and bring the saw blade to a screaming fast stop. Ingenious!

Now let me explain that although we know and respect the SawStop guys we have no commercial affiliation. As I tell folks, SawStop is the “apples” and Whirlwind is the “oranges.” As we struggle to assign patents to industry, we don’t have any hardware products. If you or members here are concerned about your safety, particularly novices, I recommend you consider a SawStop. Though expensive, I believe it is a good investment in your safety and you will always be able to sell it after you have gained more experience and confidence using these machines.

David --

Re: A retrofittable alternative to SawStop ? *LINK*

#25

Re: Questions

Larry in nw ohio

Bob and David Thank you, I kind of understand, I think the sketch would have helped, it better. but it still escapes me. I`m very thick headed. Larry